pump flips yard gfi, but not house gfi

GWSunfishOctober 25, 2002

This could be a mind teaser.....

These events occurred last week during our 7 inches of rain and continues with the rain....

If an answer occurs to you someday, please let me know?

Septic system:

Gravity flow into 2-500 conc. tanks, then

into 4x6' conc. culvert w/ 4/10hp sump pump & check valve that

sends water uphill via 1.25-1.5" PVC 100 yards, 8-10' head to

a 300 gal. fiberglass tank that gravity distributes effluent to subterranean septic lines

When the house was built in 1980, the electrician brought power to the pump from the HVAC disconnect fuse box via


10/2 "Romex", conduit only at above ground locations,

55' to a GFI J-box into which the pump was plugged

(covered by a weather cover and a plastic hood from rain and soil poisoned against ants shorting it out)


The less than one year old GFI 15amp outlet flipped with the beginning of a gully washer and continued to flip when ever

the pump (but not a simple light) was plugged in during the following days of rain.

The normal temporary solution has been to plug the pump into a 100' 12/2 cord, then into the 15amp GFI weatherproof

house outlet on the covered porch.

This worked.

Assumption was that flooding from the rain entered the culvert and the pump was overloaded, requiring a drier, perhaps

larger amp outlet.

The 15amp outlet was replaced with another GFI, but 20amp.

This solution did not last long, as the next rain flipped the outlet again under pump loads but not light loads

Again, the (inferior) extension cord solution worked.

It was assumed that the 22 year old underground power line had insulation issues that allowed its bare wire contact with

the soil, causing a GFI reading and flipping the outlet (breaker) in very wet, soil penetrating weather - perhaps a

landscape "steel edge" had driven down enough to slice the insulation.

The 10/2 underground cable was replaced with a 12/2 cable.

The outlet again performed under light loads of a light, but flipped under the pump loads.

The pump continued to work with the extension cord to house.

The lid was removed from the pump culvert and a water hose with power spray was used to clean off all exposed surfaces

of tank, pump, etc. and under the pump area. Repeatedly, the pump emptied the clean water.

Thereafter, the pump successfully operated on the new 20amp GFI outlet supplied by the new underground 12/2 cable UNTIL

another lightning storm moved in and "flipped" it. Since then, I have used the extension cord to covered porch GFI

(dry) outlet.

Other evidence I should supply is that a description of the power box/HVAC disconnect fuse box that is mounted on the

redwood siding wall that originally supplies the underground wire to the GFI yard outlet into which the septic pump


It is metal and has the original plastic conduit protecting the underground "septic/GFI" wire into the ground a few

inches. However, a few years ago, we added a whirlpool tub GFI outlet, so the electrician used metal conduit that runs

near the ground, along this redwood wall and connects into this metal disconnect fuse box, in order to supply power

through the exterior bath wall. All wiring in the metal disconnect box grounds to the box. Although I have a generous

38" roof overhang/soffit at least 8'0" above grade in the location of the disconnect box, it does get wet .. so does its

metal conduit .... could this "wet connection" to grade be affecting a new 20a. GFI outlet under heavy pump loads, but

not under tiny light bulb loads?

A description of the outlet box is that is metal, 1980 on a plastic conduit stuck into the ground to protect the

underground wire.

A description of the pump is 4/10hp, new as of Jan '01.

Local electricians do not have an answer, so


Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
eaglesc_technowhacko(z7/8 SC)

Gfi's do notlast forever
Whats the amp rating/usage of pump when under load?
Continuity test of line
I'd check these if local electricians haven't
I am not an electrician

    Bookmark   November 1, 2002 at 8:03AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
john_4b(z4b WI)

I have had similar problems with a remote GFI outlet cutting out when used for a pond pump and outdoor lighting in periods of very heavy rainfall. Usually after the rainfall subsides, a day or so later after some drying occurs, the GFI can be reset and will work with no problem again. Excessive wet weather and high humidity seemed to be the problem. Check all wire connections, and use silicone sealant to seal against water leaks into fittings and cables. I think this helped in my case.

    Bookmark   December 2, 2002 at 4:17PM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Arborvitae planting in the winter
As many already know, the cold came much earlier this...
How protect outdoor containers in winter?
How do you protect your containers plants in winter?...
Can I plant Winter Greens over my Newly Planted Garlic Bed?
First time winter gardening. Zone 6, Southeastern MA....
Fall / Winter veggies in a straw bale garden?
I have had success using the straw bale garden method...
my winter container veggie garden
Collards, Swiss Chard, Kale, and Red Sails Lettuce,...
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™