Ghost Gum vs Mesquite for edge of lot

greyongrayMay 8, 2012

I'm going to be planting 2-3 trees on the west side of my lot and I've spent months trying to make a good choice of specie.

The trees are going to border a horseback riding arena, and so what I really want is to be able to shade as as much as possible (ie tall tree). Prefer xeriscape to tropical, filtered shade is fine.

The problem is that right on the other side of the fence is my neighbor's pool and concrete deck.

I'm leaning towards the Crown Jewel mesquite (seedless hybrid) which would give me some shade but also peace of mind around the pool. It may not be litter free but neighbor has his own Chilean mesquite to clean up after so they would probably be on the same schedule.

I love the look of the Ghost Gum though (papuana), anyone have experience with those - how messy, concrete crackers, etc? Help me decide so I can go get my trees already :)

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
tomatofreak(Z9 Phx USA)

RUN from the Ghost Gum! Go get the mesquites! How I wish I had gotten the mesquites - or just about anything other than the eucs I did get. They are messy, refuse to live up to your idea of how they should grow and are almost impossible to prune once they reach mature height. I am seriously considering taking one out and replacing it with - ta da! - a mesquite. I so regret getting these trees.

    Bookmark   May 8, 2012 at 7:21PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
greyongray

Thanks Tomatofreak, you are the voice of reason that I needed :)

There are mature eucs in my neighborhood (probably the older, brittler, messier kinds) and I think I will just continue to enjoy them from the walking paths/little trails, and the ghost gums planted by ADOT! Beautiful white trunks and I was trying to block out the expensive pruning they would surely need.

    Bookmark   May 9, 2012 at 1:34PM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
drumstick tree
I was reading old posts and this tree sounds great. I...
calb_gardner
April 2015 what looks good/bad/awful in your garden?
Hi everyone, happy April! I don't know about you,...
grant_in_arizona
Yaupon Holly
Someone reccomended yaupon holly as a good substitute...
colinhanke
Palo Verde (Desert Museum) - Bends Over like Willow - Pruning?
My son lives west of Phoenix and had a Palo Verde planted...
elaineindy
Water Softener
I'm going to install a new water softener to replace...
newtoucan
Sponsored Products
Feiss Aveline 15 3/4" High Brushed Steel Wall Sconce
Lamps Plus
Winter Wind Canvas Wall Art by Megan Duncanson - 30W x 16.5H in. - ART012HN
$81.87 | Hayneedle
Kartell | Lou Lou Ghost Child's Chair
$150.00 | YLighting
Blue Vessel Artwork
Grandin Road
Nova Amarillo Ghost White Floor Lamp
Lamps Plus
Wingback Cream Queen Size Upholstered Bed
Overstock.com
Ghost Bioethanol Fireplace
FRONTGATE
Ghost Style Arm Chair
IFN Modern
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™