experience with activated charcoal?

colopatironAugust 1, 2008

I just moved to a place where my c.p.'s look like they're suffering from soil toxins. They have to catch roof run-off and maybe even run-off from an upper balcony when it rains. It's the only place they can get enough sun. Anybody ever put activated charcoal on top of the soil of their C.P.'s? Wouldn't it help purify water that drips past it? I know in the wild most of them grow in areas where flash-fires are necessary for the ecosystem. i wonder why all C.P. soil mixes don't recommend charcoal? Something I'm missing?

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
hunterkiller03(9)

You probably know by the lack of response that no one has experimented using charcoal. The most its been used is to put a layer of it on the bottom of a terrarium to keep the water collected from getting too stale.

There was a grower in Wisconsin that experimented fire burning on his pots of Sarracenia x moorie but I have been unable to locate his website.

Some growers use charcoal as part of their Nep soil mix. So some people say it works but others like Barry Rice, author of "Growing Carnivorous Plants" advices not to. In his experience it seems Nep's roots avoid growing and spreading to where charcoal is present.

So maybe you can experiment yourself using charcoal and post your results.

Sorry I don't have anything else to add.

Good luck.

    Bookmark   August 12, 2008 at 1:21AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
DNewton

The best I've used is Biogize-SD which is available on Amazon under 'soil detox'. They have an easy mix and apply bottle which I just run through my hose-end-sprayer. But they also sell it in bulk (40lb box). I'm convinced my tomato plants were suffering from herbicides big-time until I treated them with the AC. They revived nicely.

    Bookmark   July 13, 2012 at 12:58PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
RainforestGuy

If your soil is the problem, CHANGE IT! Why add something that will just modify the problem when a total change will resolve the problem and the plant and go on growing i=without interruption.
Most Nepenthes grow in media that may be organic or even limestone based. Charcoal would be best for those subject to fires and burning which should recover quickly from ash build up.
The use of coco peat/bark is good but this breaks down too rapidly that they will require a soil amendment. I recommend the use of pumice when using coco peat products and also orchid fine to medium bark.
But as they break down, amend it by adding a media with these components to give it good air circulation.

    Bookmark   July 15, 2012 at 5:28PM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Miracle Gro
:/ sigh Miracle Gro..... so it seems that this stuff...
ermaclob
Nelenthes 5 basal shoots on 1 plant!
My newish nepenthes, not sure what kind since it was...
mora2817
Artificial lighting for Sarracenia?
I lived in Zone 10 (San Francisco) and moved from a...
rms9004
Can dead sphagnum turn into live sphagnum?
I'm noticing some green patches in my LFS. Is it live...
outsiders71
What would you call the crown jewels of the CP world?
OK, I read recently a great topic of what's my favorite...
jonocross
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™