Guidance on new tree purchase, please

idloveamochaJune 20, 2014

5 years ago, we purchased and planted an Autumn Blaze maple. It was a 30 gal. container, and the caliper was around 3".
Five years later, the 'vigorous grower' has grown a measly 5". Sure, I expected a few years of sub-par growth, but we discovered girdling roots this season. The tree has to go.

We want to replace it with another blaze. I refuse to buy another 'larger' caliper tree for fear of girdling roots.

We have two reputable nurseries in our area...and their stock is priced as such (expensive). Nursery #1 offers a 1" caliper in a 15 gallon container. Nursery #2 offers a 1.75" caliper B&B. Both are comparable in price.
I have never planted a B&B before...only container trees.

I've been reading up on the pros and cons of each, but I am still uncertain as to which way to go on this.

If you were in this situation, what would you do?

Note: I have even toyed with the idea of buying more of a whip, but I think my hubby would scoff. Plus, I am not sure where to buy reputable whips online.

Thanks!

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
gardengal48

I'd always go with the smaller size :-) It is very well documented that smaller sized/younger trees establish faster than larger specimens and will typically catch up to them in size in a single growing season. As to the advantages or disadvantages of containerized trees versus B&B, both can have pluses or minuses. Nothing wrong with a containerized planting as long as you make sure no girdling roots and loosen the rootball as best you can before planting

    Bookmark   June 20, 2014 at 3:04PM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Diffetences between the Autumn Blaze, Flame, and Fantasy?
In looking and reading on the WWW about different types...
Dmacsimus
Planting a Sugar Maple seed.
Hello! I've got a beautiful Sugar Maple in my yard,...
Pippers
Japanese cultivars requiring the least sun (Zone 5)
Japanese Maple Cultivars Requiring The Least Amount...
directorrod
Mail order source for improved silver maples?
Greetings! Brand new to the forum. This spring, I'll...
arbordavein
Central lead?
Had this tree planted in the fall and getting increasingly...
libratravel
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™