Round Up vs Vinegar

dian57(M-H Valley NY-5)May 22, 2011

I have a handwritten note in my garden records that says Organic Round Up alternative--20% vinegar.

Although I don't recall the origin of this recipe, I do remember going to every Agway and store around me looking for 20% vinegar without success.

A few questions:

Does it work?

Is readily available 5% effective, even if it takes longer and more applications?

Would boiling down the 5% produce a 20% concentration?

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
morz8(Washington Coast Z8b)

Dian, 20% vinegar, if you could find it, is quite caustic and there is some danger to the applicator involved.

As far as I know, boiling vinegar does not increase the acidity - at least the ph doesn't change when using it in pressure canned recipes and canning where acidity can be paramount :)

If you use regular 5% vinegar as a weed spray it will kill minor weeds, especially if sprayed on a sunny afternoon (as opposed to a shady morning or evening). It will quickly kill top growth, and may not have a lasting effect on tap rooted weeds like dandelions. Unlike Roundup, it doesn't have a systemic action, meaning it is not taken down into the roots to kill at that level.

    Bookmark   May 22, 2011 at 3:33PM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
barrier for plants with invasive roots
What have you used in the ground to prevent invasive...
taterbug
why do seeds that are already covered with dirt have to be germin
This is more one of those, "But...WHY?" types...
conjuay
Natural way to get rid of ANTS???
Hello - I haven't seen Ants around in years but some...
CapeHeart
How do you get the gardening information that you need?
Hi everyone! I'm new to gardenweb, Houzz, whatever...but...
tanya117
New Gardener with three raised beds
I just created 3 raised beds but do not have anything...
Redwigglerwarrior
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™