help! koi dying - is there still time?!

StogieFartsSeptember 30, 2013

I will give you guys the quick version since this is rather an emergency.

I have a small pond which was very overstocked. After 2 years in peaceful harmony, it all came to a crashing end this month, when fish started dying, one after the other.

Ammonia, nitrites, and nitrates appeared to be fine. And yet, every morning, more and more fish would die.

I would do water changes, but they still died.

Now, what I THINK happened is that 1) the warmer weather and overstocked pond made the diurnal pH swing too great. I literally would see the pH be around 7.4 in the morning, and 8.6 or so in the evening. I think this swing was too much and perhaps killed them outright, or weakened their immune system to where they succumbed and died.

But I digress.......

I THINK I have things under control now by adding a TON MORE AERATION to the tank, which is supposed to help with pH swings because it equalizes the CO2 in the water.

However, I have ONE DYING KOI. He's small, about 6 inches in size.......his first symptoms I saw was when he isolated himself from the others and only stayed on the bottom of the tank.

Then, ONE WEEK AGO, I saw that he could no longer swim right. He was swimming like a barrel roll - spinning in 360 degree turns.

I immediately moved him into a hospital tank, salted to 0.3%, and applied a treatment of Maracyn 2 (thinking perhaps it was a bacterial thing).

It's now been ONE WEEK and he is the same (if not, worse). He usually just stays completely horizontal on his side, breathing. He will occasionally swim but only on the bottom, and always canted to one side. When he stops swimming, he looks dead because he's on his side, but he is still breathing. I haven't noticed him eating at all, unless little specks of food get ingested while he's keeled over on his side.

Does this fish have any chance to recover? The fact that he's lived like this for a week is playing with my mind. I thought he would have died many days ago. So is there hope? Should I do anything else? Or just keep him isolated in this other tank until he either improves or dies?

I even considered putting him back into the main tank (because there is more aeration, more room, etc, but I don't want him to get picked on by the few remaining fish, nor do I want to expose him to those fluctuating pH ranges if the aeration doesn't control it.

Please let me know what your thoughts are on this.

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
waterbug_guy(Phoenix AZ (Melrose))

What is the water temp, KH, size of these tanks, number and size of fish? Terms like "small" are too relative to be very useful.

I think your diurnal pH swing is very acceptable, especially if this has been the case for a long time. I'd still check KH just to know.

I have no idea where this pond is located. Adding a TON MORE AERATION in freezing weather can drop the water temp to less than 32F which fish will have a hard time with.

Hopefully when you treated with salt and Maracyn the water temp was in the 75F range? At cold temps the fish immune system isn't very good. Raising the water temp can be your best tool as the fish has many good natural weapons. A fish's immune system is much better at diagnosing these things than we ever will be. Treating with salt for example irritates the skin causing mucus production. In cold water mucus production can be a problem for fish adding to the stress. Also salt treatment has no effect on bacteria so no reason to stress fish if bacteria is suspected imo. Salt in cold water isn't something I would do. Maracyn also stress fish, so warmer water makes it easier on the fish and I think more effective.

Swimming in circles my first guess might be electrocution, that the fish injured itself. But that's just a wild guess but something that can be checked without too much trouble. The behavior is a symptom which could be caused by many things.

    Bookmark   February 1, 2014 at 2:03AM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Stock Tank Patio Pond
Hello! I am posting plans for a 250 gal stock tank...
Concentrated Barley extract
I have a 2000gls and I put 1.25oz of concentrated Barley...
My Koi is laying on it's side on the bottom of my pond
I have plants in my pond for shade for my koi and to...
Kois lying at the bottom and straight up on pond
Hello, I have a 12x14 size Koi pond in my home where...
%$$#@^ great blue herion
my koi pond is an all you can eat buffet for a blue...
Sponsored Products
Neutral Shag Rug 4' x 6' - MEDIUM GREEN
$499.00 | Horchow
Designers Fountain Outdoor Woodmere LED22331 Wall Lantern - Oil Rubbed Bronze -
$179.50 | Hayneedle
Montmartre Arm Chair in Aqua
$164.99 | Dot & Bo
Vitra | Asterisk Clock
Central Coffee,Herb and Spice Grinder
Monet Cafe Armless Dining Chair
Grandin Road
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™