flats or direct

v1rtFebruary 11, 2009

Good evening folks,

I have many annual seeds that I bought and others were given via seed exchange. I can't decide route I should take for the annuals. I was thinking to direct sow all my annuals. Just poke a hole, drop the seed, pot the seed, put a little dirt back, then mist. Or should I put them in flats after last frost then just transplant them?

I can't decide.

Please help. :)


Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
mxk3(Zone 6 SE MI)

Depends on what it is your sowing. If it's something like marigold, nasturtium, morning glory, something that doesn't take a long time from germination to flowering and doesn't require very warm soil temps, you can certainly direct sow. An annual that requires a longer time or needs very warm soil temps to germinate isn't a good candidate for direct sowing in your zone (e.g. impatiens, petunias, heliotrope, vinca, browallia) should be sown in flats and allowed to grow on in the flats prior to planting out date (info on when to plant will be on the seed packet).

Of course any of these can technically be direct sown but the problem is in the colder zones the ground doesn't warm up sufficiently in enough time to allow germination, plant growth, and subsequent flowering to enjoy the full season, the season will begin to wind-down before warm-lovers really get going. Obviously, this isn't an issue in warmer zones where the growing season is longer.

I am not familiar with the winter sowing method, so perhaps someone who sows that route may have differing information.

    Bookmark   February 12, 2009 at 7:04AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

I don't winter sow, but have looked at the forum and am constantly amazed at the phenomenal success with that method. And even though I have a large yard, I plan out what I can normally use effectively - without either discarding or giving away to a willing taker. Consequently, I buy my flats of annuals from a local Mom & Pop greenhouse that grows only annuals - they do all the work growing beautiful plants; I get to support a local business and have exactly what I want blooming all season.

Starting seeds indoors four to six weeks in advance of the usual Memorial Day earliest plant out date here in zone 4 has always been dismal for me personally. No problem getting seeds to germinate, but keeping them from getting leggy and damping off is a skill I haven't mastered. I'm sure that many people who start seeds indoors have the appropriate set up for doing so - the right exposure or grow lights; pretty much the same conditions a greenhouse would have; plus enough experience to know what works and what doesn't.

As for direct sowing, last season I had good success with zinnias, nasturtiums, and Bells of Ireland. Those were all I attempted.

I wouldn't be discouraged about seeds in any case though - if you have enough of each kind - sow some in flats to see how you do with them. Reserve the rest to direct sow. Attempting things is a good teaching tool, we've all pretty much learned by doing. Or head over to the winter sowing forum; this might be the time to start that in your zone to have nice sturdy plants to transplant when the time comes.

    Bookmark   February 13, 2009 at 11:07AM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
I picked up some caladium bulbs today -- am wondering...
we are doing a whole series of posts in the perennial...
ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5
"Bounce" and "Big Bounce" Impatiens are highly resistant to DM?
With the move to houzz I haven't been following very...
Best Garden worthy Sunflower?
I haven't found a Sunflower seed to purchase for this...
prairiemoon2 z6 MA
Best medium for starting seeds
In a previous thread I was advised to use a seed starting...
Sponsored Products
Flat Weave Tribal Gold/ Yellow Wool Area Rug (5' x 8')
MLCAN60LED50-BorW MaxLite LED Ceiling Light, 61 Watts
Waste Bin by Eva Solo
$297.50 | Lumens
Estiluz | Miris Elliptical Pendant Light
Coastal Cottage Perfect Yellow Table Lamp with White Linen Shade
$115.95 | Bellacor
Modernist Amis Bell Lamp White Medium
Original FUF Chair 6 ft. XL Comfort Suede Bean Bag Sofa - 0000176
$185.99 | Hayneedle
Pineapple Border Outdoor Rug
$39.00 | FRONTGATE
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™