Systemic deer repellent experiences?

squonk61(upstate NY)July 31, 2012

OK, so I just got off the phone with Amar, the inventor years ago of the systemic deer tablets you let soak up into a plants roots. His partnership 'dissolved' and the other guy started Repellex, which can't use the original formula so instead uses capsacian or hot pepper. Amar is still selling the original formula under the name Natura Products. A few web postings report the original formula is superior to the new product. I am starting a side by side test, but was wondering if anyone has used either product and what their results were?

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
greenhavenrdgarden

I'm not sure about the product mentioned above but I used Liquid Fence this year. We live in an area over run by dear. At one point I counted 18 in my yard at one time (I live on less than an acre!!!). I have had huge problems with deer eating everything. This year I planted 171 shrubs, 13 small trees, 60+ clematis and too many perennials to count. I used liquid fence this year and NOTHING has been eaten. Hostas, rhododendrons, 59 hydrangeas, roses. Nothing.
At one point I found a deer right next to my rhododendrons and the deer was eating weeds!! The ONLY plant that got eaten this year was a Limelight Hydrangea that I planted and forgot to spray. All my neighbors have had their yards devoured.
I spray heavy at 1st, I saturate the plants but I only do it once a month. It even lasts through rain.
I know that I will need to switch up the products as the deer get used to it but for now I am vey happy. Also, deer hunting season started this past weekend and the bow hunter using my yard has already taken 3 :)
Finally, whenever I read glowing reviews about a product I get suspicious that the person is a paid reviewer from the company. I can honestly say that I have no relation with this company. I am a pretty frequent poster here at Garden Web.

    Bookmark   September 19, 2012 at 7:59PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
Mcpotts

We have used Liquid Fence for years on the farm and it still works incredibly well. The deer cannot tolerate the smell, which thank goodness disappears in 48 hours for us humans. We have gardens and trees/shrubs and make sure we apply every 3 weeks. Expensive but effective.

    Bookmark   December 18, 2012 at 7:42AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
Dee67

I'm a Liquid fence girl too.It is expensive but worth it's weight. Don't buy the "ready to use".In my opinion, it's not mixed strong enough. Buy the concentrate.It lasts awhile & you can mix it a hair stronger, if you need to, but I find you don't. It's all natural & doesn't wash off in the rain. I to have never used the product you mentioned, but have heard of it.

    Bookmark   February 26, 2013 at 10:42AM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Bed of Nails
I have just received a plant labeled "Bed of Nails"...
carmellia
Deer/ Honeysuckle and Trumpet Vine
I have a deer problem. They just consumed all of my...
robinva
Cheap homemade deer repellent..actually works!
I did an experiment with my new plants this year. The...
mersiepoo
Hanging plants in wind and shade
Hello! Any suggestions of a suitable plant for this...
melange
Foundation planting help
I posted a whole long message but I think it was lost....
lmich9
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™