Williams was not cold tolerant!!

asacommMarch 12, 2007

Hi Banana Friends!

Despite I believed that Musa Williams was one of the cold-

hardy bananas, it could not overwinter in the ground even

with the cold protection of wrapping by mats of vegetable

materials. The pseudostem and the rhizome were rotten.

For your information, the lowest tempratures of this winter

were as follows:

Nov. 58F, Dec. 29F, Jan. 30F, Feb. 27F, Mar.sofar30F

On the hand,Rajapuri overwintered perfectly in the same

ground and with the same protection.


Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
laterita(7b Holland (dr))

I don't trust any cavendish below 12C (53F)
Now you know why.

    Bookmark   March 20, 2007 at 7:19PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Hello Simon,

You are one of the rare dutch visitors to this forum, and
I do understand why you don't trust any cavendish below

On the other hand, however, it is interesting to serch
edible species that could grow even in the marginal areas,
and in fact I am growing several bananas inluding Rajapuri,
Dwarf Orinoco, Helen's hybrid, King banana, Williams and
some cavendishes, among which Rajapuri is so far cold
strongest. Musa Basjoo and Sikkimensis are in this case
exceptional as they are always strong enough.

Can you show us what you are growing and what are your



    Bookmark   March 21, 2007 at 3:43AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo


How would this Williams do in somewhere like Kalgoorlie where we do get a heck of a lot of heat but does drop to -2C in winter on a few nights?

    Bookmark   March 26, 2007 at 9:47AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
laterita(7b Holland (dr))

Sorry for this late answer.
The trouble with our region is a long wet winter. For a banana a bit of cold is no problem but the amount of water is the trouble here. Most of the plants are killed by too much water or a fungus because of wet conditions.

I moved from the coldest region in Holland to a warmer region. (7b to 8a USDA) But because of gardenweb doesn't recognise a dutch zip-code, I cannot change my profile any more.

About your question:
I have the "normal" bananas for a colder region:
basjoo, sikkimensis, velutina, itinerans, ensete's, Musella Lasiocarpa etc.
And some fruiting species: Dwarf Orinoco, Namwah, Manzano, French Horn, FHIA 23 and 25 and a Grand Naine. The last 3 I overwinter inside my house.
I lost a FHIA 18, Pitogo ans a Zan Moreno due to a grey mold this winter.
The Namwah and Dwarf Orinoco are the strongest here to survive, if you dig them up and store away at ca 5-10 degrees C.

    Bookmark   April 5, 2007 at 6:01PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Thanks Simon,

As I had been in Duesseldorf, Germany for some periods, I
do understand the winter situation there in the northern
parts of Europe.

Not only growing them purely as ornamental, but also with
the purpose of freuiting bananas, it would be considerably
difficult, but I think there should be the ways.
For instance, dwarf species can easily be taken into the
house in the winter time to keep them comfortable
conditions enough to prepare blooming in the coming spring.
This is in fact one of the ways I adopted here and it did
work well.


    Bookmark   April 6, 2007 at 4:53AM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
First Year End Red Esente
This is the first year of growing Bananas (Red Esente)...
Banana plant is dying, what is wrong?
Hello all! I bought this banana plant a couple of months...
What size container to transplant into
I just purchased an unknown banana plant (labeled Musa...
Prepping the soil for banana plants
Hello, I have a nice space for about 2-3 dwarf Apple...
Banana Palm uprooted in winds!
How can I save it???
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™