Can FACW wet messic perennials grow in a bog w/out standing water

njbiologyJune 16, 2008


Can facultive wetland/wet messic perennials grow in a bog without standing water?

My bog has a liner and is always soggy, but without standing water as the soil has been backfilled all the way to the top of the liner at ground level.



Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
ladyslppr(z6 PA)

The important thing for plants is not whether there is or is not standing water; saturation of the soil is much more important in determining which plants will grow well. When soil is saturated the pores are all full of water, not air, which makes the diffusion of oxygen into the soil much slower. Most plant roots get the oxygen they need for respiration from the soil, and in saturated soil the oxygen supply is very slowly replaced so it gets used up by both plants and soil microbes, so as a result many types of plants suffocate in saturated soil. We usually think they drowned because of too much water, but really they suffocate because of too little oxygen at the roots. Wetland plants can transfer oxygen from the leaves to the roots, allowing them to survive in saturated soil.
Standing water is a clear indication that the soil below is saturated, but standing water isn't necessary to have saturated soil and wetland conditions, and your bog sounds like it has saturated soil.

That being said, a facultative wetland plant is one that in nature grows both in wetlands (saturated soils) and outside of wetlands, so facultative wetland plants should be able to grow in a bog, assuming other factors are OK such as pH (true bogs are usually very acidic, but your backyard bog may not be). I am not familiar with the term 'wet mesic' perennials but my guess is that it describes plants that like moist, but not saturated soil, and that a wet mesic perennial might not do well in a bog.

    Bookmark   June 20, 2008 at 9:58AM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Sowing prairie seed into snow
I am interested if anybody has experience with prairie...
establishing a prairie garden - QUACKgrass
I've started converting my lawn to a prairie with the...
More recommendations please!
Is there a grass for this? Location: N. VA mtns...Appalachian...
My California Wildflower meadow
In mid winter I cut out some grass near my front yard...
Trumpet Vines
i have a trumpet vine and it is very healthy but i...
Eric Harvilicz - PA
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™