I posted this on the name that plant forum, but thought some of the visitors here might be helpful too.
Thanks for the help.
Here is a link that might be useful: Name That Plant Post
I agree with gardengal. The red one is Cinderella. And I also agree the seed will probably not grow true unless it came from a field with only Cinderella pumpkins.
Thanks for the information. Good to know.
I let the squirrels have the seeds and the soup came out great :)