[Basil] Please help me understand what happened here.

LunachicJanuary 14, 2014

First of all, I must explain that I'd never tried to grow any sort of plant before, so I don't really know what I'm doing yet.

I purchased a basil plant from Walmart. It was in a small plastic pot.

I kept the pot in a bowl which contained about an inch of water. After several days had passed, I was pleased to see that it looked healthy.

I noticed that Harris Teeter was also selling live basil plants, but theirs were a little larger and more robust-looking. Another noteworthy difference is that they did not have pots. I purchased two of the HT plants and placed them in the bowl with my other basil plant.

As you can see in the photo, my two newest basil plants have died, while the Walmart basil remains alive.

The instructions on the Harris Teeter basil plants said to put the roots in water, so I thought nothing of setting them in the bowl with 1" of water. Was this my mistake? It hasn't been sunny here, lately, but I thought they would get adequate light at the window I chose. I changed the water every day and did not use any fertilizers on them.

What went wrong? What should I have done?

Thank you!

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
zzackey(8b GA)

I would never grow them like that! Just water them when they feel partially moist. Lift the pot when it is wet and lift it every few days. Wait until it is fairly light and water it until water comes out the drainage holes. It is a very easy plant to grow outside in the sun. You can save seeds from it when it flowers, which it loves to do! I keep most of my flowers cut off and leave a few branches flowering for the butterflies and bees.

    Bookmark   January 15, 2014 at 4:46PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
balloonflower(5b Denver CO, HZ 5-6, Sunset 2b)

Lunachic, First, where are you? That will affect how something grows. Upon first glance, to me it looks like the plants got too cold, but it's very hard to tell from a picture. Basil likes it hot! (below 50 is too cold--above 70 is really where they'll thrive). If you are in a cold weather place, the window may be too cold for the basil. It does also need a lot of light.

Second, I think you got two different 'types' of plants, for lack of a better term. The potted seedling from Walmart is meant to be planted up--that pot is definitely not big enough for the basil to thrive, especially since there are three plants there that I see. I would recommend a 12" pot for what I see. The others I'm guessing were the type that you can find in many supermarkets now that are grown more hydroponically, and not meant for planting or long life. They're meant to harvest all leaves for use right away. That's why no pot, and instructions for placing in water. They are not really meant to live once they're sold.

As for placing in the saucer of water, it's a common misconception--you'd think that since plants need water, then that would be ideal, and it probably is for a few types of plants. But, herbs do need the soil to drain to avoid root rot, and be watered as needed according to the plant's needs--basil likes to be kept moist, but not soaking if you see the difference. Your originaly potted plant may be saveable, but it is stressed right now--needs a bigger pot and more light from the looks of it.

    Bookmark   January 15, 2014 at 6:36PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
weedlady(Central OH 6)

The non-potted ones drowned; toss 'em. They are not even edible at this point.

There IS hope for the potted one, but get it OUT of standing water as Zackey suggests. Never allow any potted plants to stand in water. (But do not let it dry out entirely, either! The light mix the nursery uses, once dry, is almost impossible to re-hydrate.)

The basil in the pot is actually 5-6 plants -- way too many for that size pot. In the garden or good-sized container, one basil plant can get a couple of feet tall and at least a foot wide. It would be chancy to try to separate them at this stage of their growth but you could try cutting each one back just above the lower sets of leaves and try rooting the cuttings in water. But you must not allow any of the leaves to sit in water or they will rot as the Harris Teeter plants did. If they do send out roots (sometimes they do, sometimes they don't), once the roots are about an inch long you could carefully pot them separately using a seed-starting mix (NOT backyard dirt or even potting soil--those are too heavy). Seeding mix is peat, vermiculite and perlite. Don't use fertilizer at this point. If you can get some good compost or worm castings, mix some of that in.

The potted plants are "leggy" -- too tall because they are not getting enough sunlight. Even a south window (especially if screened) does not provide the sun a basil prefers for good growth. With luck, your plants will survive long enough to plant into a larger container and go outside when the weather is totally warm (consistently above 50 degrees at night).

And if you want success at growing plants, start reading & learn how to do it! Tons of good info on the Web.
Good luck.

    Bookmark   January 15, 2014 at 6:49PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
zzackey(8b GA)

I've had several of the herb plants root that are meant for leaves only. Most have a good root system even tho it is quite small. But I always put them in a 4" pot to start.

    Bookmark   January 22, 2014 at 3:31PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Yes they have drownor gotten root rot. Give the living one a larger pot & fresh soil and don't let it sit in standing water. Give it a while to recover & show new growth before harvesting from it.

    Bookmark   January 27, 2014 at 6:36PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

At first glance it looks like the smaller plants have root rot, but what jumped out me first was they all should have been potted in larger pots. I don't think it's possible to save the smaller plants so I would just put them in the trash, but I would save the larger one.

The large plant looks a bit leggy to me, so I would first get a larger pot and fill it with potting soil. Then I would cut the stem into 3-4" cuttings, making sure to leave at least 2 leaves near the top so the plants can re-establish themselves. Then I would stick the cuttings in larger pot(s), And if it looks like one of the stems is about to flower (small white flowers at the top of the stem) I would pinch them back. Otherwise you will wind up with a woody plant.

Also I would never place basil in standing water. Basil is especially prone to root rot as seedling, so that is something to keep in mind.

Hope this helps!

    Bookmark   January 27, 2014 at 6:58PM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
How should I dry my parsley leaves?
I have three large bunches of Parsley. How should I...
Unidentified Herb, Maybe Mint??
Moved into a new home over the winter. Within the...
plants in cat litter bags?
I've seen pics of plants growing in reusable shopping...
Wanted: Herb seeds for SASE
Hello. I am trying to do a project with my daughters...
Brenda Lee
What is attacking my basil? Whiteflies?
I have an indoor growlight which has allowed me to...
Sponsored Products
24" White Marble Vessel Sink Natural Stone - BALI WHITE
Hoffman Oushak Rug 6' x 9' - LIGHT BLUE/BROWN
$2,019.00 | Horchow
Five Thrillers Sample Art Print
$23.99 | Dot & Bo
Hydro Systems Duo 6048 Tub
Modern Bathroom
Spring Air Back Supporter Pillow Top Mattress and Box A & E Spring Set Multicolo
$704.99 | Hayneedle
54" Savoy House Zephyr Mercury Black Finish Ceiling Fan
Lamps Plus
Sapele Luxury Folding Shower Bathroom Seat Modern Bathroom Accessory
Hudson Reed
LZF | Raindrop 7in Suspension Light
$810.00 | YLighting
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™