both epigeal and hypogeal germ. w/in a single species??

adidas(6/7)June 6, 2013

I am puzzled. Last yr. I collected a large number of spicebush (Lindera benzoin) seeds from shrubs in the area (I'm in northern VA, Appalachians). Some of them germinated w/out stratification and they all germinated epigeally, w/primary leaves appearing above the soil. Now, the second lot germinated in the spring after having been wintersowed outside all winter. A few are epigeal w/primary leaves above the soil, but most of these specimens have germinated hypogeally like peas w/the cotyledon below the soil and no primary leaves. How can there be hypo and epi germination w/in a species?

I have googled 'til the cows came home w/no luck.

Thanks for any input!

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
brandon7 TN_zone(7)

I noticed that this post has gone unanswered (at least on GardenWeb) for quite a while. I think the answer that Michael F, on the UBC site, gave may be as good as any that I am aware of. For anyone wondering, Michael's post concluded with, "...the distinction between epigeal and hypogeal is less absolute than one might think."

    Bookmark   February 18, 2014 at 10:17AM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
The Tetragonostachys of the USA
Interested in the Tetragonostachys? While often seen...
Changes in Flowering Time
Hello! I'm a postdoc at Harvard, studying flowering...
What are they?
Hi gardeners, I just went to empty the scrap bucket...
Name this flower
Found this flower growing up on my fence behind some...
A Question about hybrid vegatable seeds...
Hello all. I feel that this is very basic and that...
Sponsored Products
5-inch Recessed Trim Clear Reflector BR30/ PAR30 Ceiling Light
Robin Outdoor Patio Lounge Chair in Espresso White
$599.00 | LexMod
Yellow Origami Boat Serving Dish
$12.99 | zulily
NX-812 LED Edge-Lit Exit Sign with Adjustable Housing, Battery Backup - Single F
LBC Lighting
Floral Red-Black Border Heriz 3''x21' Serapi Hand Knotted Wool Runner Rug H5500
BH Sun Inc
WAC Logos 24 Degree Black 23W LED Track Head for Lightolier
Euro Style Lighting
Weave LED Tall Wall Sconce by Maxim Lighting
$274.00 | Lumens
Hopson Leather Single Arm Chaise - Brighton Aubergine Purple
Joybird Furniture
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™