Grafting pyrus on....malus

zcabn(France)August 21, 2006


By accident (and chance?), I grafted a pyrus onto a malus sylvestris rootstock. 3 were made but only one succeeded. And the tree is growing normally. I read that such experience was impossible. Perhaps it will die in the next years, but I am curious to know if such experience was made and how long the graft lived.

Would like to know if there is a compatibility between mespilus and sorbus intermedia.

Thanks for your opinion

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo


I don't think you are going to get this kind of technical advice on the fruit and orchards forum. Grafting a pear to an apple rootstock has been done many times, and I understand that the results, when they survive, are short-lived. Whether medlar is compatible with mountain ash is a question to ask of a professional horticulturalist, although I don't know why it would make any difference to anyone except as a pure experiment.

Most of us here grow apples on apple rootstocks, and pears on pear or quince rootstocks. We grow fruit.

Don Yellman, Great Falls, VA

    Bookmark   August 21, 2006 at 9:15PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
joereal(Ca z9/SS z14)

I have winter banana apple growing vigorously on Bartlett Pear branch.

Todate, I have the following 5 species grafted together on one tree, with 9 cultivars, which I think is going to be a very decent growing fruiting tree:

Pyrus betulaefolia (rootstock)
Pyrus pyrifolia (Asian pear) - should bloom next year, vigorous growth
Pyrus communis (European pear) - should bloom next year, vigorous growth
2 cultivars of Malus domestica (Apples) - already fruiting
5 cultivars of Cydonia oblonga (Quinces) - all cultivars fruiting already.

IT IS NOT IMPOSSIBLE! Common sense is the key. If one rootstock can accomodate all the 4 species listed above, you can naturally have 4 species in one tree.

So if a certain rootstock can be used to graft apricots, peaches, nectarines, cherries, pluots, plums, apriums, plumcots peachcots, almonds, etc..., naturally, without even bothering with interstems, you can have all of these in one tree, perhaps as many as 12 species if you accept that the interspecific stone hybrids are different species.

I have grafted together 36 pears into one tree. 2 dozen cherries into one tree. 2 dozen apricots, perhaps 27 persimmons, more than 48 apples into one tree. All types of blood and pigmented oranges in one tree. I only have one tree which is not multi-grafted, and I use that for wine making, that is why I need to harvest at one time to make wine in big batch.

Todate, I have 50 citrus cultivars in one tree. But it doesn't mean I will have 50 times more yield. My total yield is the same as any ordinary tree of the same sized canopy, only the harvest dates are year round, quite manageable.

Practically I have all major types of citrus included todate into one tree. Bergamot, Sudachis, Yuzus, limes, lemons, grapefruits, pummelos, clementines, satsumas, tangerines (clementines, satsunas and tangerines are all mandarins) navels, valencias, kumquats, limequats, mandarinquats, grapefruit x pummelo hybrids, citrons, sweet oranges, blood oranges, acidless oranges, tangelos, orangelos, and most other hybrids all on one tree. I cannot agree on which major citrus types to follow honestly, as citrus naming is now thrown into chaos after it was discovered that most major commecial types are actually complex hybrids progenies of only three citrus species. These complex hybrids are propagated true to type in nature, fooling our taxonomic forefathers into believing that we have various distinct species, but not anymore, according to genetic tests. Anyway, whatever system of categories you have chosen, I practically have them on one tree, excepting only the microcitrus genera from Australia.

If I had just a couple acres of land, I won't bother multi-grafting, but as expensive as the city lots are, I simply have to fit 355 cultivars into 750 sq ft of soil. A couple acres of land, I could perhaps fit the entire germplasm if I don't take other time to enjoy life.

    Bookmark   August 22, 2006 at 4:33AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

As Joe indicated, there can be some fairly long-lived compatible combinations within the pomefruit species.
'Winter Banana' and 'Superclone' apples are well-documented to establish good, long-lived unions with many pear selections. Likewise, 'Fertility' pear is reputed to be quite compatible with many apple varieties.
I have both pear and quince(Cydonia) happily growing on native cockspur hawthorn(Crataegus crus-galli) understock, and understand that grafted selections of Amelanchier are often worked onto Crataegus rootstock.
A number of years ago, I purchased a bundle of 10 seedling P.communis rootstocks, which I lined out in my orchard, and grafted them all to named varieties of pear. Most 'took', but one rootstock 'refused' to accept a pear scion - I re-grafted this one three times that first year before I finally gave up - and once I allowed the rootstock to grow, it was immediately evident that it was an apple seedling. Subsequently, two other pears in this group of young trees began to show signs of decline over the next two to seven years, with rootstock suckers providing proof that they were, indeed, seedling apples, rather than pears. All of my 'pears on apple' are now gone, as the last one finally 'gave up the ghost' last year.

    Bookmark   August 22, 2006 at 1:00PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Thanks all; interesting.
My issue about mespilus is to find an understock that could increase the vigor to get a tree providing fruit with a good quality but more ornemental (higher). Perhaps Pyrus would be better
I graft mespilus on crataegus but would like to graft on sorbus intermedia if possible as I have young seedlings.

    Bookmark   August 22, 2006 at 1:43PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

For what it is worth, I have found both medlar and the sorbus group (mountain ash) to be pretty promiscuous. They will graft to alot of things that you would not suspect. And alot of suprising things can be grafted to them. So I say go for your proposed graft, do it to 10 or 2O seedlings so you don't inadvertantly grab the lone seedling that is going to reject such a graft. I have seen some seedlings reject all foreign grafts while others take and mend okay. So it does vary sometimes.

I have a Mountain Ash hybrid that is in its third year on a seedling apple, FYI. And not all sorbus' are inedible. Russia came up with a number of useful selections a coupla decades ago. I have seen selections that have fruit as large a golf balls, altho I do not have it in my collection.

Joe Real, I am interested in the betulaefolia multi-tree of yours. Did you let the betulaefolia go up to six feet, then start bark grafting to major limb stubbs?? How many years have the apples and quince been on it and what kind are they? Thanks in advance.

    Bookmark   August 24, 2006 at 11:05AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Hi all,
I live in Belgium (Europe)and I have a small nursery of about 2 HA(= 20000M2)where I grow all kinds of "edible landscaping" plants. I have quite some grafting experience and I can tell you that pear,apple,hawthorn,sorbus,amelanchier,cotoneaster,eriobotrya,mespilus and probably other members of the rose family can all be grafted onto each just depends on varietal affinity, some varieties will work well while other varieties of the same genus will's all a matter of trying and finding out what works and what does not...Commercially ofcourse this has no point whatsoever but it's great fun to experiment....
Perhaps the strangest grafting fact is this : In mexico a commonly used understock for apples and pears is the mexican hawthorn or tejocote(crataegus mexicana) strangely this understock will also happily accept any peach variety....try this one!
(prunus species are allways the odd ones out ,but not here)
Happy experimenting!
Dithmar Guillaume

    Bookmark   November 22, 2006 at 3:55PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
tampopo(z6 Ohio)

Hi, I'm NOT the expert, I'm a relative newbie, but can say for a fact that medlar (at least the little round brown ones) can be grafted onto a quince tree for a bit of height. I know because my late uncle had some like that.

    Bookmark   November 25, 2006 at 1:20PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Joe Wrote:
Todate, I have the following 5 species grafted together on one tree, with 9 cultivars, which I think is going to be a very decent growing fruiting tree:

Pyrus betulaefolia (rootstock)
Pyrus pyrifolia (Asian pear) - should bloom next year, vigorous growth
Pyrus communis (European pear) - should bloom next year, vigorous growth
2 cultivars of Malus domestica (Apples) - already fruiting
5 cultivars of Cydonia oblonga (Quinces) - all cultivars fruiting already.
Joe, what are the quinces grafted to on that tree?

    Bookmark   March 22, 2007 at 4:42PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
joereal(Ca z9/SS z14)

Quinces: Pineapple, Portugal, Smyrna, Champagne, Mideastern seedling (no formal name yet), Aromatnaya (recent).

This year I have grafted 10 more cultivars. Can't remember what they are exactly, but I added another quince, 3 apples, 4 European pears, 2 Asian Pears, and another one which the label was blown away, the tree is 30 miles away from me at the moment.

    Bookmark   March 22, 2007 at 5:14PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Murky, I am betting he is able to graft quince directly to the betulaefolia stock. Joe has never revealed his secret!

    Bookmark   March 23, 2007 at 2:56AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

With regard to medlars, I usually graft these onto pear rootstock. Joseph Postman from the USDA in Corvallis had originally suggested that I follow this however by planting with the soil above the graft union to encourage the medlar to put out it's own roots and improve vigor. This appears to work well with them.
The ability of plants to graft compatibly to other species is dependent on their isoperoxidase make-up in the tissue. As long as the two plants have profiles that overlap sufficiently you'll have a compatible match. As the profiles overlap less, you'll see increasing rates of graft decline or outright failure. Apple varieties such as Winter Banana and Northern Spy are quite well known for having a broad spectrum of compatability as does the pear variety Beurre Hardy. For this reason, they are commonly used as interstem grafts. If you were to dig around in some of the technical texts for botanical biochemistry you could probably find additional information on the isoperoxidase spectra of different plants.

    Bookmark   March 23, 2007 at 9:21AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
Sunrise Vineyards(6 (Western NY))

In the spring of 2012, I attempted to graft a Pear scion onto my apple tree using Winter Banana Apple as an inter stem.
(All of he grafting i do is "Whip and Tongue" grafts wrapped in grafting tape. I then coat the wrapped union with grafting wax)

The parent branch was a Winesap Apple branch with a grafted Winter Banana Apple scion from a few years before.
(I actually have two of these paired branches.)
I then attempted to graft two "Kieffer" Pear scions onto my two Winter Banana Apple inter stems. The "Kieffer" Pear scions started to grow, but died a few weeks later.

This spring (2014) I attempted to graft this Apple / Pear union again using the same Winter Banana Apple inter stems. I had just enough branch on my Winter Banana branches to try this experiment one more time. This time around, I used "Sunrise Pear" scionwood.
The grafting was a screaming success! (I had enough "Sunrise Pear" scionwood to graft two branches onto my apple tree, and two more onto an ornamental pear. All four pear grafts were a success!)

I have no idea why this experiment failed in 2012 and was a success in 2014. I do not know if it had to do with the pear variety used, or if it had to do with environmental circumstances. I will re-post in 2015 with an update.

There are a few different treads on this subject so I will be re-posting on those threats also.

Below are pictures taken on 07/27/2014.

    Bookmark   July 29, 2014 at 11:04PM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Shaping and pruning some BYOC trees
In January I planted two peaches and two pears, intending...
Confused about grape vine spraying
I'm getting overwhelmed trying to figure this out on...
DandyLioness (CA 9, SZ 14)
Blueberry help!
What's going on with this blueberry bush? Is it going...
Water and other issues with young peach tree
I have a peach tree that was transplanted last spring...
My Spupreme plum turns into Alderman!
At Plant Hill Nursery! They don't have a email address,...
Sponsored Products
Masiero Lighting | Drylight Outdoor Wall Sconce
$680.00 | YLighting
Masiero Lighting | Drylight 12 Light Outdoor Chandelier
Felco Bypass Pruning Saw - P95G V39060
$23.97 | Hayneedle
Masiero Lighting | Drylight 24 Light Outdoor Chandelier
Masiero Lighting | Drylight 6 Light Outdoor Chandelier
Masiero Lighting | Drylight 18 Light Outdoor Chandelier
Silver Two-Piece Angel Figurine Set
$54.99 | zulily
Masiero Lighting | Drylight Outdoor Table Lamp
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™