yolanda_bSeptember 20, 2011

Four years ago I bought a cheap pond kit and dug a bathtub sized pond to cool off in. The next year I added plants and a huge school (flock, herd?) of comets from the feeder tank. The population was halved over the summer but the fish I set up in a winter tank were wonderful. When I put them out in spring I noticed that it seemed like every chain pet store in town had koi so I got a couple, lost one, got a couple more, lost one. Seems I have about a 50% survival rate.
That's one thing I'd like to improve for sure.

Things that are wrong with my pond: It's really much too small. The fish are small enough now but that won't last. I've not started but hope to start enlarging it this autumn and finish in spring before the fish go out.

One thing I'm hoping to do with a new pond is design it better for plants of various depths and such that the plants can be left in. I'd like things that are hardy in my zone even if they're not as flashy. I'd like to dig a corner of it under the waterfall deep enough to keep liquid and leave the fish there all season but I'm not sure if that's even possible.

Last year I kept a lily pot alive in a bucket of water with a birdbath heater in it, inside a cooler. The water hyacinth with it rotted and so did all the leaves, but I've since read that I should have pruned the lily and composted the hyacinth. this year I'll prune the lily once freezing is entrenched and I've put the birdbath heater under the waterfall rocks and the lily right by it, with the basket of bulrushes guarding it so I can perhaps insulate with snow.

I'm wondering if something of this sort in the new dug pond would allow fish to stay out at less extreme depths. I am not planning a pond much more than 60 or 70 square feet at the most. I read on one site that you need 7-8ft of depth and that just wouldn't work here. It's just a small urban garden.

Perhaps I should just focus on figuring how to fit a bigger tank into my house as the fish grow? At this size they're already getting harder to net gently enough.

View from behind the rock waterfall of my wee pond with dwarf bullrushes. In case the image fails:

A late spring snowfall between setting up the pump and adding living things made this a very sweet view. Flickr page for this:

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
donnaz5(Z5 NY)

You are right...bigger is definately better as ponds go...much easier to maintain, and the fluctuations in temp and ph and everything else are much more gradual.
As for your 50% survival rate..don't be too hard on store/ big box store koi are usually much less vigorous to start with, and are the culled fish from larger growers..follow that by the poor care they usually receive in pet stores with no quarantines and you're very lucky that any lived!
I am not an expert on maybe someone else will have that answer for you...but a pool heater might work to keep a shallow pond from freezing, although I wonder if the cost of running it would be astronomical?
I have an earthen pond that is about 8 feet deep at the deep end, and my koi do fine in the winter with no help.
Keep asking questions, and you will find a compromise suitable for both you and your fish! Good Luck...Donna

    Bookmark   May 17, 2012 at 10:47PM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Koi Pond Liners
I have been seriously pondering the design of a Koi...
barred owl ate 9 koi!
my koi are all gone! They've been in this pond for...
New to koi
Hi folks, I just picked up an established koi pond...
Neighbor's Koi in our bass pond
Hi all...any help would be appreciated. After a heavy...
Pond not deep enough
I purchased a house that has a small pond in front....
Sponsored Products
Progress Lighting Pendant Lights Illuma-Flex 1-Light Brushed Nickel Pendant
$99.99 | Home Depot
Diane P Wall Sconce by Leucos Lighting
$563.98 | Lumens
Ankara White 84 x 50-Inch Embroidered Faux Silk Taffeta Curtain Single Panel
$113.95 | Bellacor
Retro CD/USB Stereo Sound System
$249.00 | FRONTGATE
Colmar Square Glass Shade Bronze Finish 1-light Floor Lamp
A Tier Above Jewelry Stand
$24.99 | Dot & Bo
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™