Help settle a marital dispute about a pit greenhouse idea :)

stockelc66(4)July 17, 2014

I'm a newbie to posting here but have gotten a lot of good information over the years by reading others' posts so I'm hoping to get some good advice and ideas.

I have been doing a lot of research online as I prepare to talk hubby into building a greenhouse. My main goals are to extend my Wisconsin growing season by a few months and have a place to overwinter a few things that aren't reliably hardy in my zone (4).

I think a pit greenhouse would meet those needs the best for me with the least amount of cost in the long term - mostly heating costs in the winter. I have read a lot of good information online and plan to also order some books that have been recommended.

Here's where the marital dispute arises. Hubby is all on board with the idea and we do have plenty of room to build a typical pit greenhouse as well as loaders, etc for the hard digging so that isn't the issue. I would like to use an old block milkhouse that is already on the property as the "pit". The plan would be to bring soil (as well a possibly broken up concrete, etc) to cover the walls and berm up the north side after adding to it. This would save a lot of the cost of new blocks plus the hard work of digging and setting blocks would be mostly done. So, rather than dig down we would be creating a hill around the structure already there. (maybe even in a hugelkultur type process to grow on) In addition to the greenhouse part we could also plan a root cellar area where the door is to the barn (which is no longer there)
The milkhouse is about 14 x 14 with 6 foot block walls. it has a drain in the floor. The tin roof would probably need to be completely replaced as it is oriented facing east / west. We so have some salvaged double pane windows we could possibly use. From what I have read I think the angle of the windows would be about 60 degrees as we are about 45 degrees latitude.

Hubby's concerns are:
1) the amount of dirt that would need to be brought in to cover the whole thing. Although we live on a farm...seems like plenty of dirt around here to me :)

2) would we also need to have windows extending up some on the south side wall?..I think with a 6ft depth that that wouldn't really be needed

3) Would this even work? A lot of work for nothing if it doesn't.

I know he would be swayed a little if we could do some aquaponics, chickens, etc as well but that is not my primary concern.

Haas anyone done this? I haven't been able to find anything about repurposing a structure other than a concrete swimming pool or using the side of a structure.

What other considerations should I be thinking of? Is this even feasible?

Any advice or suggestions would be appreciated.

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Do both,dig pit,take that soil and use on the milk house,pit is going to be more heat saving,than milk house in my opinion.

    Bookmark   July 18, 2014 at 10:19AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

With regard to the heat saving, how much difference would you anticipate? I was thinking that with the milk house being 6-7 ft underground relative to the surface (once it is backfilled with soil) and being bigger it would have a more stable temperature compared to digging down 4-6 ft with a pit.
I would love to try both but that might be a difficult sell :) It would make for a good experiment, though. We would still need to bring in soil to berm both of the north sides so hubby might not go for it as it would make more work for him and expense than I already have planned - lol
Thank you for your input. It's good to have different points of view as I'm considering such a big project.

    Bookmark   July 18, 2014 at 9:55PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
sturgeonguy(5a ON)

FWIW, I would be very surprised if you could use the milkhouse with the ouside walls covered up to 6' in dirt piled against them.

Buildings are constructed to withstand blow-out, not cave-in. Basements are designed for cave-in, not blow-out. Of primary concern would be the buildings footings, but equally the thickness of the walls and whatever ceiling cross-bracing is in place. Consider the snow-load on the roof, as it won't be able to shed off as it did before if you get 2' of snow on the ground at the eaves.

Assuming you piled dirt up to the top of the 6' wall, you will end up using nearly twice as much dirt as you would have to remove to create a 16'x16'x6' deep pit. So consider that.


    Bookmark   July 19, 2014 at 4:38PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

I think the cave-in aspect should be considered. It was not designed for this type of use, and I doubt if it could be easily retrofitted to assure safety. You can't just heap on soil and assume it won't fail, unless you are an engineer and have crunched the data on it.

    Bookmark   August 20, 2014 at 7:19PM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
What are considered warm and cool weather plants for...
Tempered Glass Panels for Greenhouse?
I have talked my DH into building me a Greenhouse.. I...
temp in your greenhouse, and temp/weather outside, right now?
I'm curious as to what kind of passive solar gain you...
High hoop greenhouse
Wondering how many of you are growing in hoop houses?...
watering pugs
Watering plugs...better from the top or the bottom
Sponsored Products
Linon Morocco 30 in. Bar Stool - Lava - 0226LAV01U
$143.99 | Hayneedle
Hang Pendant by Moooi
$535.00 | Lumens
Justice Design Group GLA-8911 - Capellini 1 Light Wall Sconce - Bowl with Ripple
$290.00 | Hayneedle
Quoizel Adrienne Q611T Table Lamp - Q611T
$279.99 | Hayneedle
Outdoor Corner Chair with Cushions
Grandin Road
Shires Equestrian Waterford Full Cheek Bit - 572-5
$25.99 | Hayneedle
MR Direct 921 Single Bowl Oval Copper Sink
Heavy Metal Table Lamp by Diesel by Foscarini
$1,355.00 | Lumens
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™