white line sphinx moth- case of mistaken identity?

katydid85(8)April 7, 2013

While I've been vegetable gardening for years, my insect identification skills have been clearly lacking...

What I have been dubbing a "hornworm moth", and smashing on sight, I have now correctly identified it as a white lined sphinx moth. Are these detrimental to vegetable crops? and are their larvae similar to a tomato hornworm?

I'm a first year market grower, and was terrified I had a huge population of hornworm moths emerging. I'm getting hundreds a week on our patio, and would like to know if these are BENEFICIAL insects or not.Thank you in advance!!

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

White Lined Sphinx moths are also known as Hummingbird Moths and the larva of these sphinx moths grow on and eat a variety of what we call "weeds" so they are known as a beneficial moth.
Because the Tobacco, or Tomato, Hornworn is the larva of members of the sphinx moth family many people think all pf the sphinx moth family is a pest, although there are also those that think that the Hummingbird Moths come from the larva of the Carolina Sphinx or the Five Spotted Hawkmoth, both sphinx moths and the parents of the Tobacco, Tomato, hornworm.

    Bookmark   April 7, 2013 at 6:55AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
rhizo_1 (North AL) zone 7

So, you're sure about the ID of your Sphinx moth? Just checking. The larvae of most Sphingidae have a horn, making them pretty recognizable; they are often pretty large, as well.

If yours is really the Whitelined Sphinx moth, it enjoys a wide range of host plants, something a bit unusual in this family. I've identified them on oaks and elms, tomatoes, and even portulaca but they can also be
found on many other plants. If populations are high, they can be a pest of tomatoes, grapes, and other crops. Yes...I said tomatoes.

The "beneficial " aspect is complex but you should try to understand it as much as possible. These moths visit an enormous variety of flowers, especially those that become strongly scented at night. Therefore, they are pollinators. It's the larvae that can cause problems IF your crops are their host plants AND they are in large enough numbers. Accurate ID is very important.

As a market grower, you need to find dependable information resources for insect identification. If you can provide pretty good pictures, you have a much better chance at getting some accurate information. Not just here in the Gardenweb but at your Extension office and other places.

I'll be happy to help when I can....just post in here or email.

    Bookmark   April 14, 2013 at 10:48PM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
What's in my mulch?
I have a large mulch bed (the Texas native mulch that...
Caterpillars come back to eat petunias every year
I live in NYC and am a terrace gardener. I love to...
Mice in the house! Help
About three months ago my wife detected in odor in...
spotted wing drosophila
Anybody is fighting this pest?
Can't get rid of lone rat in my home! Help!
About three weeks ago, I saw a rat running through...
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™