Experience with Jack o'Lantern Pie?
I made a pie with a jack o'lantern pumpkin last year. These aren't Connecticut field of Long Island Cheese pumpkins - just your standard jack o'lantern, and a hybrid at that! I used the "Libby pie recipe." It didn't come out all that wonderful.
I make squash pies every year. That has gone on since I was a kid (my responsibility & contribution at Thanksgiving :o). Way back then, I used Pink Banana squash but have used Buttercup squash up here. Always, the "Libby pie recipe." You can find that recipe on a can of Carnation milk.
My squash pies have always been very good . . . in my not so humble opinion. Big problems in the squash patch this year but the pumpkins did great. Any ideas how I might use a jack o'lantern pumpkin for pie, maybe just with a different recipe???