Return to the Butterfly Garden Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Are these butterfly eggs on a milkweed?

Posted by beatrice_outdoors 6a MA (My Page) on
Wed, Sep 26, 12 at 15:30

Hi Everyone. This is my first time posting in this forum. I hope you can help. I pulled a milkweed plant out of my garden just now-it is the only one I had. As soon as I did it I remembered that butterflies lay eggs on milkweed, and my heart sank.

I have been growing my garden to attract butterflies, but did not realize I may actually provide egg sites, too.

Will the eggs survive if the plant dies? I do not know my butterflies well, but we had a LOT of them (and bumblebees) this year. Here's hoping I did not just cause some dreadful harm to the lifecycle.

The plant was lying on the ground, so I believe the black spots are dirt. Nothing seems to move when I gently poke it, so I don't think they are aphids either. It's just that there are so MANY.

I am in eastern Massachusetts (if that matters/helps).

Thanks for any help you can provide.
Beatrice


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Are these butterfly eggs on a milkweed?

Sorry-let me try adding the picture again!


 o
RE: Are these butterfly eggs on a milkweed?

It's probably all dirt, but some of those yellowish grains might be monarch eggs ready to hatch.
I'm linking you to a site with a picture of a monarch egg. They're very small, so you may have to get out your magnifying glass to see if any have the typical vertical lines that monarch eggs have.

Hopefully, congratulations!

Sherry

Here is a link that might be useful: Monarch Life Cycle


 o
RE: Are these butterfly eggs on a milkweed?

Beatrice, I live in eastern Mass. too and in my area (metro west Boston) the Monarchs have LONG stopped laying eggs. The nights start getting too cold and they don't have enough time to complete their growth cycle. The last eggs I collected were probably laid Sept 1st or 2nd.

The Monarch breeding season is longer along the coast because nights are warmer than inland, so if you are in the warmest section of eastern Mass then maybe there might be a stray egg? But your dots don't look like eggs to me.

I am curious why did you pull your one milkweed plant?


 o
RE: Are these butterfly eggs on a milkweed?

Sherry,

I tried looking, but my magnifying glass is not strong enough to distinguish stripes. I put the plant back outside in case I am lucky and they are eggs, but the fact that there are so many makes me wonder. I looked up more images of eggs, and none of them has more than a few at a time.

Terrene, my nights have been in the 50's, and this week started getting into the 40's on occasion. I was never taught to think milkweed is anything but a weed, and was on autopilot when I pulled it. I have been looking things up lately, though, which is why I said my heart sank as soon as I pulled it and realized I may not have just been "weeding". You can bet I will know better next time! I just don't normally get milkweed plants in my yard, either. There are plenty of them in the neighborhood, though.

I better learn my caterpillars soon, otherwise I may not know what I am looking at if they come out.

Thank you both for responding and helping me!


 o
Follow up to:: Are these butterfly eggs on a milkweed?

Hi folks. I figured I'd post a quick follow up to my earlier post. I was not able to track the eggs or whatever they were (too busy) but unless there are some other black and orange butterflies that I am not aware of, I have seen four monarchs this past week, the last one just a few minutes ago.

So my milkweed plant may have indeed had eggs! I am amazed, but happy. :)

Beatrice


 o
RE: Are these butterfly eggs on a milkweed?

BTW-I meant to say, black and orange butterflies that look like monarchs. I do know there are plenty of B&O ones....


 o
RE: Are these butterfly eggs on a milkweed?

BTW-I meant to say, black and orange butterflies that look like monarchs. I do know there are plenty of B&O ones....


 o
RE: Are these butterfly eggs on a milkweed?

Looks like your plant had aphids.


 o
RE: Are these butterfly eggs on a milkweed?

Beatrice,

There is a wonderful book that helps identify eggs and caterpillars. It is geared towards kids, but that just makes it an easy read. I love it for the pictures it provides. It is called The Life Cycles of Butterflies, by Judy Burris and Wayne Richards. I think I saw it was available on Amazon a while back.

Mechelle


 o
RE: Are these butterfly eggs on a milkweed?

Hi Beatrice, there's no way you would have monarch eggs in Massachusetts in October. I agree they were probably aphids.

As for your butterflies, could they have been painted ladies?

http://www.butterfliesandmoths.org/species/Vanessa-cardui

Tony


 o
RE: Are these butterfly eggs on a milkweed?

coolbutterfly-the wings on the ones that were very close in the last week had distinct black lines, not black whirls and swirls. One was sitting on a plant for about a minute, so I did get a good look, one flew in front of my face for about 30 seconds while I was gardening (also a very good look), one went by in a fairly straight line, one was only close enough to see the colors (not so good look). But I don't know enough about butterflies to say definitively that they were or were not monarchs. I am just hopeful

In any case, butterflies in my garden are awesome. Especially these Halloween colored ones in October. :)


 o
RE: Are these butterfly eggs on a milkweed?

Beatrice, I am attaching two photos of Monarch eggs on Common Milkweed (Asclepias syriaca) for your help in knowing what you are looking for. These are larger than life-size. Hope it helps you.

Bob


 o
RE: Are these butterfly eggs on a milkweed?

Bob-thank you so much. I did receive a picture from someone when I originally posted, too, but I have no reference for size. How big are they compared to the tip of a pencil?


 o
RE: Are these butterfly eggs on a milkweed?

Beatrice, perhaps you did see some late monarchs since much of the migration took place on the east coast this year.

Now that you know what monarch eggs look like, I hope you find some in 2013!

Tony


 o
RE: Are these butterfly eggs on a milkweed?

The white dot on the leaf at the tip of my thumb is a Monarch egg.

DM


 o
RE: Are these butterfly eggs on a milkweed?

Thank you DM! Your picture is extremely helpful!


 o
RE: Are these butterfly eggs on a milkweed?

Bob, those are great macro shots of the eggs.

Yes it is unlikely that eggs are being laid in Mass. in October, but common for migrants to still be passing through. I haven't seen a Monarch for over 2 weeks, since we had a hard frost, but people along the coast see them longer because they have milder low temperatures and they probably have not yet had a frost.

Beatrice, hopefully your milkweed will pop up again next year from the root system! My experience with Asclepias syriaca - common milkweed is, that it grows where it wants to, so I sort of try to accommodate in the garden beds, and make it look like it belongs! It's not the best behaved garden plant, but it works well to attract the female Monarchs.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Butterfly Garden Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here