Winter King Hawthorn vs. Amelanchier 'Autumn Brilliance'

ilikemud_2007March 27, 2009

They both sound like beautiful trees and both fit the bill as far as size and culture requirements are concerned. I think it's a personal issue thing, but am looking for opinions.

Seems to me that the Hawthorn has more seasons of interest with the exfoliating bark, good fall color and persistent fruit.

What are your two cents?

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

I really don't have experience with 'Winter King' except that we planted two at the school and I can't say that they have done well ... however, who knows what has been done to them? It's at an elementary school.

However, we also planted two 'Autumn Brilliance' and they have done very well - but they are multi-stem and I imagine that if kids were messing with one or the other, they'd pick the single trunk tree.

I will say that if you're interested in them for wildlife (berries) then the Serviceberry is way more popular with birds. It also has very nice fall color and I haven't heard that about hawthorns in general.

    Bookmark   March 29, 2009 at 8:25AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Thanks esh, I think that the Serviceberry is more available too. I hope I get more replies before I buy!

    Bookmark   March 29, 2009 at 1:10PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

I prefer the serviceberry due to the fall color and bird attraction but that's a personal opinion. Bird song goes under the "asset" category in my book. I'm just doing a new landscape and have 2 serviceberry cultivar and 3 Hawthorn, including winter king, on my list, but the hawthorn is on the "if there is room and I happen to run across one in a nursery" list.

Went shopping this weekend for s. Autumn Brilliance and could not find it anywhere but John Deer Landscaping. Theirs were quite large, $129 each, which is more than I can spend on a single plant considering how much I need. I bought 7 viburnums, more shrubs, two other trees, yada yada that day and haven made a dent in my wish list. Very nice specimens though. I'm going to try a few more places this week, travel further, if I find any I will post.

    Bookmark   March 30, 2009 at 7:53PM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Native shade plant recommendations
I live just north of Atlanta and am looking for recommendations...
Would anyone like some plumeria trees. I post this...
Dracaena Massangeana - leaves are turning yellow and then brown!!
Hello, I bought a Dracaena Massangeana plant about...
N. Ga. Mountain region
We've purchased a home with what appear to be 6 established...
eagleap_gw Zone 10
Howdy Folks!
Any of the old regulars still around? I have been...
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™