Power CFL or T5 for 3ft vivarium

risingpower1(Essex, UK)August 13, 2005

The vivarium is 3'x18"x2' and there'll be orchids in there,so I'm wondering which is a better option, power cfls or t5 lighting.

All the power cfls which I've come across didn't have integrated ballasts or were only in the region of 18-23w and of course t5s have a non integrated ballast which makes them more expensive.

However, I have come across a power cfl with an integrated ballast and pretty significant output today and was wondering whether one would be enough for a 3'x18"x2' vivarium. i.e 13,500 lumens

http://www.hydroponic-shop.com/product_info.php?products_id=780

Thanks,

RP1

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
angelo_s(z6 NY)

I have t5 and they work great but I never grew orchids try posting this question on growing under lights fourm mayby they can help you

    Bookmark   August 17, 2005 at 9:33PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
dmarin(Z9 NorCal)

I'm sure T5s would be great, but the expense of them keeps me away. I've always used CFL bulbs and I'm stuck on them. My terr. is a little bit bigger than yours-4'x18x2'-and I light everything with 2 65-85W bulbs.

    Bookmark   August 24, 2005 at 11:47PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
risingpower1(Essex, UK)

Yeah t5s are looking hideously expensive, and t8 is the other option. I've now changed my mind to the 4'x2'x2' version, just for the depth.

RP1

    Bookmark   August 26, 2005 at 10:30AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
sahoyaref(Alberta z3a)

I would actually go with VHO T5s for a tank that deep. Yes, the initial cost is a lot more, but the bulbs can burn at full strength until they die (unlike CFLs, which sould be replaced every 6-12 months, and the T5s are more energy-efficient. So in the long run, you'd be saving money to go with T5s. They would both work just fine for growing orchids though, so it's really a matter of how much money you have for the initial set-up.

    Bookmark   August 31, 2005 at 8:22PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
risingpower1(Essex, UK)

Well the orchids are going to be around 4"-6" away from the lights needing the highest light levels of say 2000fc, I'm still thinking t5hos, or t8 38w x 4.

Was considering gro lux t8s until I thought about what it would make the tank look like.

Now thinking 4 x t8 ge polyluxs, 2 in warm white, 2 in cold white(unfortunately there's no daylight or interna versions in 38w).

I can't really find any suitable t5hos for the tank though, unless you can name any suitable tubes.

RP1

    Bookmark   August 31, 2005 at 8:38PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
homer_zn5(z5 IN)

I really don't think there is much difference between the T-5's and CFL's, as far as what I have read. Some of my CFL ballasts say "T-5" on them, but are rated for 96 watt CFL's, and the lumen output per watt is nearly identical from the scant information I have found from manufacturers.

Further, my understanding of T-5's (which is not written in stone, but is my understanding) is that they are simply CFL's in linear form (all CFL's are "bent back" on themselves). Therefore, the only additional efficiency gained with a T-5 is from the fact that the tube is in a straight line, rather than bent back on itself, so that some of the light is not being shot into the tube right beside it (which happens in the case of CFL's--light shot back into the tubes doesn't reach the terrarium, and is merely converted to heat--inefficient).

With that said, I can also say that the recommendation to replace CFL's every 6 months is hooey. I used mine for over 3 years before replacing them, and they were used when I got them. I have Dendrobiums and Oncidiums growing and blooming regularly in a terrarium (2'x 2' x 2') with those three 40 watt CFL bulbs over it. Upon replacing the bulbs (original bulbs were 3000k bulbs, replacements were two 4100k bulbs and one 6500k bulb), I can honestly see not appreciable difference in light output or growth response from the plants.

Just my thoughts and experiences, for what it is worth. Go with whatever works for your space and is most cost effective for the lumen output you need.

All the best.

    Bookmark   October 5, 2005 at 3:40PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
tfraleigh(Ont)

Im actually looking into lighting a 3 foot tank too. I think I'm settling for the 2x56w CF kit from from ahsupply.com
And yea, I have orchids in mine too.

I may upgrade to VHO's way down the road, but I think that CF's would be fine, and cheaper initially (long term does, as mentioned depend on how often you change bulbs and incorperate the fact that they are slightly less energy efficiant).

I've never tried Hydroponic Grow lights though, so I cant give any input there.

    Bookmark   October 6, 2005 at 12:34AM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Fungus gnats
Hey everyone, I recently turned a 10 gal aquarium into...
lrn2gro
Browning fern in powder at bottom of terrarium?
Hi guys, The first week (of 3 months of hainvg the...
tiffanylam38
Fungus in container
i am trying to grow a terrarium for the first time....
babcia
Plant I.D.
Hello! I was wondering about the identity of this plant....
Jeffrey Schneider
overwintering maidenhair fern in cloche
In the late fall I dug up and potted my Maidenhair...
ladycave
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™