Return to the African Violets Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Cut it or leave it?

Posted by froeschli 6b (My Page) on
Mon, Jul 7, 14 at 11:26

This is my last leaf of pink dove. I has some roots, but no mouse ears yet. Everything else I got at the convention has babies by now (or died all the way).
The 'spot' is growing very slowly, so I've been leaving it, but I am getting a bit worried, because I was hoping to have plant lets before it's overtaking the entire leaf...

So, leave it, or chop it?

Thanks,

Karin


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Cut it or leave it?

And the back:


 o
RE: Cut it or leave it?

If you cut the damaged part all the way you have a better chance of having the leaf continue to grow and produce babies. If you leave the brown spot it will only continue to get larger and eventually rot the entire leaf. I would definitely cut it.


 o
RE: Cut it or leave it?

I, too, take a clean blade and trim away damaged parts of leaves that start to "go." It often works out fine.

Just seconding what Chiqui said. I use a razor blade.

Diana


 o
RE: Cut it or leave it?

I'm in agreement,

Cut out the bad & possibly dust with Cinnamon?

best of luck! (love the leaf variegation)


 o
RE: Cut it or leave it?

Thanks,
I figured I'd have to cut it but didn't want to admit it...
Now I just have to wait and see if it will stay healthy & sprout.

Karin


 o
RE: Cut it or leave it?

You could just sit and watch the whole thing rot ;) If you trim the bad back to healthy tissue, it has a good chance.

Now this is new for me. I've had several (mostly small ones) where the leaf looked fine but when I tugged them, the whole stem had rotted. Sometimes it was one of a pair. I now have the leaf top set of one. I don't quit easily.

Diana


 o
RE: Cut it or leave it?

I had two leaves do this. Best I can tell is, they probably touched the side of the Baggie. it's not mushy-rot just a slow turning brown...

As for rotting stems, yup, had those too, and perfectly healthy looking ones in the evening, then gray and dead in the morning. Sometimes I think I am working on perfecting ways to kill my plants...

Then I decide to try again.


 o
RE: Cut it or leave it?

This isn't the greatest photo, but it is a picture of some leaves I set toward the end of April. It's hard to see but notice the (shaky) arrow and the circles? After I set them, I lost most of the big variegated leaf to rot, the tip of the other leaf, and one whole small leaf. I would have blamed it on them touching the side of the box, except the little leaf wasn't even crowded. (I do know how to do better lines, just couldn't do it that night.)

However, I did rearrange them so they didn't touch the sides. Now most of them have babies. The "twin" of the tiny leaf has plantlets, the one with the trimmed tip has them, and the big variegated ones are firmly rooted and the whole one has them down under. There was probably about 1/4 left of that other leaf but it held on and rooted. As I recall, the problems occurred quite soon after I set them so I think they may have been a little chilled since the damage was so spotty.

Diana


 o
RE: Cut it or leave it?

Do you root them in perlite vermiculite mix?


 o
RE: Cut it or leave it?

Yes. That's what I use.

Diana


 o
RE: Cut it or leave it?

Trim the spot away taking it a bit into the healthy area. Dust the cut edge with cinnamon.

Linda


 o
RE: Cut it or leave it?

Diana, Nice Photo, thanks!
Joanne


 o
RE: Cut it or leave it?

Mix the cinnamon with sugar, put on toast with butter ;) Mmmm.

Thanks, Joanne. Not the greatest of photos but those leaves were trimmed and came through just fine so I thought it might help. I trimmed that Wrangler's several times and didn't think it would survive it but it did.

(I have never used anything on the cuts but I do try to let them dry off before covering them over with the bag or whatever.)

Diana


 o
RE: Cut it or leave it?

A bit jagged, but done, and I managed not to cut into the big vein. Bits of the cut edge turned a bit rusty coloured, so I'll have to keep an eye on that.


 o
RE: Cut it or leave it?

It looks fine. The main thing is to get the dying tissue so it doesn't keep spreading.

Diana


 o
RE: Cut it or leave it?

I find the cinnamon really helps keep the rot from spreading. I have a leaf that I had to cut down to almost nothing and it is beginning to send up babies. It is about the size of my little fingernail.

Linda


 o
RE: Cut it or leave it?

It may help. Generally it seems as though cutting out the bad spot works all right too if the rest of the leaf is healthy.

I just saw that someone was dipping the stems in cinnamon before setting them and claimed that helped with rot. Ever try that?

I lost another one that way but it was an iffy leaf anyway. The other one is fine. Since these have all been duplicates, even from people who do not routinely send 2 leaves, I wonder if they knew they weren't top quality, thus the extra. (I appreciate it.) I think the high heat has taken its toll here also with one starting to go bad. I'm taking the babies off it now.

I'm just too cheap to put cinnamon on everything. I did use a rooting hormone for its fungicidal properties on holiday cactus cuttings after one had begun to rot. That worked fine.

It's too bad no one ever does actual studies on anything for african violets. Every time I apply anything, I wonder if it has some bad side effect that no one knows about.

Diana


 o
RE: Cut it or leave it?

I usually send 2 leaves in a trade. Not because I know they're not top quality (I wouldn't send them if they weren't), but just in case one leaf doesn't make it. Some people only send one leaf, but, in my experience, a majority of people will send 2 of each variety. It's not a reflection on the quality of the leaf.


 o
RE: Cut it or leave it?

These are not traders but vendors, Vivey. Generally the one only sends one leaf. Occasionally there's more but one is the norm there.

Diana


 o
RE: Cut it or leave it?

Optimara and Lyon's sent two leaves each time.
Cinammon works really well for me.
Joanne

This post was edited by fortyseven on Sat, Jul 12, 14 at 2:15


 o
RE: Cut it or leave it?

Most commercials say how many leaves they send. Some will occasionally include an additional one, same variety. Lyons never. I doubt Optimara does but only ordered once (still I was pleased with their leaves.)

I don't think you can compare people who trade with commercial vendors. It's like apples and oranges.

Diana


 o
RE: Cut it or leave it?

I was wondering about that too. Bloomlovers for example says they ship one leaf (or that's how i understood it) but at the convention they had two per package...

i was just asked if i would share leaves and i automatically looked if i could spare two per plant (they are small still). one just seems so final, if you lose it....

karin


 o
RE: Cut it or leave it?

I much prefer two, even 3 is nice on some tiny or difficult varieties. I just took plants off leaves of Happy Harold. The cat had knocked him over for something like the 7th time and I'd set two leaves. Oddly enough, only one had produced babies, something like 5 although I didn't really count. I didn't actually need more Harolds. Still, if my own leaves act like that, why wouldn't a vendor's? The other one was well rooted.

I just looked over my Bloomlovers leaves (so I don't buy stuff I have). Now I know I messed up a time or two and ordered two, but she may have sent a two of some other ones. I do know that she appears more likely to send multiples of the unregistered and, possibly less popular? ones. Apparently I thought I was going to get a bigger house... When you get two varieties in a solo cup, that's a lot of potential plants. I haven't lost a variety yet there although I've lost a leaf or two or three. However you know what to expect and any extra are just ....extra.

Diana


 o
RE: Cut it or leave it?

I also prefer 2 leaves over a single one. There have been a few I've ordered, like from Bloomlovers, and lost the leaf - thus losing that future plant in my collection as well. Much nicer to have 2 leaves just in case. At least that way I don't feel like I've paid money for something I don't have.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the African Violets Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here