Return to the Aquariums Forum | Post a Follow-Up

Butterfly koi in a aquarium..

Posted by lljdma06 10 Miami (My Page) on
Sun, Aug 7, 05 at 22:03

I am new to this forum and I would like some advice.

I am currently going to school in IL, but my concern is with my too small fishtank in Miami. It is being well cared for by my family, and the fish are fine, I would just like some advice on an upgrade.

In my 45-gallon hex, I know too small and wrong shape, I have two fish. I have one 9 inch red and white comet, but the main attraction is a foot long golden butterfly koi, not including fins. I have a very powerful back filter to keep things clean, but I would like to upgrade to a much larger system.

My family and I have discussed a pond, but the feral cat population in our neighborhood is way to large and too agressive. The koi in question was only 7 inches with fins when I bought it five years, ago, and it's doing extremely well. It even eats from my hand as good koi do.

Any advice regarding setting him up in a new home? I've kept lots of tanks in the past, but am a little scared to go so large. It sounds like a wonderful idea, but just a little scary. I'm interested in type, size, stand, and about how much should I be looking to invest in that kind of system.

Thank you very much, and I look forward to hearing from you soon.


Follow-Up Postings:

RE: Butterfly koi in a aquarium..

I would look in the local classifieds for a tank. Fair value is a $1 a gallon used. I found one in my local paper 125gallon with filter and other equiptment for $150. If you are handy you can save alot of $$$ with DIY tank stands, Lighting(especialy is the tank is 48" long like 50,75 and 90 gals.)and even filtration. If you need some ideas for DIY let me know. I am planning an indoor pond/aquarium down the road. It will be in my basement when I get arround to finishing it. I was going to use all local natural rock for constructin with a pond liner but have side veiws with acrylic "windows". This link has some good ideas I have a lot of others that are also good or just do a search for DIY aquaria, Good Luck.

Here is a link that might be useful: DIY site

RE: Butterfly koi in a aquarium..

At only a foot in 5 years, it's clear that the current tank has kept your butterfly koi pretty small in comparison to pond koi. Definitely don't go smaller than a 100 gallon tank - larger if you can. Your comet will also benefit from the size of the tank.

DO keep in mind that koi also tend to love to leap up and out of water from time to time - so you want a good fitting lid as well.

Another consideration if you have a spot in your house that can take the weight load is to build an indoor pond setting. This is something I'm considering to do for my indoor fancy goldfish since I have a porch area that has a concrete floor. This way you can make new digs for your fish the size and shape you want.

RE: Butterfly koi in a aquarium..

  • Posted by kirap Alabama Z9 (My Page) on
    Wed, Aug 10, 05 at 20:14

IMHO a koi does not belong in any aquarium except perhaps for a short tuerm QT treatment. They just grow to large for such an environment and are a heavy load on any filter system typically found on most aquariums. I fyour bf koi is as small as it is its stunted for sure either by insufficient feeding or its environment. The koi in addition to a 9" goldie is just a bad setup. My GF grow from small feeders to well over 6" in length in less than a year in my pond, and my koi are all well over a foot long by 1 year of age. NOt trying to sound harsh, but koi and gf as such are not aquarium fishes. You can get by with some of the fancy ornamental GF breeds like a black moor or Ryunkin etc, but the red/white (usually a sarrasa) and koi are just not suitable. Build a pond and net it. Lots of folks like me live in the boonies with lots of natural predators and raise koi and gf just fine.......there is ways to deal with predators such as feral cats.

RE: Butterfly koi in a aquarium..

Thank you woeisme for some great advice, especially regarding fair pricing and the DIY links. Now, I feel better knowing I won't break my bank account.

I also appreciate your imput on the cover and the possibility of an indoor pond, Skygee. All my tanks have been covered since my first aquarium, over 15 years ago, when I had a suicidal Harlequin rasbora, who jumped out the tank 4 times and then lived 2 more years after the last jump! But the new tank will for sure be covered. My turkish Angora, Lily, would just love it if I put my koi in an indoor pond, but I don't think she'll get her wish.

Now, for clarification, I acknowledged in my initial post that I am well aware that the environment for my koi and goldfish is not ideal, so I would be grateful if the focus of future posts would not be on how bad my setup is, which no matter how well-worded, is still harsh and not, I believe, the point of the learning environment of a forum. Please focus instead on advice on how to upgrade to a 125+ gallon system.

Also, a pond, whether indoor or outdoor, is just not an option for me, so if this is your opinion, then just don't reply to my initial post. I know that there is debate on this issue, so I'd rather not cause trouble.

I appreciate everyone's imput so far, and I will carefully weigh all my options before I make my final decision.

Warmest regards,


RE: Butterfly koi in a aquarium..

I can understand your hesitation to put the koi outside... especially when you've enjoyed him inside all this time!

My suggestion is to make the tank (this is if you're going the DIY route) as wide as possible, along with being long. Koi really do like to be able to "stretch their fins" and swim. GF and Koi do produce quite a bit of waste, which is why if anything concentrate on a good filtering system to keep the water as clean as possible - along with being rigidly routine about water changes. On my goldfish tank (seriously overcrowded and I myself have to start thinking upgrade - hence my thoughts on indoor pond) I have two filters - a marineland biowheel filter and an eheim cannister filter. It keeps the water crystal clear and clean. I DO have to make sure I'm doing a 25% water change at least every two weeks if not every week - which is easy enough to do with the Python water changing system.

If you go to the pond site, you will find folks who will say not less than 100 gallons per koi to not less than 500 gallons per koi!! There are also folks out there in this country that want the town of Fishkill, NY to change its name because it's current name sounds cruel to fish (although "kill" is a Dutch word for river or stream, which is why it's called Fishkill. Go figure!) So don't take any stuff you read here or on any other message boards too personally. Just glean the info that you know is useful for your situation.

On a side note... I do have an outdoor pond. It's definitely a challenge when dealing with outdoor predators, but it IS doable. Something to think about in the far future (although you may not want to put your koi out there immediately until you would be perfectly assured that you've figured out the best methods to keep your fish safe!)

Good luck.

RE: Butterfly koi in a aquarium..

I think a 125 gal would be suitable. 6' of side to side "should" be adequate. I never had Koi before so I am not to familiar with the breed. A good sump style filter is a good idea for larger tanks. You can make the sump as large as you want. It can be stored under the tank in a cabinet. The larger the sump the more water you actually have. Also media changes are simple as long as you design it right. The DIY link should have some examples. Another option is a filter like the "magnum" series by Marineland. They usually come with a micron cartridge as well as a every day cartridge. The micron filter is for "polising" the water. The addition of a few Tbsp. of D.E.powder before the micron cartridge will remove even more crud. You can polish as part of a weekly routine or as needed.

RE: Butterfly koi in a aquarium..

I recently began keeping Butterfly Koi in an aquarium. Would you be willing to share your experiences on Aquarium’s Butterfly Koi at it's a new forum I created for just Butterfly Koi owners who prefer raise them in aquariums than ponds.

There will be no judging or condemning fish keeping habits at Aquarium’s Butterfly Koi. Keep in mind that it is a new forum. So if you are interested just register and start posting.

Here is a link that might be useful: Aquarium’s Butterfly Koi

 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!

Return to the Aquariums Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.

Learn more about in-text links on this page here