Tomatoes Heirloom vs Hybrid

BigcarlMarch 20, 2003

It is my understanding that one cannot plant tomatoe seeds from a Hybrid plant and expect to get the same plant. My question has to do with Heirloom tomatoes that were developed by crossing different varities. Specifically the Mortgage Lifter that is the result of cross breeding four different varities. Why will the Mortgage Lifter, a Heirloom, produce the same fruit from seed, when an Early Girl, a Hybrid, will not?

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
Sparaxis(Vic Aust)

I don't know a lot about either variety, so I am taking it that you have your facts correct.
It can be readily accepted that an F1 hybrid plant (the immediate cross between 2 selected varieties) will be heterozygous (will carry pairs of unlike chromosomes) and will give you a variety of different seedlings.
Species plants are homozygous - both chromosomes of a pair being identical. Varieties also approach homozygosity because of diligent selection (or, in the case of naturally formed varieties - through isolation).
If the Mortgage lifter is the result of cross breeding 4 different varieties, then it will give mixed offspring UNLESS it is also the product of a selection program. When a desired type is selected over a number of generations, it again approaches a homozygous state, and will breed relatively true. There will not be absolute homozygosity, so some variation may creep in occasionally, and this can be again selected for.
This is how most selected strains of garden annuals work. You get some variation of course, but it is minor compared to the variation you get when you cross an F1 hybrid.
Cheers, jan

    Bookmark   March 22, 2003 at 5:49PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
maineman(z5a ME)


"Specifically the Mortgage Lifter that is the result of cross breeding four different varities. Why will the Mortgage Lifter, a Heirloom, produce the same fruit from seed, when an Early Girl, a Hybrid, will not?"

Jan's explanation is accurate. Mortgage Lifter was repeatedly selected for several generations to stabilize it after the initial hybrids of hybrids. It may not be 100% stable today. But you could continue the selection process to develop your own strain of Mortgage Lifter.

Early Girl is an F1 hybrid. That's not to say that you couldn't save seed from Early Girl and get some interesting F2 variations, some of which you might like. The interesting thing about growing F2s is that you can see new characteristics that were different from either F1 parent. If you found an F2 that you liked, or several, you could save seed from it (them) and the resulting F3s would still vary a lot, but each group would be somewhat centered around the characteristics of the F2s that you selected.

In several generations of such repeated selection you could stabilize one or more of your own varieties from the F1 Early Girl.

Then you could go to the next level and cross a couple of those varieties to produce a new F1 hybrid tomato. By continually improving your inbred strains you can also improve the F1 hybrids that you can produce from them. There are a lot of ways you could combine, segregate, and recombine tomato genes.

-- Burton --

    Bookmark   December 18, 2003 at 1:04AM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
native plum graft
i want to improve wildlife feed. we have a lot of native...
Here is my proprietary peachmond, Elberta peach (pollen...
goose plums; paw paw
I just read that goose plums were a natural cross between...
Weird green echinacea
This summer one of my echinaceas bloomed green---all...
Cindi McMurray
hybridizing euphorbias
Hello All, Does anyone have experience hybridizing...
Sponsored Products
Avanity MODERO-VS60-ES-A Modero 60-in. Single Vanity - MODERO-VS60-ES-A-A
Modern Indoor/Outdoor Area Rug: Kaleen Rugs Heirloom Melanie Brown 2 ft. x 3
$79.00 | Home Depot
DENY Designs Jennifer Denty Anchor Small Fleece Throw Blanket - 12934-FLELAR
$59.00 | Hayneedle
Safavieh Indoor/Outdoor Area Rug: Safavieh Rugs Austin Red/Creme 8 ft. x 11 ft.
Home Depot
Kostner Three-piece Holy Family Nativity Figurines
$229.00 | FRONTGATE
Stem Gem Strawberry Huller
$7.49 | zulily
New Oriental Hand Knotted Heriz Serapi 12'x15' Red/Midnight Blue Wool Rug H3608
BH Sun Inc
1-Light Pendant Heirloom Bronze
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™