Looking for a great red Tomato

northerner_on(Z5A ONCanada)September 29, 2010

Hello friends: I am in the market for a red tomato to grow, which will give me a crop before the snow flies, which tastes like a good old-fashioned tomato (not too sweet) and which is quite productive (I'm not asking for much). This year I tried Sub Arctic Plenty and firstly, the fruit are too small (hardly a slicer); the taste was not great; as a determinant, it was extremely low growing which exposed many of the toms. to slugs which I have lot of; it was early but sporadic e.g. I still have lots on the plants. I have tried many red toms. in past years, some with tinges of black or green, but the family did not like them (although some of them were rather tasty). I have grown, for the second year a yellow slicer (Livingston's Golden Queen) which I like, I also grow Bull Heart but that is really a paste tomato (but my family likes that in salads). So any sugggestions please? Thank you. I live in Ontario, Zone 5A.

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
oilpainter(3)

There is no tomato that will give you a crop before the snow flies in zone 5 in Ontario, unless you have a heated greenhouse to grow them in.

Subartic is the fastest growing tomato that matures in 48 days from the time you set it out. That means you need about 2 months of warm or hot weather to get them to the fruiting stage. Even if there was the time, there is still the issue of shorter days with cool weather

    Bookmark   September 30, 2010 at 3:22AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
northerner_on(Z5A ONCanada)

Thanks Oilpainter. I do get tomatoes as early as mid-August because I start my plants indoors under lights in April. By the time I plant them out they are good-sized, healthy plants. I have never had success winter sowing tomatoes, but just last week, I had a ripe tomato on a 'volunteer' plant from last year's Livingston's Golden Queen. I did try Sub Arctic Plenty this year, but I am not a fan. The first ripe fruit were on August 11, but they are too small and not as tasty as I expected. I posted this question on the Tomato forum and have lots of suggestions which I will mull over during the winter. Enjoy the Fall.

    Bookmark   October 2, 2010 at 4:48AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
DrHorticulture_(Z3 Central Saskatchewan)

I get Subarctic Plenty producing reliably well in Saskatoon, and compared to Saskatoon, zone 5 Ontario is a tropical sauna. In fact, my wife and I would like to move there to get away from this province with cold, unpredictable summers. All kinds of cherry tomatoes also do well here. Having never grown slicer tomatoes, I can't help you there, but yes a greenhouse will help for the cultivars that are more finicky. Just make sure it can be cooled (ventilated) well in your hot summers.
Sorry, I just find it funny when Ontarians complain about their growing season! You guys have it EASY.

    Bookmark   October 3, 2010 at 12:10AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
oilpainter(3)

Hey dr horticulture--That's a big whoops. You don't want to reserect that whole Ontario versus the prairies battle.

For a prairie Canadian you should know not to lump all one province into the same growing zone. Did you forget about northern Ontario.

We grow slicers and you can too. Just look for those which have a fast maturity date. Applause( a new one for us this year and one I will be ordering again) has a maturity date of 66 days. Some are even earlier. I think that's close to your cherry tomatoes. If frost threatens then pick then green. We put the green ones in 6 quart baskets about 3/4 full in the basement and they ripen just fine without losing their taste. You do have to sort through them every couple of days, but that works for me.

If you don't get it already I suggest you order T+T seeds catalogue--you can do it on line. They're in Winnipeg and have a lot of varieties of flowers and veggies bred for the prairies

    Bookmark   October 3, 2010 at 1:34AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
DrHorticulture_(Z3 Central Saskatchewan)

hey oilpainter,

Thanks for the suggestions. I will look up T+T for next year.
No I didn't forget northern Ontario - I think you folks have it even worse than in the Prairies, sometimes. I was just referring to the Toronto-Ottawa-Mtl banana belt where people have never experienced the misery of a July frost, or a summer where half the nights can't crack 10 degrees :( It is the greatest myth that the Prairies have hot summers...only localized areas do, like around Medicine Hat.

    Bookmark   October 3, 2010 at 12:58PM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Online irrigation stores?
I've posted a similar message on the irrigation forum....
Sherwood Botsford
Help me kill the Goutweed (Aegopodium)
Further to the post regarding the sale of goutweed: Please...
vicki_vale
Looking for a Scuffle Hoe
Hello everyone: The new anti-pesticide laws have my...
northerner_on
Charisma Lilac
I bought and planted two Charisma lilacs in May 2010....
Mary.13
weed or no weed?
approx 4 ft tall any info appreciated
ralu25
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™