AVSA Scale of Points

minimac(6 So In. Louisville Ky)September 12, 2010

Hi All,

I was looking in my Growing to Show book on the check-list of what the judges look for in a show plant. In there it has for example symmetry - 25 points, condition - 25 pts. and so on, but what would really be helpful for me to know is the points judges take off for say smaller leaves below large leaves or to perhaps leave on a slightly damaged leaf. How many points are taken off for each?

Under condition it asks "Have all damaged leaves been removed? (If a damaged leaf affects symmetry, consider the option of leaving it vs. removing it." Guess I need to know my options. LOL

Any help here would be greatly appreciated.

Mac

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
robitaillenancy1(zone 5)

The Growing to Show book is probably the best book you can buy on AVs.

For those baby leaves, smaller rounded leaves under the larger leaves, judges can take off up to 3 points, for each. Some judges would be lenient and take off only one point or two just to help you out. So those baby leaves really are very important to remove.

You may have a damaged leaf or one marked in some way. You could remove it, but it may leave a hole in the symmetry, so it might be worth the lesser points being taken off. A speck of dirt or hole in leaf, or crack or some sort of damage on the leaf--depending on the size and the judge would be from about half a point to a point for each piece of soil, or damage. A missing leaf in the symmetry would mean many more points taken off, possibly up to three points.

A judge can be lenient or very tough. If the show is full of perfect, beautifully grown plants, he/she may judge with full points taken off.

Nancy

    Bookmark   September 13, 2010 at 12:23PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
fred_hill(6)

HI Mac,
As Nancy explained a judge may deduct points for many things. I personally deduct a point for each secondary leaf and maybe a half point for marred leaves. Most points have deductions for condition and these are more severe than any of the others, under condition I deduct points for secondary leaves and dirt etc. There are things that can be controlled by the grower so they should be corrected before judging.
Fred in NJ
A good source for knowing what can be deducted is the AVSA Handbook for growers and ju dges
. Fredin NJ

    Bookmark   September 22, 2010 at 10:54PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
minimac(6 So In. Louisville Ky)

Thanks for your replies. I entered the Ohio State Show Sept. 16-19, and wasn't sure about a couple of plants. Had a Bob Serbin with three discolored (older) leaves on outer edge. I left them on till I got there. I wasn't confident enough to take them off. My violet mentor extraordinaire who is also a judge told me "never, never leave leaves like those on!" After they came off the gaps weren't so bad. Whew!

I now have an AVSA Handbook. You're right Fred, just what I needed. It will be especially useful in calculating point deductions for my "next" collection class.

THANKS!
Mac

    Bookmark   September 29, 2010 at 8:23PM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Give me your best yellow violet
Looking to brighten up my pinks and purples. What...
Tally
Violet ID?
Hi Y'all! I was curious what these violets would be?...
suyoder
Newbie at AV
I rescued this AV a few months ago, it was pretty sad...
loveofbostons
NOID single blue thumbprint
just got at HD. similar variegation on both, except...
petrushka
Nice vendor
Today I received an order from Fancy Bloomers in NJ. She,Donna,...
fortyseven_gw
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™