Return to the Bamboo Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Bamboo ID Help needed ! Photo heavy...

Posted by iggypoppy (My Page) on
Sat, Jul 10, 10 at 2:04

We have 10 kinds of bamboo in our backyard:

B. Multiplex 'Alphonse Karr'
Phyllostachy Nigra 'Black'
Bambusa Oldhamii 'Giant Timber'
Sinobambusa tootsik Makino ex Nakai 'Suzuko Narihira'/Chinese Temple
Chimonobambusa Quadrangularis 'Square Bamboo'
Bambusa Textilis 'Weaver's Bamboo'
Bambusa Vulgaris Wamin 'Dwarf Buddha's Belly'

Three are unidentified (ie, we lost the tags). They are:
thin culmed yellow clumping
yellow running
giant green clumping

I'm hoping one of you will know what we have!! Here are some pictures:

Yellow Running bamboo:
Unidentified Yellow Runner

Unidentified Yellow Runner

Unidentified Yellow Runner

Big Green Timber?

Unidentified Green Clumper

Unidentified Green Clumper

Unidentified Green Clumper

Unidentified Green clumper

Thin culmed yellow clumping:

Unidentified Yellow Clumper

Unidentified Yellow Clumper

Unidentified Yellow Clumper

Unidentified Yellow Clumper

here's a link to my photobucket if you want to see more. I hope this isn't too many pictures...

Photobucket Account


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Bamboo ID Help needed ! Photo heavy...

  • Posted by kudzu9 Zone 8b, WA (My Page) on
    Sat, Jul 10, 10 at 13:38

Nice bamboo. The yellow runner is likely Ph. bambusoides 'Allgold' (or 'Castillon' if it has a green sulcus). Unfortunately my knowledge of clumpers is limited by the fact that I live in a colder area than yours and can't grow those beauties. If you don't get those other two identified here, try posting this query on the www.bambooweb.info site where quite a few folks grow clumpers.


 o
RE: Bamboo ID Help needed ! Photo heavy...

Thank you Kudzu! (what is a green sulcus???) The green clumper is some kind of timber bamboo... but... I don't know what kind.


 o
RE: Bamboo ID Help needed ! Photo heavy...

  • Posted by kudzu9 Zone 8b, WA (My Page) on
    Sun, Jul 11, 10 at 3:24

On a bamboo there are rings that are called nodes, and on certain bamboo, mainly the Phyllostachys types, there is a vertical groove in the culm that goes from node to node. In some bamboo these grooves are the same color as the rest of the culm, and in some it is a different color...often green if the culm is yellow. So my question was: Are your culms all yellow or do they have a green groove (sulcus)?


 o
RE: I learned something...

Thanks for asking Silversword. I was wondering the same thing. And I do think it's a timber bamboo. It actually looks a lot like the Oldhammi but my DH says it's not the same.

Kudzu, I gotcha now. I just went out and checked that groove, and the entire boo is yellow, including the grooves. In other words, they have a golden sulcus :) So it's likely that they are All-Gold?


 o
RE: Bamboo ID Help needed ! Photo heavy...

The 'Big Green Timber' is a probably a Bambusa. Possibly a B. malingensis, B. pachinensis, or maybe B. ventricosa. If these don't sound familiar, then there are a few other close probabilities.

The 'yellow clumping' looks like B. mult. Al Karr but I know you mentioned that you already have this plant ID'd above. It too is a Bambusa.

Kt


 o
RE: Bamboo ID Help needed ! Photo heavy...

  • Posted by kudzu9 Zone 8b, WA (My Page) on
    Sun, Jul 11, 10 at 15:05

Iggy-
Yes, I'm pretty certain that it's Ph. b. Allgold: it has the form of a Phyllostachys, the culm color is typical, and Allgold usually has some leaves with cream-to-white striations, like in your photos. So that is the most likely guess. There are couple of other Phyllostachys with all-golden culms, but I don't think the characteristics match what you have.


 o
RE: Bamboo ID Help needed ! Photo heavy...

Hi Kentuck,
I'll have to look into those. My DH says it's going to get 4" culms... is this possible???

Thanks Kudzu... as I was looking closer today I found a couple with just one green stripe. Is this a characteristic of the All Gold or do you think possibly there were a couple mixed in when transplanting??


 o
RE: Bamboo ID Help needed ! Photo heavy...

B. beecheyana gets very large culms just like oldhamii.


 o
RE: Bamboo ID Help needed ! Photo heavy...

Help... I'm super scared... I just went outside and noticed on my boo's there is a lot of brown. I've googled it and can't find anything that looks like this,but it looks like it's killing the culms :(((((

B. Multiplex 'Alfonse Karr'


 o
RE: Bamboo ID Help needed ! Photo heavy...

Not sure about the brown spots. My Al Karr gets that on many of it's culms but it never harms the overall plant.

Is that B. vulgaris 'Vittata' PAINTED BAMBOO?

Kt


 o
RE: Bamboo ID Help needed ! Photo heavy...

  • Posted by kudzu9 Zone 8b, WA (My Page) on
    Sun, Jul 11, 10 at 19:52

iggy-
Where are you finding the green stripe and how pronounced is it? Can you post a picture of a culm section that's maybe 4-5 nodes high?


 o
RE: Bamboo ID Help needed ! Photo heavy...

Kentuck... whew!! I hope that's all it is. I'm not sure if it is painted or not, I thought Alphonse Karr but am not certain. Do you know how to tell the difference? It seems to only be affecting that kind. I thought it was damage/stress after purchasing but it seems to have spread.

Kudzu, it's only one tiny stripe, very thin, like a pencil mark. Only from one node to another long. About four feet off the ground, and only on one to two per plant. I will take some pics tomorrow and post.


 o
RE: Bamboo ID Help needed ! Photo heavy...

  • Posted by kudzu9 Zone 8b, WA (My Page) on
    Mon, Jul 12, 10 at 3:14

iggy-
Can't tell from the detail level in your photo whether it's Alphonse Karr or Painted. The stripes on Painted are more pronounced and thicker...and look like they were painted on. When culms of most bamboo get older they can develop patches and lose color, but I have to say that those do look a little strange compared to what I would normally expect. However, I don't think you have to worry that the plant is diseased or dying. Here is a link to photos of Alphonse Karr:
Al Karr

And here is a link to Painted:
Painted

Compare the pictures and you should be able to figure which one is in your photo.

Will look forward to your next post with the green stripe on the runner. There may be one other possibility based on what you show me.


 o
RE: Bamboo ID Help needed ! Photo heavy...

I believe the runner is Phyllostachys aereosulcata (aeroecaulis). It looks just like mine and the green stripes are about like a pencil mark _not on the sulcus. Only about 1 in ten culms have this feature and the stripe does not appear on the whole culm just on certain segments. As for the clumper I have no ideas.


 o
RE: Bamboo ID Help needed ! Photo heavy...

The heavily striped leaves are only sheath leaves(temporary leaves) and after the real leaves come out they will mostly be solid green.The sheath leaves will fall off. Which really disappoints me. That looks like that is what's going on with yours. I'm no expert like Kentuck or Kudzu. But I do grow aereocaulis and this looks exactly like it. I grow 22 different species and have only been growing for 10 years. But this is the only bamboo that I know of that has this characteristic. I could be wrong and if I am please someone correct me.


 o
RE: Green Stripe

Good morning Kudzu,
I found one of the pics on my photobucket that shows the green stripe but will take more after work. It's the furthest right culm, directly next to the artichoke leaf, and then the green stripe repeats itself just above the next node. None of the mature culms seem to have that marking.

Unidentified Yellow Runner


 o
RE: Painted or Alphonse Karr and damage

Kudzu, Thanks for the picture links. After googling around a bit just now I found Alphonse Karr has culm diameter of 1.5" and Painted has a culm diameter of 4". My culms are larger than 1.5" already, so I'm tempted to think it's Painted based on that alone.

I just found a website with someone else who has the same issue with his Painted bamboo. B.v.Vittata shoot damage

It's an old posting, but I emailed him to see if he ever got a resolution.


 o
RE: Calling Bob

Ok, I called Bob my bamboo guy to come out and take a look. I'm super worried there is something really wrong with them. He sounds perplexed by my description and he's been doing this for over 40 years. He said he'll call me back in a little while. I'll keep you posted!


 o
RE: Bamboo ID Help needed ! Photo heavy...

  • Posted by kudzu9 Zone 8b, WA (My Page) on
    Mon, Jul 12, 10 at 12:19

iggy-
Those culms in your picture look fairly slender to me. Are you sure about the dimensions (we're talking diameter here, not circumference)? Here are some photos of Painted Bamboo I took in Hawaii where the biggest culms were about 3"-4" in diameter. You don't seem to have the thick, characteristic striping in your photos or the same, chunky proportions of the culms. And note how the stripes end just short of the node.

Photobucket

Photobucket

Photobucket

I'm thinking you really do have Alphonse Karr.

One last thing: you might want to post in the forums at www.Bambooweb.info with your concern about the patches.


 o
RE: Bamboo ID Help needed ! Photo heavy...

HMMMM... maybe you're right ;) I think I need one of those caliper measuring things. I'll take a measurement best I can with a tape or ruler and a closer picture of the stripes this afternoon. Thank you for all your help Kudzu!


 o
RE: Bamboo ID Help needed ! Photo heavy...

  • Posted by kudzu9 Zone 8b, WA (My Page) on
    Mon, Jul 12, 10 at 19:26

boomantoo-
All speculations are welcome! I thought about Ph. a. 'Aureocaulis,' too, but I was troubled by the fact that those striped leaves looked pretty pronounced and permanent to me, and I've never had any of the light green pencil striping on my culms. I also have some Ph. viridis 'Robert Young' and that one has that yellow shade of culm and randomly gets that faint pencil striping on some culms, but mine doesn't have striped leaves. I'm still leaning towards thinking it's Allgold...although mine doesn't have the pencil-striping on the culms. My experience, though, is that there are some cultivars of certain bamboo that have minor variations...


 o
RE: Bamboo ID Help needed ! Photo heavy...

Kudzu, why is it that I lose the heavily variagated leaves when the permanent leaves come out? My P.a.aereocaulis only has the thin stripes on 1 out of every 10 or 20 culms. Of course our different zones may have alot to do with it.


 o
RE: Bamboo ID Help needed ! Photo heavy...

Hi Kudzu... here are some more pictures:

Base of Yellow Unidentified:
Photobucket

Yellow Unidentified Green Stripe:

Photobucket

Photobucket

Photobucket


 o
RE: Bamboo ID Help needed ! Photo heavy...

  • Posted by kudzu9 Zone 8b, WA (My Page) on
    Tue, Jul 13, 10 at 18:54

iggy-
One more thing and we might be better able to nail down the mystery runner. Run your fingers up and down a culm: Is it smooth or rough (like fine sandpaper)?


 o
RE: Bamboo ID Help needed ! Photo heavy...

LOL Kudzu!! Thank you for embarking on this mystery tour with me! It's smooth, very creamy to the touch. Not at all rough.


 o
RE: Bamboo ID Help needed ! Photo heavy...

  • Posted by kudzu9 Zone 8b, WA (My Page) on
    Wed, Jul 14, 10 at 2:29

iggy-
Well, that rules out the choice of Ph. aureasulcata 'Aureocaulis.' So my best guess is the Ph. bambsoides 'Allgold.' However, why don't you cross-post on BambooWeb.info and see about a second opinion?

boomantoo-
I don't know why you lose the heavily striped leaves; my Aureocaulis keeps them. But I will correct my post above: I took a really close look at my Aureocaulis and, of the probably 50 culms I have, a couple had that light green striping here and there which I never noticed previously. I'm thinking that the amount and frequency of culm-striping and retention of variegation are just some minor variations within the cultivar. And you could be right about the different Zones having an effect....


 o
RE: Bamboo ID Help needed ! Photo heavy...

Thanks Kudzu. I posted on Bamboo web. One person seems to think it's P. vivax Aureocaulis....... What do you think about that? :)


 o
RE: Bamboo ID Help needed ! Photo heavy...

I have to admit the new pictures show big differences in the striping characteristics. It does look different than the aureocaulis. I do love the striping on the mystery plant. Good Luck


 o
RE: Bamboo ID Help needed ! Photo heavy...

Thanks Boo! I love the striping too... it's very understated but the green is very pronounced and the stripes are so "clean" looking.


 o
RE: Bamboo ID Help needed ! Photo heavy...

  • Posted by kudzu9 Zone 8b, WA (My Page) on
    Sat, Jul 17, 10 at 2:38

iggy-
I'm not convinced that it's Ph. v. 'Aureocaulis' and I posted my reasons on that site...


 o
RE: Bamboo ID Help needed ! Photo heavy...

Got some answers from the 'boo man!

The thin yellow clumper is Alphonse Karr.
The yellow runner is AllGold.

Thank you for all of your help! Our only mystery now is the large green clumping. The boo man said it's Oldhamii... but that's not what he said when he sold it to us so my DH is a little irritated (cost $50 more per plant, and we already had Oldhamii).


 o
RE: Bamboo ID Help needed ! Photo heavy...

  • Posted by kudzu9 Zone 8b, WA (My Page) on
    Tue, Aug 3, 10 at 17:18

I agree with those IDs on the yellow ones. The green clumper illustrates the difficulty of distinguishing between some of the green bamboos...and maybe the "boo man" is even not sure at this point!


 o
RE: Bamboo ID Help needed ! Photo heavy...

I think "boo man" will be called "no clue man" around our house for a while :)


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Bamboo Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here