Root competition damage -- after 6 years

butterclem(z6 W.PA)April 18, 2013

I have four clematises under an arbor. I put them there 6 years ago and fronted them with dwarf deutzia Nikko. The combination was lovely, but last year I noticed I had fewer stems on the clematis and many fewer new green stems. I guess I lived in denial for a year, but now I need to get my clems healthy. The ones in question are Margaret Hunt, Etoile Violette, and Ascotiensis (Beata was planted there in the fall but didn't come up -- maybe not hardy?? -- but that's a different issue). Etoile Violette looks the worst. Ascotiensis is battling back the best and doesn't seem too bad.

There are three questions here, I guess:
1. Do you agree the deutzia is the likely culprit?
2. If I rip it out, what are replacement candidates (phlox subulata, dianthus, epimedium, tiarella??)
3. Should I rip all the clematises but Ascotiensis out, too, and start over? It's hard to imagine Etoile Violette putting forth enough stems to make a show for a long time. On the other hand, do the existing plants stand as good or better chance than new clematises?

I should mention that I have a half dozen other viticellas in other parts of the garden, and they're doing fine. Some of them have some root competition because they're growing up a tree or a shrub, but I guess I was more careful with my distances there. Also, I have dozens of integrifolias growing on shrubs and small tuteurs all over the place with never a thought to root competition, and they are all glorious.

But the arbor isn't. I have to change it. Input would be appreciated.

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
buyorsell888(Zone 8 Portland OR)

In my own garden, compacted clay soil that was not properly dug and amended has been worse for my clematis than root competition though to be truthful, some of those spots weren't properly dug and amended because of arborvitae and Douglas fir roots....

Those that I just hacked out holes for still struggle even ten years down the road than those that went into established beds that were originally rototilled and amended.

    Bookmark   April 20, 2013 at 8:19PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Without seeing the situation firsthand, I can't say for certain but I highly doubt the Nikkos are the problem. They are just too small a shrub to offer any significant root competition. The vast majority of clematis at my old garden were planted to scramble up various shrubs and trees (so quite close to the base of the plants) and virtually without exception root competition from the shrubs and trees was never an issue.

Like BorS, my first inclination would be that the planting hole was not as adequately prepared as would be preferred. I'd prune the vines back hard, apply some alfalfa meal to the root zone and mulch well with a high quality organic mulch - compost would be my preference. In addition to being an organic fertilizer, the alfalfa meal will stimulate basal growth or the development of new stems from the root grown.

    Bookmark   April 21, 2013 at 2:49PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
butterclem(z6 W.PA)


These planting holes were really well prepared and, I think, are well maintained. Holes were dug at least 2 ft. deep and filled with a mix of composted manure, peat moss, bone meal and the upper part of the original soil. Clematises are pruned back hard every spring, dressed with composted manure every spring and every fall, and fed Epsoma rose fertilizer every two weeks they are not in bloom. I also give them seaweed fertilizer from time to time. Clematises in other parts of my garden, not fronted with deutzia, thrive with this preparation and maintenance.

But buyorsell brings up an interesting point: the difference in performance between clematises planted in a meticulously prepared hole in an uncultivated bed and others in identical holes in thoroughly cultivated beds. I have done a tour of my property since receiving that email, and indeed the clematises I planted within perennial borders (usually on a tuteur) are wonderful specimens about which I have no complaint, and those planted in well prepared, but isolated, holes are not doing as well.

I think I'll wait a couple of days hoping for a few more clematis addicts to chime in here, then carefully dig out one deutzia and see if I can ascertain how much mischief it's doing.

Thanks for your input. It will all be used in the end!

    Bookmark   April 21, 2013 at 3:19PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
buyorsell888(Zone 8 Portland OR)

IF you dig a hole in clay and then plant in amendments you basically create a pot...they can become potbound in such a situation.

    Bookmark   April 21, 2013 at 8:27PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
butterclem(z6 W.PA)

I fear that makes sense. I don't have a terrible clay situation, though. My community is on a pretty steep hill, and my street is at the bottom of the hill. Over hundreds of years, much of the top soil seems to have worked its way downwards, and the people on my street are the beneficiaries. I do have some clay but not huge hunks of it. It's probably the best soil I've ever had.

Still, the clematises holes are a lot finer than the surrounding soil, and I can see where the clematises might have become potbound. Certainly something has happened!

    Bookmark   April 22, 2013 at 12:23PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

If you think it is a diffuse root problem, I would not hesitate to dig it up and examine for whatever signs of damage might be found. The roots can be trimmed and the vine potted, while looking at the hole and surrounding area. As a test, if you add water to the hole, using a hose and find water does not drain, the reason is hard pan. Trees living in places with shallow hard pans will spread roots laterally, searching for preferential watering sites and can provide significant root competition. Digging in the hole, tree roots are larger & when pulled up, lead to the culprit. Sometimes in digging up a vine I've found nothing wrong with the roots, leading me to conclude the site was just not getting enough sun and other times finding the roots severely damaged beyond my wildest guess.

    Bookmark   April 22, 2013 at 7:04PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Did you figure out the problem?
What did you do?
How are the clems now?

    Bookmark   June 23, 2013 at 10:57PM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Need 2 clematis that go well together
Hello. I am putting in a new trellis that gets full...
Clematis heaving out of the ground?
Hi. I have a 4 year old Jackmanii clem that has begun...
Can you please post here if you find clematis at walmart/lowes
Can you please post here if you happen to find clematis...
How climate specific are clematis?
I want to add a few clematis to my gardens. I actually...
armandii: promise me it's *really* big?
My bedroom window is effectively three stories high...
Sponsored Products
Herman Miller | Setu® Work Table, Laminate Top
Eurostyle Kate Side Chair in Taupe Leatherette [Set of 4]
Beyond Stores
Beige Abstract Rug (5' x 7'6)
Cadence 6-lt Chandelier
LBC Lighting
LED 6" Retrofit kit For New Construction non-IC
$55.94 | Lamps Plus
Turkey & Sausage Gumbo
$68.00 | Horchow
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™