Phantom tree vs limelight

greenhavenrdgardenMay 24, 2012

Hi all, I was planning to plant a limelight tree. I already have 5 limelight shrubs and I do love them. The price on the tree is $130. I recently found a Phantom tree form for $38 w/a one yr guarantee. I have to say I've never heard of this one but I'm interested (especially w/the price difference). Can someone explain the difference and what would you go with? Thanks :)

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
luis_pr(7b/8a Hurst, TX)

Kerchunk! That was the sound of my mouth hitting the floor! $130! That is awfully expensive unless it is a large/old Limelight specimen. Speaking about hydrangea trees in general, I have seen advertisements somewhere around the 30-50 zone. If it is shipped by mail and it contains a lot of soil, maybe you end up paying that much due to the soil weight. Since hydrangeas -most- tend to grow quickly, I would not mind getting a smaller tree and saving some dollars in the process. I would shop elsewhere for a Limelight tree. Or better, see if someone posts a current price for one that they have seen locally.

    Bookmark   May 25, 2012 at 12:04AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
Springwood_Gardens(6B Pittsburgh)

Lots of nurseries charge that for most trees in the 5-6' tall range in #5-7 pots. And this usually means that the smaller stuff is uniformly expensive, and that's a point where I turn around and leave. If they think they can get people's business, that's great for them.

It's hard to find cheap Proven Winners trees to begin with.

Phantom should be fine, especially for the price. I got a regular old Grandiflora tree for $20 and it's already 5' tall with a 3x3' bush up top. I bought it in August and it flowered profusely right after I put it in the ground!

Nurseries seem to love to get people trouble who are in a hurry to buy nice stuff.

In just a few years, you can get plenty of things cheap by being a patient shopper, or by taking divisions/donations from friends, neighbors and family, or by pitching in with people's yard work, etc.

    Bookmark   May 25, 2012 at 5:44AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
greenhavenrdgarden

Thanks for the responses. In the 30-50 price range I have bought regular Limelight shrubs but if I want to get an actual Limelight that has been trained into a 4-5ft standard, I will be paying $120 minimum around here and that's if I can find it. Last summer I bought a regular PeeGee standard at Twombly's nursery and paid $115. It's beautiful and I like the look of the big floppy flowers on a standard. I think I'll try the Phantom. You guys are right. At that price, why not? I live in Fairfield County in CT and seems like EVERYTHING is overpriced around here but sadly, the closer we get to NYC it actually gets WORSE. Not much I can do about it bc my husband works in NY. Thanks again.

    Bookmark   May 25, 2012 at 8:12AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
hydrangeasnohio(6a)

Guess I am lucky. Our local Nursery in the Fall always puts 5-7 Gallon Hydrangeas on sale for $20 in tree or shrub form and have hundreds to pick from. I see many Limelights in tree form in my area. They are always flopping or staked if not. I bought many years ago a Pink Diamond that has done great. Also I have heard good things about QuickFires in tree form. I am just not big on having stakes in my yard to hold things up. Maybe something to think about if you dont like stakes. If I remember correctly Phantom has bigger blooms than a Limelight and just dont go thru that lime/green stage that a Limelight does.

    Bookmark   May 25, 2012 at 9:13AM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
How are those limelight hedges looking? (pic)
I know a lot of us were planting limelight hedges this...
joannemb
No Time To Winterize Endless Summer
I did not have the time to winterize my endless summers...
DDhydrangea
Nikko Blue size
I planted a tiny bare root stick of a Nikko Blue Last...
NVL4
Wanted: Big blooms in shade, Gulf Coast/Texas
Hi folks - I've been nursing a couple of ES hydrangeas...
cagoldbear
Hydrangeas in wet soil
I have an empty area beside our air conditioning unit...
ryank817
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™