hps or mh for first indoor attempt (details)

wvcruffler(z4 WV)January 21, 2006

Howdy all,

Looking to grow cooking herbs (basil, tarragon, etc.) and a few smaller pepper plants (Thai bird, etc.) indoors here in WV. Are there any opinions on which between these two would be better for that application? I have seen refurbished ones on Ebay for Phil

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
shrubs_n_bulbs(z8/9 UK)

How large is the area that you wish to light? HID (metal halide and HPS) can be tricky for starting seeds because they don't evenly illuminate a wide area. Stuff in the middle may fry while stuff at the edges will lean and stretch. The area you wish to light will also determine how much power you need. A 400W HID will be good for at least ten square feet, possibly double that. Small HID lamps tend to be less efficient and it probably isn't worth using less than 250W. Also, older lamps are less efficient and you might be better with a new fluorescent or compact fluorescent. How long do you want to grow them under lights? Do you have any natural light at all?

HPS light is the best as a supplemental light, simply because you get the most light for your money/electricity. As the only light, it usually needs extra blue spectrum to produce healthy growth. You could get an enhanced HPS (extra blue from an HPS bulb), add some blue-ish fluorescent tubes, or many people just use metal halides to keep it simple.

Fluorescents generally need to be almost in contact with sun-loving seedlings to produce good growth. Good ventilation is also helpful to keep temperatures down and have some moving air around the seedlings. A modern four-tube setup should be well up to the task, older T12s or magnetic ballast lights just might not be intense enough. Look for 48" T8s producing around 3,000 lumens, they will grow good seedlings. Overdriven lamps or T5s will produce even more intense light.

    Bookmark   January 21, 2006 at 4:03PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
jwmeyer(Z8 OR)

Ceramic metal halide is the way to go...Best of both worlds. I kinda feel like a pioneer here. Once people see how wonderful these lights perform they'll never turn back. I'm not talking about if your just starting seeds for transplant outside, then flourecent is fine but, if you want to grow vegies or whatever indoors, to maturity, these lights are definately something you should consider. I'm doing eggplant, toms, hot pepper and bell pepper right now and am very impressed w/ this light.
(400w philips cmh w/ 4' vertizontal reflector)

Here is a link that might be useful:

    Bookmark   January 23, 2006 at 6:48PM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
T5 vs T8 and equivalent
Obviously T5s are the better choice for indoor growing,...
bulb question
I put a 75 W Philips Bulb - 120 volt- (Agro-Lite BR30)...
Browning and drying avocado leaves
I've been growing two avocado plants for about 10 months...
HELP!..Possible Indoor Pepper growing probz!
I have a few questions regarding my pepper plants at...
Bobby Cooper
More beautiful plumeria blossoms under grow lights
More proof that grow lights work! I planted this plumeria...
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™