Magnolia Grandiflora in MN?

mantorvillain(z4bMN Dodge)April 17, 2014

There is a Nursery in Canada that has a specimen it rates to zone three but they don't ship to the US yet and it's waay too far for even a several day trip.
Do any of you folks know of M. Grandiflora varieties being grown successfully in MN? As you can see I'm in 4b but its been acting more like 5 the past few years (well up to this winter!). Any input will be much appreciated.
...and I already have smaller mags but am bred and born Mississipian and grew up with the great saucer magnolia...sentimental in my senility?

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
mantorvillain(z4bMN Dodge)

no responses, so bumping to let it move down

    Bookmark   May 9, 2014 at 10:45AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
leftwood(z4a MN)

No experience with them here, but if the Canadian source is in Ontario, I would be skeptical. While there are parts that do get to USDA zone 3, be aware that the Canadian zones are a little different (~about a half zone of) if that is the system they use.

All magnolias have a more fleshy root system than most other cold temperate climate woody plants, and so are more susceptible to root damage in winter. As you have probably witnessed, a heavy continuous blanket of snow through the winter keeps the soil warm. The ground here, 40 miles west of Minneapolis, thawed in February under the heavy snow, despite the longest subzero like temps practically in recorded weather history. Most of Ontario is like this every year.

Also, sustained cold air temps like this past winter for us is way different than just dipping down. I have winter burn on on several evergreens that have not ever burned in 20+ years.

    Bookmark   May 13, 2014 at 11:01AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
rockman50(6b SEMASS)

It depends what you mean by "grown successfully in MN". Do you mean a "charlie brown x-mas tree" type thing that barely survives with lots of protection or a 50 foot glorious tree with luxurious green leaves blowing in the arctic January breezes in MN? I used to live in Mpls so I am familiar with winter there. I now live in a marginal zone 7a in coastal SE Mass where I do grow southern magnolias. In my experience, there are two varieties that grow reasonably well here.....Edith Bogue and Bracken Brown Beauty. By "reasonably well" I mean they grow into small or medium sized trees 20-30 ft tall. And they bloom in early summer. The Edith Bogue is hardier and experienced no leaf damage here this winter. It is considered the hardiest southern magnolia. The Bracken Brown Beauty is less hardy and experienced about 50% burn this year here--growing in full winter sun I might add--but the branches and buds are all alive. Just for a point of reference, my location had only ONE below zero morning this winter (-7) and we average one such morning every 3 years--hence the marginal zone 7a designation. So I think if you wanted to try growing one you could try an Edith Bogue. must be small enough so that you can protect it--a lot. Zone designations are misleading because they don't include duration of cold or wind. Even a "mild" Mpls winter features many below zero mornings--and many more windy mornings with just above zero readings. And then there is that occasional day where the temp might stay below zero all day. That kind of constant assault of cold and wind probably kill even the hardiest southern Mag without protection. So build an enclosure for it. Fill it with leaves and pine needles. Then wrap it in burlap a few layers deep and hope for the best! There used to be a forum member in Mpls who I communicated with a few times many years ago. He planted a variety called "24 below" but I lost touch and I have not heard anything about that variety since. Good luck!

    Bookmark   May 15, 2014 at 8:04AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
dandy_line(3B (Brainerd, Mn))

Just an aside, most Canadians live south of here! Look it up on a map.

    Bookmark   May 15, 2014 at 10:35PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
mantorvillain(z4bMN Dodge)

I've resigned myself to not being able to grow M. Grandifolia but hope to order M. Sieboldii Collosus which is rated 4AB. What the heck, that's part of the fun.

    Bookmark   May 17, 2014 at 9:28AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

I am zone 3 and had one in my yard for two years loved the flowers and it got to about 4 foot high, it was an experimental plant from the nursery that i worked for, our winter was just to harsh for it but in zone 4 should make it - good luck it was a beauty!!!

    Bookmark   June 17, 2014 at 1:08AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

I think you are pushing your luck. MN Arboretum (SW of Twin Cities) has some bigleaf magnolias and cucumber trees, but grandiflora might be asking too much. For MN, I think cucumber tree might be your best bet for a large magnolia (otherwise there are a number or dwarf type star magnolias that will grow here)

    Bookmark   August 6, 2014 at 7:07PM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
What to do with all of my Kale?
I grew kale for the first time and really have a beautiful...
apple trees
What should you do to keep apples from insects when...
Strawberries in strawbales?
Has anyone here done the strawbale gardening? A book...
Seed catalog time
Over the past two weeks a whole lot of seed and nursery...
Minnesota Apples
Photo shows what I harvested today from the orchard...
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™