Return to the Arizona Gardening Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Raised beds against cinderblock walls?

Posted by bamf z9 AZ (My Page) on
Mon, Sep 18, 06 at 18:59

My yard, like 99.9% of the yards in Arizona, is surrounded by a 6' high concrete block wall (the variety with the 20' x 4" deep 'wall' sections between 8" 'columns').

I'm putting in some 18" high raised beds and the back of these beds will end up against the block wall. This is probably not such a good thing since I'm not certain the wall can handle the weight of the dirt, and then there's the moisture-seep/discoloration problem that my neighbor will likely end up with.

To alleviate these problems, my plan has been to erect a separate free-standing 18" high wall at the back of the bed (also probably out of concrete block) to support the weight and to prevent direct contact of the dirt with the old wall.

This solution sounds like it might have it's own issues (not the least of which is cost), so I'm wondering if anyone has any better ideas?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Raised beds against cinderblock walls?

I had almost the exact same situation in my garden. 18" high up on a cinder block wall that I shared with my neighbor.

We didn't see so much white discoloration because that is usually associated with leeching of salt from below the soil lines. Since I imported a garden mix from a local gravel yard, there wasn't a salt problem like you'll find in native soil.

There aren't too many plants that would do well against a cinder wall in the summer, but with the fall/winter season approaching you might be able to plant right up on the wall.
Also, a watering system that drips water to the base of the plant will help reduce this issue. I don't know what you're planting in this bed, but chances are that you'll need room away from the wall for the plant to grow up and spread out.

A dripper near the base of your plant, or a deep soak less regularly, may help your problems too.


 o
RE: Raised beds against cinderblock walls?

I am thinking of also building raised beds next to my block walls. For years we had a wood fence with Oleandors. All gone now. Couldn't I paint the block wall up to the height of a raised bed? Seems like there should be a masonry paint that would resist moisture.


 o
RE: Raised beds against cinderblock walls?

  • Posted by hoku1 8/Tucson (My Page) on
    Tue, Sep 19, 06 at 11:13

When we moved in, our landscapers built us a corner raised bed in the back. I had told him I wanted roses and herbs, so that is where he said the sun would be best. These walls are so sturdy, I don't think there is any danger from the pressure of soil, or too much water. One side backs onto a common area of desert. The first year, I planted sweetpeas against the wall of my bed. Wel, for many years after, sweetpeas sprouted on the other side of the wall! I guess the seeds dropped down there, and the water seeped underneath to keep them watered. The other side of the wall is shared with a neighbor, but she has gravel mulch, so if there is a water problem, she never sees it. We planted tombstone rose in the corner and carolina jasmine on both sides against the wall. These plants keep the wall cooler and look nice as a backdrop, but now they are a pain to trim because they have gotten so big. Its hard to keep them trimmed close to the wall so as not interfere with the roses. I think the idea was good, but we planted too many of them. The roses do great. I have lavendars on the other side of the bed and they are doing great, too. The soil in the bed has sand in it, so it drains well.


 o
RE: Raised beds against cinderblock walls?

Well I will be the voice of dissention and suggest you go with your original instinct and install the interior 18" wall. I say this because you can never tell just how strong or weak those block walls are around here. You need to be absolutely sure the wall can take the extra weight before you put it there or else you are looking at a very costly repair. Reinforce the interior and exterior walls with rebar.

As far as the water stains, I thank you for thinking about your neighbor (perhaps you can discuss this with my neighbor, they apparently have no regard...) Anyway, it is easy enough to put an emulsion on the block wall that will water seal the thing, then you dont have to worry about it. Home Depot will have the stuff, just ask someone there to show you.


 o
RE: Raised beds against cinderblock walls?

I suggest tar for a lining. Definately line both walls with it. Inside of the walls of course where it will be covered by dirt. Nothing else will be permanent. It comes in a big bucket from home depot. It is cheap and it works like nothing else. If you don't use something you will have leaching from water and salt. I even had some water draining out through the cracks. We used the tar our second time around and it is a dream. It is messy to do but you won't regret it. Water leaching into the wall can also weaken it.

I have had two raised beds of this kind and have been extremly happy with them. My only other suggestion is to consider more than 18". About 3' can give you more depth to layer your plantings. Put big plants in back and small ones up front. You would even have room for a dwarf tree maybe.


Good luck.


 o
RE: Raised beds against cinderblock walls?

When I lived in Santa Fe, I had a really nice raised bed garden against a cinder-block wall. The wall itself was stuccoed and was on the south and west side of the house.
I grew raspberries, apples, nectarines, plums, honesuckle, Russian sage, irises, silver lace vine, roses, yarrow, gaillardia, coreopsis, penstemmon, purple coneflower, and some impossible-to-destroy bindweed along the wall.
It was pretty impressive in the spring and summer. The wall kept in the day's warmth as the temp dropped at night, and sheltered much of the garden from harsh afternoon sun.
It also helped to retain moisture in the soil along with heavy mulching.
I had no problems with discoloration or with injuring the wall. Most cinder-block walls are strengthened when builders erect them with steel rods inserted into the hollow cinder blocks and driven deeply into the ground.
I even put a compost pile in one corner and had no problems there either.

Here is a link that might be useful: Desert Gardens


 o
RE: Raised beds against cinderblock walls?

I am planning exactly the same thing and have been entertaining bids from local contractors (it is entertaining). Yes you need to have the interior retaining wall if you current cinder block wall is not a retaining wall. Most of these walls are built more like fences and only have a 6 inch foundation, this is not strong enought to hold several tons of wet soil. A good way to check and see if your wall may be a retaining wall is to see whather your neighbors yard is on the same level as yours. If yours is say higher then it is likely that your current wall may be a retaining wall already i.e. it is already built to stop your yard from falling into their yard.

Definately use the tar on the back walls and you might even consider drainage pipes coming out of the front face so that should your planter bed flood during heavy rain etc there is an escape for the excess water other than over the top of your bed.


 o
RE: Raised beds against cinderblock walls?

I did the same thing you are considering during the summer, and my wall between myself and the neigbor is exactly like yours, but textured and painted with 2 heavy coats of exterior paint. The bed portion against that wall is about 40 feet long, with 16" block front (4 high by 4"), and the dirt mounds to about 20" in the back. In between the sturdier support columns and the large drip system cement enclosure I made an interior retaining support system in 2 parts, made up of pressure treated 2x6's nailed to 8' by 2' 5'8 plywood, shaved at the top, and reinforced every 2 feet with 3/4 x 3 foot rebar. It is not visible above the mounding dirt, and it is 6" away from the wall itself. I placed dirt in between but did not pack, and being unamended clay, does not really allow water to soak in thus remaining dry and semi loose underneath. My main dirt area is ammended with peat moss, sand, and mulch, and my drip hoses occupy the area between the retaining system and the wall. I do not believe much weight, if any is against the dividing wall, as I filled it after the main area was filled, and have run a 36" metal spike in there well after and it ws not compacted at all. I finished in July, and the subsequent heavy rains of the summer did not impact the wall at all. If you want some pics, email me @ pheitmeyer@imagetag.com


 o
RE: Raised beds against cinderblock walls?

  • Posted by bamf z9 AZ (My Page) on
    Wed, Sep 27, 06 at 20:06

> I made an interior retaining support system in 2 parts,
> made up of pressure treated 2x6's nailed to 8' by 2' 5'8
> plywood, shaved at the top, and reinforced every 2 feet
> with 3/4 x 3 foot rebar.

So you're using some kind of treated plywood as well?


 o
RE: Raised beds against cinderblock walls?

No, the plywood isn't treated, just the main support of the thicker lumber. I figured that once the 5/8 thick plywood started to fail, that the dirt would be so settled that the sideways forces would be almost nil.


 o
RE: Raised beds against cinderblock walls?

Your ideas sound good, and also seem to add a bit of insulation for the soil. Would enjoy seeing the pictures, pheitmeyer.


 o
RE: Raised beds against cinderblock walls?

What would you do for up against your house? I can't make that part very deep, so cinder blocks wouldn't be very practical. I was thinking maybe the same type of frame as my free standing raised bed- with lumber on all 4 sides to protect the house. Is this necessary or too much?


 o
RE: Raised beds against cinderblock walls?

Personally, if you live in a house like I do (cookie cutter stucco and chickenwire), you'll want more than a piece of wood between wet dirt and the house. Here is what I did:
block wall (fence block) for the bed
reinforced with rebar and block wire (those little ladder looking things :) )
coated the inside of the planter with waterproof stucco
tarred the waterproof stucco
No leaks what so ever, and it has been four years. Might want to try that.

Gene.


 o
RE: Raised beds against cinderblock walls?

I have flowerbeds against my wall and I haven't had much problem with the water issue (use drip lines), my problem has been my dogs running it to death trying to get the lizards that get on the wall. I've tried fencing it but they jump the fence. Now I'm trying a new approach. I'm still going to grow my vines on the wall with some protection around their base from the dogs. I'm going out about 6 ft and building 4'x8' raised beds. I'm going to make 3 to start and leave enough room to mow between them.
Hopefully the vines will help shade and color the wall.

gemfire


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Arizona Gardening Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here