Return to the Butterfly Garden Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
LATE red admiral- Where do they go?

Posted by coolbutterfly 5A (My Page) on
Thu, Oct 17, 13 at 21:59

I saw a red admiral playing with fire (or should I say ICE) in Minnesota today.

It looked newly hatched. We are a good week past our avg first frost date and it's finally going to freeze this weekend.

It was only 60 degrees today, but there was no wind and it felt warmer. A beautiful bonus day to our 2013 season.

There is still lots of nectar to be had in the garden and there were honey bees stocking up too. I hope the RA got what it needed and flew south like the wind! There'll be no more nectar after this weekend... Tony


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: LATE red admiral- Where do they go?

..or it could hibernate locally.


 o
RE: LATE red admiral- Where do they go?

Thanks, Larry. I'm glad to know they hibernate. They are the most common butterfly in my yard and I get quite a flurry of them in the spring. I keep searching the woods for nettles so I can collect seeds and expand on them, but I haven't found any stinging nettles, yet.

Martha


 o
RE: LATE red admiral- Where do they go?

I find this rather confusing too. According to the BAMONA website, most red admirals do not survive cold winters and much of North America has to be recolonized every year by Southern migrants. That seems to me to leave half of the lifecycle incomplete. In other words, where do all those southern butterflies come from that make the trip north? Do they breed all winter long further south to build up the population?


 o
RE: LATE red admiral- Where do they go?

I don't understand how this works either, but I do know that here red admirals fly on sunny winter days every year. They then lay eggs on the false nettles in early spring, I raise and release many of them, and I continue to see at least one male on my gravel road in late evenings into the summer. I haven't seen any for a while, as usual for this time of year, so I'm assuming they come from up north, where they start the process all over again.

Sherry


 o
RE: LATE red admiral- Where do they go?

Coolbutterfly- I was wondering the same thing. Yesterday I took photos of 3 Red A, 1 common buckeye, 1 American L and several monarchs here in New York. The monarchs are getting ready to leave but what about the rest?


 o
RE: LATE red admiral- Where do they go?

It may depend on how snug the hibernating nook or cranny is for survival of overwintering northern RAs. They are apparently common in a Michigan yard in the spring, perhaps too early for them to have been arrivals from down south.


 o
RE: LATE red admiral- Where do they go?

I see hundreds of RAs in the Spring after a warm Winter and few to none after a colder one.
I think they may hibernate locally during these warmer spells (2011/2012, esp) and swarm in the Spring.
Otherwise, they get frozen back down South by cold winters and take a while to migrate back up North.
American Ladies always seem to be around early, as soon as their hosts get a couple inches high. They are very cold tolerant and their cats don't mind cool nights. In fact, they fare better c the greatly reduced threat of wasps, which prefer hot summer days.


 o
RE: LATE red admiral- Where do they go?

Martha, Late next month (if I can manage to have them ready by that time) I'll be giving away various kinds of seeds for a SASBE. False nettle is one of the seeds. If you'd like to try it, maybe you want to wait and see if there is anything else from my list that you'd like. I've gotten to raise Red Admirals because of having false nettle. Personally, I'd rather have false nettle than stinging nettle. I'm already allergic to many of the plants that I grow for the butterflies and would hate to think how I'd react to stinging nettle. Just the name scares me away. ;-)
Cathy


 o
RE: LATE red admiral- Where do they go?

Thanks Larry, It's good to hear they hibernate. My guess was they didn't because I don't normally see them in spring...although during the EARLY spring of 2012 tons of them migrated north. A spectacular display! Tony


 o
RE: LATE red admiral- Where do they go?

I saw the first red admiral I've seen in a while on the road today, dusk hadn't even arrived. I imagine it's here for the winter.

Sherry


 o
RE: LATE red admiral- Where do they go?

Thx Larry & Leafhead. It's very good info. Sherry- I wish I lived where it's warm and I can see butterflies all year round...

Nerry


 o
RE: LATE red admiral- Where do they go?

You and me both, Nerry!


 o
RE: LATE red admiral- Where do they go?

Oddly enough, I had a few RA cats during the summer...very unusual. After that time, I saw no more, even now I haven't seen a single one. Sometimes I see RA's during the winter. They like the Rue bushes that bloom in winter. Other winters, none spotted until February. I haven't seen any Common Buckeyes since spring. Modest numbers of agalinis came up, bloomed and it's all seeding now, no cats.


 o
RE: LATE red admiral- Where do they go?

Have you tried growing False Nettle, or Pellitory?
I don't know how prevalent RAs are in Tx, but they're common in the Midwest in some Springs. I can't keep enough Urtica dioica (I know, OUCH, but it's up early enough) on hand to feed all the cats.
I've tried growing False Nettle, and it comes up in July.
Another + is Stinging Nettles are bunny resistant.


 o
RE: LATE red admiral- Where do they go?

Leafhead,
Could you gather any seeds from the stinging nettles? I have a large forested area that's full of poison ivy already, so stinging nettles would be a perfect addition. Don't get "stung" on my account. You could just snip off a branch into a paper bag, maybe? I can check with Prairiemoon nursery, too.


 o
RE: LATE red admiral- Where do they go?

Sure. I can spare lots. I'll send you an e-mail c my address.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Butterfly Garden Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here