Can I use 'dirt' instead of sand in making cement?

fossilnut(Z3-4, NE WA)August 20, 2006

I'm about ready to start making some rustic cement stairs (through our garden area)at our new lakefront cabin. I've got a pile of pebbles (left over from house renovation)and some portland cement but I don't have any sand. (nearest building supply place is 50 miles away!) Can I just use "dirt" instead of the sand? Thanks!

Sandy

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
Dena6355(z8 WA)

Sandy,
Dirt is a difficult one, unless it is sort of craggy. Dirt tends to be more 'rounded'. If you decide to use this also add pebbles or some crushed rock if you have it. Your stairs will likely be rustic and may not be durable for the long run, but fun for a little while.
Now about the rounded versus craggy. Cement is a 'dry glue' it does better if it has nooks and crags and sharp edges, as sand does to allow for it to adhere to all of the surfaces. After you have thoroughly mixed the dry ingredients, sand/cement/dirt etc then add water it hydrates the cement and bonds all the areas together. Dirt, dependent on where the area is tends to have more composted leaf and needle, and other organic material, bat, worm, slug, snake digested materials that as they decompose do not have sharp surfaces. The other difficulty with dirt is dependent on your area and either water run off or natural minerals in the soil you may find some area in your mix that 'harden' better than other, which could be decieiving.
But if you have a little extra dirt and some cement you can always try, if you have some saw dust and glue (Elmers, white, wood, or other) try adding that to your sample mix. If things are not anywhere set up in hmmm, say 6 hours, then I would not venture further with the stair idea.
Be creative,
Dena

    Bookmark   August 20, 2006 at 2:01PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
tango88(z8TX)

Certain types of "dirt" have been used successfully in making concrete, but unless you have an analysis done by a lab to confirm the usability, odds are it will fail. It all comes down to the chemical content and unfortumately most dirt does not measure up. Even if you run a test batch that looks good initially, you could encounter serious deterioration over a fairly short span of time simply due to the chemistry being wrong. Commercial concrete production is a highly controlled affair and even then contaminants (often from the surrounding soil) can wreck the mix.

Graded sand is cheap & reliable. Personally, I'd stick with known quantities...especially for something like stairs.

Best of luck --- Tango

    Bookmark   August 20, 2006 at 10:39PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
gemfire(z9/10 AZ)

I would make a small batch and test it out. They made adobe for years so who knows. Make a few bricks with it, let them cure real good and then try soaking them in some water and see if they stay together.

good luck and let us know how it goes.

    Bookmark   September 3, 2006 at 5:46AM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
New at Hypertufa
I am just getting started at doing hypertufa. I have...
cherbo
Response to 'Faux Bois Tools'...
You can use just about anything (and everything) you...
tango88
making EASY roof for small tower
I am not sure if i can even do this, but, I want to...
poaky1
Help with easy stepping stones
I want to make some stepping stones. I'm open to what...
harmonyfarms
Sand or no sand
This is one part of the various recipes that always...
ctquilter
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™