Shrubs/ landscaping and black walnut trees

ropari(MI)March 17, 2004

Not sure where to post this with so many forums???

We moved to new acreage with many black walnut trees. We would like to plant pretty shrubs, flowers, etc'., but have been told the walnut treees are harmful to many varieties.

Are there any nice looking landscaping shrubs, etc'., that do well around walnut trees.

I live in lower SW Michigan...zone 5 I believe.

Thanks much for any advice.

Also, not possible to remove trees...hundreds of them and they are the only variety planted here.

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
scenery(zone 7 VA)

I have seen Helleborus foetidus, Dicentra, Hosta (particularly 'Royal Standard') and primula do well under black walnuts. I know that the last three are hardy for you, not sure about the helleborus. Oh, and Arum italicum.

    Bookmark   March 17, 2004 at 9:07PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
enchantedplace

We successfully grow iris, day lily, hesperis matronalis (sweet rocket) tall phlox, and lycoris (surprise lily) below a black walnut tree. Also in the area are photonia, flowering quince, forsythia, and mahonia shrubs. However, the tree is tall and the branches do not spread much. good luck. EP

    Bookmark   March 17, 2004 at 11:15PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
Hawkeye_Belle(z6 PA)

Go to the forum known as the "Plants for Difficult Places". I have a post (Second Report....)reporting the plants I have within the drip line of Black Walnuts. This is a new planting; however, as far as the perennials are concerned, these are on lists of tolerant plant to juglone toxin.
Add to the list, Hydrangea microphelia (?sp) and Kerria japonica. I have these planted beneath a BW and they are doing fine. Also the Hydrangea species variation Annabelle is tolerant. Rugosa roses also seem to be tolerant and will tolerate some shade.

Good luck. It is always a challenge to plant anything with these trees.

    Bookmark   March 29, 2004 at 4:50PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
tmtmom(lehigh co. pa.)

I was interested in the replies to the question about suitable plants to grow near or under Black Walnuts, as we moved last fall to a property with a huge Black Walnut near the house. I was surprised to see a lilac flourishing around the trunk, as some sites have listed lilacs as one plant that will not grow under BWs. I don't know how robustly it flowers in the shade, but it seems perfectly healthy, and I was told it's been growing there "forever".
------------------------------------------------------------
I plan to look at the "plants for difficult places" forum also, but wondered if anyone has suggestions for other uses for the area beneath the tree. I had thought of locating a small chicken house nearby, but dont know if the leaves are a problem for poultry (not to mention the walnuts dropping on the roof and scaring them half to death!). Part of the area is a gravelled parking area at present, but BWs are not always car-friendly! Another consideration is ease of gathering the walnuts, a chore that apparently falls to to one of our neighbors, in exchange for a superb poppy/black walnut bundt cake- a tradition that we'd certainly like to continue ;-)

    Bookmark   March 6, 2005 at 1:59PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
Mandyvilla(7a No.VA)

I have been stuggling with this for years and have learned to try many different things...fortunately, I have no way of knowing if a plant's demise is from the dripline of BW or something else - although I do try most things in more than one area. I have had success with helleborus, hydrangea, foxglove, penstemmon and many of the things on the list on this link. (the list is at the end of the article). One thing I have had trouble with is good old laminum....and I can only suspect juglone toxicity.

Here is a link that might be useful: PLANTING NEAR BLACK WALNUTS

    Bookmark   March 28, 2005 at 7:04AM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Vegetable Companion Chart
There are still requests for my chart. That can only...
organicdan
companion plant unfinished visual pic
i am a visual learner and so i created a visual companion...
QuinnaBrennan
How far/close?
When reading companion planting guides I've been wondering...
llilibel03
companions for asparagus
In the spring I'm planting a large bed of asparagus....
penny_md6
Gardenias and tomatoes
I have a lovely gardenia tree that has a woven trunk...
ribsu
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™