Shop Products
Houzz Logo Print
pitangadiego

Identifying bananas varieties is so easy

pitangadiego
18 years ago

Maybe I have missed something.We generally identify birds by their plummage, esp. the male plumage which tends to be more colorful. One of the ways of classifying plants is by their sexual parts. IF you look back at all of the the banana flower pictures I have posted, and look at the male flowers, it seems to me that each variety has different shapes and colors. SO, perhaps, it is easy to identify which variety you have after is has flowered.

{{gwi:418571}}
{{gwi:418588}}
{{gwi:418536}}
{{gwi:418572}}
{{gwi:418492}}
{{gwi:418852}}
{{gwi:409792}}
{{gwi:415584}}
{{gwi:417614}}
{{gwi:405714}}
{{gwi:420436}}
{{gwi:420437}}
{{gwi:420438}}
{{gwi:420439}}
{{gwi:420440}}

Comments (16)

  • dirt_dew
    18 years ago

    Do you have balbisiana?

  • hibiscus909
    18 years ago

    True. Many plants can only be IDed by looking at the flowers. Unfortunately, that takes a while (sometimes a LONG while) with naners.
    You have given us such a great resource with the photos, pitangadiego. thank you!!!

    seahorse

  • ohio_banana
    18 years ago

    The photos are all truly stunning - but almost border on banana porn :-)! Try having a 10-yr old daughter looking over your shoulder when you've got pitangadiego's photos loaded! And yes, reproductive structures are the distinguishing features used to identify many plant species, varieties, cultivars, or taxa. But the shape and color of pistils [F] and stamens [M] might be affected by the maturity of the flower so that straight stamens become curly with age. And I doubt that pollen would be of any help? I still think that the only sure way is genetic analysis.

    Donn

  • pitangadiego
    Original Author
    18 years ago

    I have one seeded banana which could be Balbisiana, but do not know for sure.

    I am no botanist, and Donn may have some very valid points, but I do not believe that any of these flowers ever looked the same at any stage of the flowering process (male stage). My posting was not really an assertion, just an observation of what might be possible if someone had the time and wherewithal to undertake a comprehansive study that could put together an identification chart. Eventually I will have pictures of 80 or so varieties, but would still need some broader investigation to determine if mine were properly named in the first place.

  • ohio_banana
    18 years ago

    I think you're probably right - those structures are pretty species-specific. It sure is better than looking at leaves, petioles, pseudostems and the like. And while I have a PhD in botany, my specialty was freshwater diatom [a type of algae] taxonomy and ecology - so I'm pretty ignorant of vascular plants. But in the old pre-genomic days, floral parts ruled - I think you could generate a key based on the photos [if you're sure what's what]. And the photos - I can't compliment them enough. They are outstanding!

    Donn

  • sandy0225
    18 years ago

    IF you can get the $%^& things to bloom........

  • Dave in NoVA • N. Virginia • zone 7A
    18 years ago

    Pitanga,
    You need to create a web site banana resource with all your great pictures. For each species/variety you could post pics of the flowers, plant form, leaves (top and bottom surfaces), etc. It would make a great resource! A lot of work, but a great resource. Great close-ups. ~Dave

  • pitangadiego
    Original Author
    18 years ago

    Dave,

    Your wish is my command. We Be Bananas though not all the latest pix are included yet.

  • pitangadiego
    Original Author
    18 years ago

    Sandy,

    I can sympathize, but do not know your frustration experientially. In San Diego, you just add swater and fertilizer and compost and wait two years.

  • Eggo
    18 years ago

    Pitangadiego, thanks for the great pictures. I think some of the differences in flowers are quite obvious from your pictures.

    What?? you mean you actually add fertilizer??? lol. just kidding. But bananas do grow like weeds in Southern California.

  • joereal
    18 years ago

    Thanks for the great pics pitangadiego!

    Shall we ban the pictures of all flowers as they are truly very showy reproductive organs of plants?

    Some recent theories suggests that the Stonehenge is believed to be one giant symbol or representation of the woman's reproductive system. Shall we destroy these as well?

    I think it depends upon our individual minds to view them in terms of uncontaminated beauty or with dirty malicious minds. Unfortunately, the very same reasoning "artists" would love to argue when "admiring" nude human pictures.

  • kenzie_pom
    18 years ago

    Pitangadiego,
    Your photos are truly beautiful. Thank you for sharing them.
    Kenzie.

  • Dirkie
    18 years ago

    This is already known and used a lot by scientists. At the site of inibap : www.inibap.org you can find at the musalogue descriptions of different varieties and species.

    Dirk

  • pitangadiego
    Original Author
    18 years ago

    {{gwi:418813}}
    {{gwi:420227}}
    {{gwi:420221}}

  • pitangadiego
    Original Author
    18 years ago

    {{gwi:419421}}

  • pitangadiego
    Original Author
    18 years ago

    {{gwi:418696}}

Sponsored
Custom Home Works
Average rating: 4.6 out of 5 stars10 Reviews
Franklin County's Award-Winning Design, Build and Remodeling Expert