Return to the Butterfly Garden Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Buckeye Season is Here!

Posted by misssherry Z8/9MS (My Page) on
Sun, Sep 2, 12 at 16:15

When I hauled some sticks off to my pickup pile on the main road this afternoon, I found one lone buckeye cat -

Image hosted by Photobucket.com

I brought the cat in to finish raising myself.

There aren't too many agalinis plants where I found the caterpillar, so I went up front and searched for some on the big stands of it there. 'Couldn't find another caterpillar, but I did see this -

Image hosted by Photobucket.com

I'm hoping she was a female laying eggs on the host plants!
I wish we had these beauties year round, but, in spite of planting host plants for them that they could use in the spring and summer, the cats usually only show up in Sept., Oct., and Nov. - I think I've found a few in August.
Oh well, I guess that's nature's way.

Sherry


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Buckeye Season is Here!

They're beautiful!
They use narrow leaf plantain as a host here, a weed that's a bit too plentiful in my yard and in our hayfield too.
I hadn't seen many Buckeyes this summer until the last couple days and now have about three dozen on my celosia, butterfly bush and verbena b.


 o
RE: Buckeye Season is Here!

Wow! That's a gorgeous picture, Christie! The hot pink of the celosia is eye popping!

Sherry


 o
RE: Buckeye Season is Here!

I am seeing them in great numbers here in MI... pretty much all I am seeing right now.


 o
RE: Buckeye Season is Here!

Thank you Sherry - I love that celosia, the wasps do too though.


 o
RE: Buckeye Season is Here!

Wow - that's an eye popping photo, Christie! As colorful as the Buckeye is itself. I didn't know that butterflies would even use Celosia to nectar on. I've grown it occasionally, just for the sheer beauty of the plants, but never noticed it being utilized by butterflies.

Seems like every nectar plant that the butterflies like, the wasps do, too. Have you ever noticed how they "patrol" plants, especially host plants. They get down inside the dense foliage and crawl around the leaves looking for meat. Argh........

Wasps have been horrible in my garden this year, among many other predators. Wish I could figure out a non-toxic, non-risky (don't want to get stung) way to rid my garden of these cat junkies.

Susan


 o
RE: Buckeye Season is Here!

thanks for posting this, I found this buckeye butterfly along with a mourning cloak butterfly, enjoying some watermelon in our garden yesterday, I was thinking that was a buckeye and now with your photos, it was confirmed. I have never seen one at our place before, it was quite exciting to see.



 o
RE: Buckeye Season is Here!

Beautiful pictures!!!
I have planted several "buckeye host plants" & have never had any here...I have frogfruit that is native here, English Plantain, several kinds of Ruellias & Snake Herb(Dyschoriste linearis) but have never seen a single cat! I had seeds of Agalinis edwardsiana that I scattered but didn't get any to sprout that is also a host for them!
I usually see the butterflies a lot in the spring but Sherry...you have given me hope that I might still get some cats here this fall! Thanks!
Lila


 o
RE: Buckeye Season is Here!

This afternoon, I walked out of my daughter's school after delivering some sweetgum for some polys I have placed there. Saw a buckeye cat walking on the concrete. Took it inside, showed the principal, and told him that proved the school was a pro-Buckeyes school (boo Michigan). Put the cat in an aquarium with 2 poly cocoons where I figure it has picked out a spot for pupation by now. I'm fuzzy on whether it should eclose this year. The only time I've found buckeyes in the late summer, they had parasitoids so I have no point of reference.


 o
RE: Buckeye Season is Here!

That's great, KC! I've been lucky enough to never have a buckeye that was parasitized, knock on wood!!!

My original buckeye cat pupated a while back, and I've since found three more. These three are full size now, so they'll probably be pupating tomorrow or the next day.

Sherry


 o
RE: Buckeye Season is Here!

The original buckeye cat has emerged from its chrysalis. It flew into a holly tree by the porch, where I got its picture -

Image hosted by Photobucket.com

Sherry


 o
RE: Buckeye Season is Here!

Hi Miss Sherry, I just found a buckeye cat on the concrete deck. I thought it was very late in the year for them and I cant find any info on how big they get before the pupa, the one I found is about 1.25 inches.. do you think it is close to the pupa? Thanks for any info you can share :)I do love that spotted face... too cute!


 o
RE: Buckeye Season is Here!

Nice pictures! I've been bringing in Buckeyes too lately and have over 20 now in containers. This is the second year that I've raised them inside. I got them on my snapdragons last year, so I made sure to plant them again this year and it worked! Last year and this year are the only two years that I've had Common Buckeye butterflies here in numbers.
Cathy


 o
RE: Buckeye Season is Here!

Here are some more Buckeyes...


 o
RE: Buckeye Season is Here!

Woohoo, Cathy! You've really got a lot of them!

Nature'sFolly, I've never measured them, but 1 1/4" doesn't sound like the last instar. I'm guessing they get 1 3/4" long, but they don't get fat. Maybe I'm wrong, maybe yours was wandering looking for a place to pupate, but if it were me, I'd offer it some food to eat, just in case. Do you have snapdragons in your garden? Does agalinis or plantain grow somewhere near you? Buckeyes eat a wide variety of plants, mostly in the snapdragon family, but also plantains and others.

Sherry


 o
RE: Buckeye Season is Here!

The only thing I have for food is lots and lots of plantain, I put a couple of sticks and plenty of plantain leaves... the cat seems very interested in just crawling around, so my guess would be that it is ready to pupate. It is getting very close to much cooler temps here...how long would you say that they take to transform? Do they over winter? I have tried to research them but the info is scarce.


 o
RE: Buckeye Season is Here!

Once they pupate, it only takes about ?9-10 days before they emerge, no more than 2 weeks - they go from one stage to the other very quickly.

I can't ever remember overwintering a buckeye, and I've raised a good many of them late in fall, so I'm guessing they overwinter as adults.

Sherry


 o
RE: Buckeye Season is Here!

The cat is in the J now, just waiting for it to pupate. Thanks for the info. Hopefully the days in the 60 degree temps will be ok when it emerges.


 o
RE: Buckeye Season is Here!

A friend of mine called me Friday and told me about a field where I might be able to find some buckeye cats since she had found some there. Drove out today, spent 45 minutes looking, and came up with 3. Not many but 3 more than I had.

Field was not very big but I was impressed because it had at least 9 species of butterflies flitting about (but no buckeyes). My son was waving a net around to catch jumping grasshoppers for his praying mantis. He caught a mating pair of clouded sulphurs by accident (they were released).


 o
RE: Buckeye Season is Here!

Like you say, three buckeye cats is better than none, KC! How are they doing? What are they eating?

The rest of mine have emerged. I got this picture of one nectaring on some mistflower, one of my better close-up pictures -

Image hosted by Photobucket.com

Sherry


 o
RE: Buckeye Season is Here!

So pretty! Buckeyes have the prettiest colors. I had one this morning nectaring on the mistflower. They sure do like purple flowers.

Susan


 o
RE: Buckeye Season is Here!

Sherry,
Two made chrysalises soon after I brought them home. Unfortunately, I did not remove the chrysalises from the container (these days, I put most of my chrysalises in butterfly pavilions I have hanging from my ceiling). A few days later, I knocked the container over and it fell to the floor. One chrysalis broke open. :( The other still seems fine.

The third cat is eating plantain. I was giving it thinner leaf stuff from my neighbor's yard. Then I found a small patch of circle leaf variety in my yard and it seems to prefer that.

The weather has gotten colder here quickly. Got down to 34 degrees yesterday. If the buckeyes do go south for the winter, I don't think they are going to make it this year. This time last year, I had a bunch of monarch cats. This year: none. Makes me think the monarchs knew winter was coming earlier this year. OTOH, I still have a bunch of GST cats left. If it were not for my potted wafer ash trees, I'd be out of food already because the tree in the ground dropped all its leaves maybe 5 days ago. The really sad part is the GSTs stopped by in the last week to lay more eggs. Would not surprise me if Ohio has a "regular" winter this year, we will not be seeing buckeyes, GSTs, and a host of other butterflies next year that we have been seeing the past few years.


 o
RE: Buckeye Season is Here!

If they survive to pupate, the GSTs, of course, will overwinter as chrysalises. I think most all of the Swallowtails will.

The only time I ever got Buckeye cats was when I grew Diascia among the plantains. I have 2 species of Plantago, e.g., P. lanceolata and P. major. The P. major has a larger, wider leaf that is kind of spoon-shaped, smaller at the base where the petiole connects to the stem, and wider and rounder at the tip. Also called Dooryard Plantain. P.lanceolata is commonly called Ribbed Plantain. I think that P. major has a more tender leaf.

Diascia is in the Scrophulariaceae family like Snapdragons. It is a short-lived perennial that likes cooler weather like the Snaps, but it will tolerate heat better then Snaps if keep watered and a bit shaded. Very pretty little plant, one of the first to bloom in spring, sporadically over summer, and then another flush in fall. Only lives about 2-3 years.

I've been told that Buckeyes love the shorter Snapdragons as larval host plants, too.

Susan

Here is a link that might be useful: Dooryard Plantain aka Plantago major


 o
RE: Buckeye Season is Here!

I bought two seed packets of dwarf snapdragons for the buckeyes this year but the seeds never got planted. :( The plants I had from previous years did not come back this year.


 o
RE: Buckeye Season is Here!

Plantain seems to be the main host plant for buckeyes in most areas, but here they use the agalinis, which is blooming now and looking pretty on the roadsides - the flowers look like snapdragons, which figures, since it's in the snapdragon family of plants.

We've already had fronts go through here, too, with temps in the low 60's at night, so I think you're right, KC, this winter will be more typical. It's still warm to hot in the day here, though, so my cats are growing at the normal pace.

The monarch cats are growing like weeds!

Sherry


 o
RE: Buckeye Season is Here!

Found another Buckeye cat yesterday and it is in the J.. found a chrysalis hanging on my garden tool chest also. Still waiting for the first butterfly to eclose, it fell from the top of the container and the skin never fell off so we will see what happens.10 days and counting.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Butterfly Garden Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here