Advice on grey birch

lpinkmountain(5b/6a border PA)June 27, 2006

Last fall I planted a grey birch, Betula populifolia or something like that, anyway the native one that's not papyrifera or nigra or allegheniensis or lenta. Got it at a native plants nursery. Had aphids this spring bigtime. Sprayed with oil soap. Leaves turned brown and died. The tree is trying to re-leaf, it looks awful. I thought the PA native tree would not be as buggy as the asian or european varieties. Is this tree going to continue to be marginal? I've only seen them in the wild in the PA mountain regions. Should I cut my losses? Anyone who has experience with growing Grey birch in an urban area, advice greatly appreciated. Thanks!

Saw a "Crimson frost" vairety in the nursery that looked better but I suspect it will be susceptible to the same aphids. Is Betula lenta, black birch perhaps less buggy due to the resin? Should I just give up on birches in this urban area I live in? Other options are serviceberry or a small magnolia or maybe some type of dogwood. I'd really prefer a birch though. Not enough space for Betula nigra, River birch.

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
Pipersville_Carol(z6 Bucks PA)

Argh, that sounds frustrating.

My experience with grey birch is that they literally grow like (beautiful) weeds in a natural setting. The clump near our back pasture produces so many seedlings my husband has to mow to keep them down. It doesn't seem to have any pests. A white birch I planted died within a year, however.

I haven't had much luck planting natives, personally. Maybe they're persnickity about soil ph or something. I usually content myself with growing a named cultivar (is that the word?) of a native species. Selective breeding seems to produce sturdier plants.

Re: the serviceberry, I lost an expensive tree-form on recently. It had taken me ages to find a pair, and then one of them died. And the remaining one doesn't look too good.

The magnolia, however, is doing great.

    Bookmark   June 27, 2006 at 8:20PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
lpinkmountain(5b/6a border PA)

Just found a devil beetle on the birch. Yeah Carol, that has been my experience too, saw them growing like weeds in the wild so I thought they might be hardy in my yard. I know that birches are notorious for being short lived due to bronze birch borer, but I had read that this native was more resistant. Heck, my tree isn't even big enough around to get borers yet, and it's already had aphids and is now on to JBs.

    Bookmark   June 27, 2006 at 8:37PM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Harrisburg Garden Expo
Did anyone go this year? Why was it so small? Were...
the_lady_larrie
What kind of tree is this?
We bought a house recently and I would like to know...
Pittsburgh_Amy
Seedless Grapes
Has anyone has any success with seedless "table"...
nick_17815_pa
Need advice on digging and overwintering shrubs/perennials
We may be unexpectedly moving in late Nov/early Dec....
portia
Great full shade evergreen suggestions?
I currently have china boy holly to the left of my...
BloominOnion
Sponsored Products
Lyra Carrara Marble Vessel Sink
Signature Hardware
Cole & Co. 36" Designer Series Bridgette Vanity Chest - Dove Grey Weathered Leat
Modern Bathroom
Ceramic Bamboo Table Lamp
$299.00 | FRONTGATE
Modus Bossa 7 Piece 54 Inch Counter Height Dining Room Set
Beyond Stores
Horizontal Zipper Sofa-Bed
Dot & Bo
Belham Living Landon Extra Tall Swivel Barstool with Nailheads - WOOD H-34
$269.99 | Hayneedle
ilomio | Radius Core Pendant Light
$768.00 | YLighting
Safavieh Retro Dark Grey/ Light Grey Rug (8' x 8' Square)
Overstock.com
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™