shrubs / small trees that tolerate clay

oyuenJune 24, 2008

We moved into this 3 year old house with a flower bed on our front lawn (north east exposure) last year. It's our second summer in this house and the little mountain ash in the flower bed still has no leaves on it; but the inside of the branch is still green. It turns out that it's all clay below the 4-5 inches of soil in the flower bed.

So my questions are:

1) what do I do with the mountain ash? Is it dead?

2) if we were to plant something else in its place, what would survive the clay soil in Zone 3?

3) someone has suggested that the clay would be too big a problem and we should think about just putting rocks in the bed. We do have 3 spireas and a rhododendron spread out in the same flower bed (they look a bit "anemic" as well).

Thanks in advance for all your suggestions to us newbies.

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Evergreens like our clay soil. Crabapples as well.

That mountain ash is a goner. They require better drainage than the average tree.

My advice to you, and you're not going to like it, is to amend the area so that you have 12 inches of soil. Dig out the spireas and the rhod(!) and replant them.

    Bookmark   June 25, 2008 at 1:53AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
Pudge 2b

I have clay soil. Trees and shrubs that grow very well in it are Lilac, Ninebark, Willow (there are smaller willows), anything in the Prunus family (like a Mayday tree, or a Shubert Chokecherry), High Bush Cranberry, Dogwoods, Barberry.

Stay away from roses

The thing about clay soil is it is very rich and holds moisture well. When it dries, tho, it's like a brick. It also hinders the uptake of iron which makes a plant green so that's why the plant looks yellow (or chlorotic). Some are more susceptible.

I find it much easier to plant things that like my soil instead of attempting to amend the soil. You can never really amend it enough to make some plants happy - perhaps for the first year or three but deep rooted plants (like shrubs) will quickly bypass that 12" of lovely soil and get down into the clay anyway. (And that's what happened to my roses). And when you plant things that like your soil there is no battle and the plants really grow well and look healthy. Plants that like clay soil are generally plants that like alkaline soil with a higher PH.

You may have a bunch of 'fill' in your yard - that stuff the builders dug out of the soil for your basement then they spread it over the land again when they backfill and level. That fill may only be a few inches deep and then there might be good soil under there again. You'll never know unless you dig a hole and see what levels of soil you go through.

I have Spireas - some are great and some are a bit chlorotic. But I think your Rhododendon would prefer an Acidic soil, or that which has a higher PH. You could try an acidic fertilizer (Miracle Grow makes one) which may green it up.

    Bookmark   July 1, 2008 at 5:12PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

He still needs to do something about his topsoil. He only has 5 inches. That makes it very difficult to grow anything at all. It's not really a matter of amending - he needs to add soil.

    Bookmark   July 2, 2008 at 11:54AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
bemidjigreen(z2 MN)

I have yellow clay throughout most of my yard. I agree with the previous suggestion for lilac, ninebark, shubert (if you aren't worried about black gall) and viburnum. All are doing well in my yard.

I don't think you should give up on the spirea, it may be just a different variety you need. I have a large gold mound spirea that was here when I bought the house. It sits in totally unamended clay and is lovely.

Also, nanking cherry seems to do well in clay. I planted two about 6' apart--one is in a nice mix of soil and the other is in pure clay with about 4" of top soil (the grass). The clay was so hard I had to chip it away to create the hole. I dug a 3 foot wide, 2 foot deep hole and amended the soil that backfilled the hole as best as could. After two years this nanking cherry is twice the size of its companion (much to my surprise!).

    Bookmark   July 4, 2008 at 5:26PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
Sherwood Botsford(3a)

Spruces and larch will do well in clay. Most pines prefer a sandier well drained soil. My currents and saskatoons like the heavy soil. Lodgepole pine tolerates it where there is a slope for drainage.

Our garden was largely clay when we moved in. Took me a while to realize that the clay held on to moisture so well that I really didn't need to water it. So I use tomatoes as water guages. When they go a bit limp, I water the garden.

The other thing I've been doing is sneaking off to the city with the truck and trailer, and creeping down the alley ways in fall. Bring back a couple loads of bags of leaves. Spread out 6" thick on the garden, and rototill in. Been doing that now for several years, and the soil is getting better. Admittedly I've gotten some new weeds You could do this with a green manure crop such as vetch too. this way.

    Bookmark   August 26, 2008 at 10:00AM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Raspberries for zone 4
Hi Far N gardeners, I'm not exactly "far"...
Potted peonies already coming up in garage! What do I do?
Hi everyone, After my winter hibernation, I am back!...
Northland Crab apple
This is an older Mn. variety that is supposed to be...
Has many one tried for roses?
I came across this site,,...
prairie_northrose (3a north of Calgary, AB, Canada)
Has anyone tried bale gardens?
Due to my rampant quack grass this summer I took out...
Sponsored Products
Varaluz | Treefold 1 Light Wall Sconce
$159.00 | YLighting
Tree Rings Print
$18.99 | Dot & Bo
Chicago Glass Cityscape Ornament
$14.99 | zulily
Stencil Dining Side Chair in White
$129.00 | LexMod
Palm Shadow I Wall Art
$279.00 | FRONTGATE
Carr & Day & Martin Tea Tree Hoof Oil Multicolor - 3933
$25.85 | Hayneedle
Aspen Path Light by Hinkley Lighting
$176.66 | Lumens
Slipping Seasons Art Print
$22.99 | Dot & Bo
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™