Shop Products
Houzz Logo Print
njbiology

What host plants have you seen: Fritillaries (spp.) use?

njbiology
16 years ago

THIS thread is ONLY for the host plants of

the:

Please, specify which species of Fritillary (Heliconia).

  1. It would be interesting to know what species of butterfly HOST PLANTS different gardners have observed certain butterflies using in their respective regions, first-hand.

*Example: Some sites indicate Red Mulberry as a host for the Mourning Cloak Butterfly. It would be interesting to know if anyone can confirm this through personal experience in observation; likewise, it would be interesting if anyone has seen Mourning Cloaks use Morus alba, etc.

*Another example: Some sites claim that the Eastern Tiger Swallow Tail Butterfly uses Lindera benzoin - a known host of the Spicebush Swallowtail; and the other way around: Some sites claim that Swampbay Magnolia is the host of the Spicebush Swallowtail, although it is primarily described as the host of the Eastern Tiger Swallowtail (in the south?). This may be a re-circulated error(?)

2. If you have two or more host plants commonly known to be a host plant of a certain butterfly, it would be interesting to know which is MORE attractive then the other(s).

*Example: Common hosts of the Red-Admiral Butterfly include: Tall Stinging Nettle; Stinging Nettle L.; Wood Nettle; False Nettle; & Canadian Clear-Weed Nettle. I intend to grow all of these. I would be able to eventually report which patch (each being 5' x 5') of Nettle spp. attracted the most Red-Admirals or associated brushfoots.

_________________________________________________________

Note: There are websites that re-circulate misinformation and dubious information, so in this discussion thread, please exclusively present only your own personal observations. This should, hopefully, provide practical information when regionally applied in making decisions in host plant selection where space is limited, etc.

-Steve

Comments (10)

  • butterflymomok
    16 years ago

    I am currently raising GFs and VFs. The GFs were found on Passiflora--Incense, Incarnata, Caerula(sp?),and Lady Margaret. The most eggs were on the Incense, but my PC is still very small. The VFs were found on the Incarnata, and one little tiny violet plant. Most of the eggs were on the Incarnata, but I don't have a lot of violet plants currently.

    In the past, I have only grown Incarnata and Caerula. Caerula seemed to be preferred by the GFs, and Incarnata, by the VFs.

    OKSandy

  • MissSherry
    16 years ago

    I've found jillions of gulf fritillaries on maypops/passiflora incarnata, a good many of them on two of its hybrids p. 'Incense' and p. 'Lady Margaret', a good many on p. caerulea 'Waterloo Blue' and a few on p. biflora, and p. lutea.
    I've found variegated fritillaries on maypops/p. incarnata and common, purple-flowering, heart-shaped leaf violets/viola floridana - I've never found any VFs on the local white-flowering violets/v. primulifolia.
    MissSherry

  • susanlynne48
    16 years ago

    I have raised Variegated Frits on viola soraria and Gulf Frits on passiflora incarnata 'Incense' and P. ceurulea. Gulf frits are not "true" frits, but rather members of the heliconia, or longwing, species.

    These are the only two we get in my area of central Oklahoma. Great Spangled Frits are found in northeastern Oklahoma, and it is my understanding they strictly use violet ssp.

    V. soraria has the true blue/violet flower. I have lots of Johnny-Jump-Ups in the yard, with white flowers, and have never seen any activity on them.

    Susan

  • jrcagle
    16 years ago

    Variagated Frits and Great Spangled Frits appear to use (i.e., I see them hanging out near) violets.

  • linda_centralokzn6
    16 years ago

    Here the Varieg. frits will only use the true native P. incarnata. I don't have many wild violets. The Gulf frits will use my incarnata, incense, and caerulea.

  • njbiology
    Original Author
    16 years ago

    I wonder if up north, they would ALL use common blue violets? Or are they particular as to which violets.

    p.s. I love Johnny-Jump-Ups (Viola tricolor).

  • susanlynne48
    16 years ago

    Oh, I love the tricolors, too, NJ, but they just don't attract any butterflies. They are such a nice harbinger of spring, though. I think viola soraria is the common blue violet, and I got some from a very nice butterfly friend here. They are native to Oklahoma as well, though, but as an urban gardener, I didn't have any and I don't really get out to the country (Linda, I need to visit you sometime to see your sanctuary, and you, too, Sandy).

    Most host plant databases say the VFs and other true frits use "violet ssp.", but IMHO, they are particular as to which viola species they DO actually use.

    I hope to acquire a P. incarnata one day, but they don't use the P. incarnata 'Incense' at all.

    Does anyone have other viola species that you've found the VFs on?????

    Susan

  • mboston_gw
    16 years ago

    Here in Central Florida, I have raised many Gulf Frits on both Passiflora Incarnata and P. Suberosa. The Suberosa is available all year round and they seem to use it all year round. This is the first year that I have found lots of them on my Incarnata but prior to this it has been mostly in the shade.

    I also have P. Amethyst and P. Carelua and have seen eggs on both to a much lesser extent but I have not brought them in to raise because the leaves wilt so easily.

  • jmcat
    16 years ago

    I have only done VF's out of those, and they will use violets and johnny-jump-ups,violas, pansies, etc. I only see eggs laid on violas, etc. (I have violas, etc. outside, but the violet is potted inside until it is big enough to plant out), but I did a test this year as follows: I decided to test different VF host plants that I have heard of using, specifically; violas, violets (I believe this specific kind has blue(?) flowers), stonecrop (Sedum spurium), and (I believe) Broadleaf Plantain (Plantago major). I only used 2 cats, but the verdict was that 1 cat ate the violet when I put it on the leaf (I only put 1 cat on that sample), but the plantain and stonecrop were shunned when a cat was put on those leaves (I forget whether I used 1 or 2 cats each on them). I already knew that all VF's I had ate violas, as the eggs and cats were on them when I found them.
    -Jmcat

  • grouperman941
    16 years ago

    Southwest Florida is the same as mboston said.

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Franklin County's Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting