Meal Worm castings versus Earthworm castings?

californianMay 29, 2010

I was wondering if anyone knows which is a better fertilizer or soil amendment? Also price wise, it appears that meal worm castings are much cheaper to buy than earthworm castings, in fact I read some places give them away for free. Is the extra cost of earthworm castings worth it? Also, how many pounds of castings does the average home worm farm produce a year? Five pounds or 500 pounds or what?

BTW, mealworms are immature darkling beetles, and I don't know if either the beetles or mealworms would be harmful to garden plants, that is, eat them or their roots.

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

With no factual knowledge or expertiese I feel free meal worm castings would have the same value as free starbucks coffee grounds. I would put the meal worm castings into a bird feeder the birds could easily scatter the stuff to look through it. You might attract some cool birds. Around the feeder the ground would benifit so plant something to grow wild. Putting some into the worm bins should be fine too. I would not try to make beer out of them. :-) Free is good. Organic material is good. It probably does not have a high salt content. I do not think the bugs will survive out of their natural habitat.

    Bookmark   May 30, 2010 at 1:11AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Years ago i had a pet store and also my own private collection of reptiles. I used to raise mealworms so i could have freshly hatched mealworms to feed baby herps that were just too small to handle the ones from the commercial growers.

The castings went into my houseplants and they did great. So if you get them for free, go for it.

Now as far as which is better, mealworm or earthworm castings, my intuition says earthworm. My reasoning goes like this:

The digestive process is different. The mealworms eat 'meal' a mixture of grains etc. They convert the sugars and protein pretty much directly into their own protein and fat.

With the earthworm, they can do the same to some degree if the particulate size is small enough. However they mainly rely on microbes to break down the cellulose and macrostarches of their foods into sugars and amino acids in a form they can absorb. The resultant feces is filled with microbes that seem to have an extra beneficial effect in garden soil. You can look up some studies on this and comments of mucous-like compounds that offer surfactant effects, etc.

    Bookmark   May 30, 2010 at 8:39AM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Serving up a tray of worms
Just thought I'd share a pic of my worm project. Been...
David Myhra
putting bin outside to deal with fly problem?
I have been trying to deal with an infestation of flies since...
cow manure
I've always heard about horse manure but I've only...
Seed Swap
Due to Garden Web being houzz and everybody being unhappy,...
Chuckie's shoe totes
I'm gearing up for spring and milk jug AACT to use...
Sponsored Products
Best Quality Lighting Path & Landscape Lights LV15SLV Landscape Lighting Spot
$70.00 | Home Depot
Campania International Rioja Planter - Set of 2 - 8924-13402
$769.99 | Hayneedle
Green La Maison 5-Qt. Oval Casserole Dish
$54.99 | zulily
LEDme 4" Spackle Square Trim by WAC Lighting
$36.00 | Lumens
Pale Ice Glass Bowl
$1,475.00 | Horchow
Hinkley Lighting | Karma 41950 Chandelier
$999.00 | YLighting
Schonbek La Scala Collection 16 1/2" Wide Crystal Chandelier
Lamps Plus
Woodbridge Lighting Manchester 6-light Charcoal Chandelier
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™