hardy magnolias or other flowering trees?

catskillcottage(z5 NY)April 24, 2005

Does anyone have experience with planting hardy magnolias in the upstate/Catskill climate? I'm dreaming of planting a Magnolia 'butterflies' tree, which is listed as being hardy to zones 6,5,or 4 depending on the web site. I am technically zone 5 in Delaware Cty. but consider myself 4 after losing a few too many plants. Has anyone planted a hardy magnolia and had it thrive, or not? Other flowering trees that have been successful? Thanks, Erin

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
jannie(z7 LI NY)

I don't have any magnolias myself, but theres a star magnolia tree I drive by every spring. It's located on state-owned land next to a roadway. Been there at least three years, from a distance seems quite healthy. It is in zone 6, central Long Island NY. Apparently never tended. Except the grass is mown semi-regularly.

    Bookmark   April 24, 2005 at 12:12PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
kareen(z5 NY Renss.Co.)

I am north of you in zone 5 and have had one for almost 30 years. It started out as a 1 or 2 foot plant and is just magnificent now. If you go to the garden section of my link below you can see it ..that pic was taken a few years ago.
I think it should be fine in your area. Kareen

Here is a link that might be useful: Our pond and gardens

    Bookmark   April 24, 2005 at 6:38PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
orcuttnyc(z5-6 NY)

I'm in lower Orange County. But, up in the mountains. I'm about ten degress cooler and about two weeks behind the blooming of NYC.
My five foot high, two years in my ground, magnolia, has its first white flower this spring!
My four year(in my ground) old apple trees have their first flowers now as well! Perhaps this will be my first year of fruit!!!
I keep telling my wife that by the time we are one hundred and fifty years old...we're going to have a beautifull garden...

    Bookmark   April 25, 2005 at 6:39AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
bloomville(z4 NY)

I am very interested in this same question, as I have a weekend place in Delaware Co. and am also considered Z4, and LOVE the magnolia here in Brooklyn so much! Wayside Gardens has at leat two magnolias they say are hardy to Z4...on the other hand, I don't see anyone up here with magnolias, which leads me to wonder...

However, my experience in watching two magnolias within a couple hundred feet of each other in my Bklyn backyard has also convinced me of the importance of looking at microclimates when planting delicate creatures like magnolias; each year (I have observed this for at least the past 6 years), there is a full 10-day to 2-week difference in the blooming of these two otherwise identical trees. So maybe the trick is placement...finding a little patch of Z5 on your otherwise Z4 terrain. Just a thought, for what it's worth. Good luck!

    Bookmark   April 25, 2005 at 8:16AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
oldroser(z5)

I have a very hardy hybrid magnolia and it has done fine with temperatures down to 20 below 0. It's almost finished blooming now but it was a sight last week. The only problem I have is that it is growing taller than expected and has to be cut back so as not to interfere with the telephone wires. I think its name is Merrill. It's a hybrid of the star magnolia but is much bigger and much hardier.

    Bookmark   April 25, 2005 at 9:59PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
dbclaverack

Catskillcottage, I'm interested in knowing if you went ahead w/ the 'Butterfly' planting. I am in the mood for a magnolia and thought Butterfly was a beauty. What happened?

    Bookmark   September 14, 2006 at 4:33PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
Carol_from_ny

I'm in the Binghamton area. I planted a magnolia 10 years ago. It started out as not much more than a twig and for several years seemed to grow rather slowly. This year it's just taken off.
Mine is in a somewhat sheltered area near the house.
My mother who use to live in the area also planted one a good 30 years ago it too grew very slowly...hers was a different type...less leafy than mine.
The scent from the flowers in the spring is truly worth the wait!

    Bookmark   September 15, 2006 at 5:47PM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
ID this Critter?
These are showing up on my Joe Pye Weed in the early...
wantoretire_did
Help with ID this plant
We visited Rockport Maine in September and noticed...
p.polyxenes
brugmansia
I absolutely love the looks of these trumpet plants,...
younggreenthumb47
What do you do to keep the deer from nibbling your plants?
A gal in our garden club has had a horrible time with...
jean_mdc
Asiatic Lilly buds gone
It happened last year and I just noticed again today....
wantoretire_did
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™