beginner question

winnjoe(MTL)March 4, 2005

I've read several posts but realize I am woefully ignorant of lighting issues. Which would be better: Phillips F40T12 Plant&Aquarium 40watt, or Verilux wide spectrum F40VLX/WS? Thanks, Joe, Winnipeg

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
shrubs_n_bulbs(z8/9 UK)

Depends what you want to use them for. Neither bulb is cheap. I suspect you can do better for a lot less money.

If you want a wide spectrum high-CRI bulb to mimic sunlight then look at the GE Chroma 50 or 75, or even a Daylight Deluxe such as the one from Sylvania. There are plenty of similar bulbs but not any better and they cost more. The Verilux is an overpriced triphosphor and the spectrum just isn't so great. I'd love to tell you more but I just can't find any reliable information on this bulb. If you just want some blue light to mix with other lights then almost any 6500K (or 5000K, or 7500K) bulb will do.

The Philips Plant & Aquarium is one of those "blue and red makes purple" bulbs, although its actually just a funny pinky shade of white. Sorry, I don't have any detailed specs for the bulb, just inferring from what it looks like and a small amount of published information. If that's what you want then compare prices with the Sylvania Gro-Lux Wide Spectrum, which also has the funny pink look (some people say oraange or purple, but nowhere near as purple as the original Gro Lux). Personally, I don't think this type of bulb is any better than a generic cool/warm combination, certainly not enough to justify the cost.

Lastly, if money is no object then buy a Metal Halide, good spectrum and lots of light. They are easy to find starting at about 100W and would be far better than fluorescents for producing high light intensity over a small area.

    Bookmark   March 4, 2005 at 6:59PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
winnjoe(MTL)

Thanks Shrubs_n_Bulbs. Money is a concern. I mentioned those two bulbs because the first was recommended by the guy at Home Depot, and the second at the 'garden centre'. I'm going to look around here for what you suggest and see what they have. Joe, Winnipeg

    Bookmark   March 5, 2005 at 11:24AM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
WHERE is your light set up?
I was wondering where you all have your light set up?...
SunshineZone7
Experience with "Sunlite" T-5 systems?
I was looking at this set up from Gardeners Supply... http://www.gardeners.com/buy/grow-light-stand-with-two-shelves/8590049.html?start=8&cgid=GrowLightsStands_Cat My...
SunshineZone7
T5 vs T8 and equivalent
Obviously T5s are the better choice for indoor growing,...
gardev
How to translate lux reading from phone app into lumens/ft2
I took a reading from where one of my succulents was...
Bama_Joe
Pepper Leaf Problem
I am new to the forum, but have a question about a...
kswart19
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™