overwintering out of zone

scot(z5)June 7, 2009

OK, i know i am not the only one to go down this road, so i hope to glean some insight. i am forever trying things a zone or more south of me, with varied results. but this year i planted a Jiro Persimmon, right out in the middle of the yard, no micro-climate for that one. since they are rated for z6, (i couldnt get any sunset info) i thought what the heck. well now ive decided that i would like to put forth some effort to help ensure its survival. has anyone tried a portable greenhouse during the winter for something like this. i would not heat it, just thought that the suns warmth and the wind protection may help. i was thinking of setting it up end of Dec.and opening it up in March. that should "cover" the -10 to -20 degree nights.

any thoughts?

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

I hear you on the zone pushing thing. I too desperately want Asian persimmons, jujubes, etc.

I think that the problem with the approach you suggest is that the solar gain in such a small structure isn't adequate on those one or two really cold nights that would prove fatal to the plant.

On the palms and cycads board, a poster named Artictropic (or perhaps its Artictropical) has these amazing photos of very large palms he grows outdoors all year round in Zone 4 northern Utah at something like 5000 feet up in the mountains. He uses thick foamboard boxes and a few cfc lights to keep the plants alive all winter. I think the same approach would work very well for persimmons.

    Bookmark   June 11, 2009 at 10:55PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

thanks for the insight denninmi, i may give that a shot. as for jujubes, go ahead and plant them, i have had 2 living for 5 years on a small mound in the center of the drive with no winter protection at all. they both fruited the first couple years, then one died at the graft so i let it sprout from the root to use as a plinator, they are VERY late to leaf out, and they do put on lots of new growth too late in the fall to harden off, but they do get a little bigger each year. i cant help but think if i put some effort forth, they would do much better, but since i want them small i just let whatever happens happen.

    Bookmark   June 17, 2009 at 12:44PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
jessicavanderhoff(7 Md)

I think it's worth a try. I had a small greenhouse thing made of construction plastic and pvc pipe, by no means airtight, and there was still a noticeable temperature difference. The wind destroyed the plastic, though, so you might try something glass if it's windy where you are. If you're handy, I've heard of people getting old windows for free or cheap on craiglist and attaching them together into a box shape. If you have a terribly freezing night, maybe you could put buckets of boiling water in there, or something.

    Bookmark   June 18, 2009 at 4:42PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
picea(6A Cinci- Oh)

Without protection the persimmon won't make. As far as the jujube goes with the right cultivar you may be OK. I would try and find the earliest ripening selections available. Do a google search for Roger Meyer and Jujubes. He has lots of jujube selection and can advise you on which ones might do the best for you.

As far as persimmons go have you tried Rosseyanka? It is a American x kaki and is reported to taste like a Kaki. It is also hardy into zone 5. There are also several american persimmon seleections with large fruit such as Prok and Yates.


    Bookmark   June 23, 2009 at 8:23PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

please tell me something about my persimmon.
it is about 24 inches tall, it is from seed and I am not sure if it came from Fuyu or Hachiya persimmon fruit.
somehow it survived ontario winter although it was very younge and small and not protected. This winter I plan to put some winter protectio, just a bit. I would like to know if it ever grows big will it produce any fruit without another persimmon and will fruit be edible.

Please, write me as much as you can,
Thank you all

    Bookmark   September 28, 2014 at 8:57PM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Do Carpathian Walnuts and Butternuts Cross Pollinate?
It's probably been asked before, however, I couldn't...
Ornamentals? Who needs them!
As I see it, the basic problem with edible landscaping...
Edible Mycorrhizae Mushrooms
I have a wacky idea. Mycorrhizae mushrooms have symbiotic...
Looking for American elderberry
I am from Windsor, Ontario, Canada. I am looking for...
Designing with fruit & citrus trees
OK. I've finished the list of fruiting trees and shrubs...
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™