Was my grandmother crazy?

nyboyJuly 26, 2013

I justed picked up 6 large hydrangea that where on clearance. I want to planted them this weekend. My grandmother had great hydrangea in her garden, at least my memory thinks so. The strange thing is I remember my grandma putting money in the holes before planting.. Could this be right?

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Not crazy but operating under the belief of a very old but unsubstantiated gardening myth :-)

It was believed that putting pennies in the planting hole of a new hydrangea would influence flower color. Not true :-) It is the availability of aluminum ions in the soil that either create or inhibit the blue color. Since pennies contain no aluminum (nor do any other coins), dumping an entire piggy bank into the hole would have no effect! Same thing with the rusty nails or rusty cans alternative scenarios - long held but no scientific basis gardening myths.

Here is part of an excellent post written by my friend Al discussing this same subject on another forum several years ago: "Actually it is plant cellular pH that determines bloom color, not soil pH. Lowering soil pH makes aluminum ions readily available for plant uptake where it bonds to pigments in the blooms.

Three different pigments - chlorophyll, flavonoids, and carotenoids - mixed in different proportions, give color to plants. By mixing and matching the three pigments, an endless variety of colors can be created. E.g. most reds are the result of mixing orange carotenoids with magenta flavonoids. Cellular pH (not to be confused with soil pH) has a profound effect on plant color.

Even most experienced gardeners think that lowering soil pH produces blue blooms in hydrangea. Technically, it is only a part of the equation. Lowering soil pH makes aluminum ions more readily available for plant uptake. The aluminum is then available to bond with pigment compounds (anthocyanin, the colored component of flavonoids) changing the way color is reflected. Our perception is blooms changing from pink to blue."

Cellular pH (not to be confused with soil pH) has a profound effect on plant color. I want to emphasize this point - this explains why some hydrangeas are very reluctant to change colors regardless of how acidic the soil is or how available the aluminum is. They are just not genetically programmed to do so.

    Bookmark   July 26, 2013 at 2:13PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Grandmas system of gardening may not pass the test when looked at from a scientific perspective, but once you have signed on to grannies method, it is hard to give up. To this day I can not bring myself to plant a Daphne without burying a few rusty nails in the soil. I just can't risk losing a good plant. Al

    Bookmark   July 27, 2013 at 8:48AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Thank you guys glad she wasn't crazy just old fashon!!! I think to honor her I will put some pennies in their holes.

    Bookmark   July 27, 2013 at 9:26AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
sandyl(Zone 6B -7)

I put horse shoes in the planting hole's of blue hyd when I plant them. I put four or five around the base of the plant.

    Bookmark   September 4, 2013 at 11:30AM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Little Lime and Limelight Hydrangea
Both hydrangeas have (some) branches that are somewhat...
How are those limelight hedges looking? (pic)
I know a lot of us were planting limelight hedges this...
Hydrangeas in wet soil
I have an empty area beside our air conditioning unit...
Invincibelle� Spirit II Hydrangea arborescens
Does anyone know if the new Invincebelle Spirit Hydrangeas...
galls in dirt where to plant
Hi, Last summer I dug up a rose that had not been doing...
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™