Return to the Cacti & Succulents Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Is this what an etiolated haworthia looks like?

Posted by nathanblair Utah (My Page) on
Wed, Feb 6, 13 at 18:56

I was told to not bring succulents into an office environment, but if I really wanted to, a haworthia could survive. So I brought in this haworthia and it doesn't look as good as when I bought it. You can see in the photo that the bottom is weakening and even shriveling a bit, and the top looks stretched out. Is this what they mean by etiolated? I live in Utah where I can't take it outside yet, so is my only solution to put it by a big window and give it more light?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Is this what an etiolated haworthia looks like?

Yep, that would be what's happening. It needs as much light as it can get if it's inside.


 o
RE: Is this what an etiolated haworthia looks like?

Yes! definitely.


 o
RE: Is this what an etiolated haworthia looks like?

This might be a silly question, will an etiolated haworthia ever shrink back down after being exposed to more light?


 o
RE: Is this what an etiolated haworthia looks like?

The parts of the plants that have become etiolated will stay that way. You just have to wait for healthy new growth to grow in atop it.


 o
RE: Is this what an etiolated haworthia looks like?

So as the lower leaves dry up and the new growth is compact, eventually it will be back to it's original size? Oh man, maybe I should have never bought any haworthias - as I am stuck growing them indoors.


 o
RE: Is this what an etiolated haworthia looks like?

Yeah, that's the way. But I've grown these guys indoors, and it can be done. It's not ideal, because they will prefer a little outside sunlight, but you just need them by a good window if you're going to do it indoors. Anything sitting on a desk far off from a window isn't going to turn out well.


 o
RE: Is this what an etiolated haworthia looks like?

movenpick

Can you get some extra light (maybe on timer for 14hrs/day)? - unless you can move it to a very bright window.
I have few inside in south window (not very large), and have fluorescent lights on too. They will have to wait for another at least 2mo before it's warm enough to keep them outside. Considering the light situation, I think they are in reasonable shape.

Rina

This post was edited by rina_ on Sat, Feb 23, 13 at 8:45


 o
RE: Is this what an etiolated haworthia looks like?

Hi All,

Nice plantings Rina.

I too grow indoors only, including some Haworthias. I agree if one has at least the edge of a good window or two, it can be done.

One of my favorites, H. limifolia

Photobucket

Same Haw after I'd removed some pups a winter ago or 2.

Photobucket

This is a H. truncata & I grow it right on this west window sill for maximum possible light.

Haw truncata/Barad

You could probably experiment w/ some less expensive ones (like from Big Box stores) to find a couple you can grow.


 o
RE: Is this what an etiolated haworthia looks like?

Thank you all for the responses!

I think this H. cymbiformis is starting to show signs of etiolation... unless some of them grow tall like that.
Untitled

I acquired this hybrid last autumn. It seems to be a slow grower so the ill-effects of inadequate light might not show up until later.
Untitled

@teatree: Thank you for all the info. I keep them by the windowsill, but I fear it still might not be enough light.

@rina_: Unfortunately, I do not have enough room in my apt to set up some grow lights. They currently sit facing NW (I could only wish I had access to a South-facing window). Your plants look happy!

@pirate_girl: It's great to hear that indoor growing can be done. I understand you live in NYC, so you too are limited on space. Your haws look happy too!


 o
RE: Is this what an etiolated haworthia looks like?

it's possible, but it needs good indirect light. i have sev zebra hawortias. i read that they are mislabeled 99% of the time - and really they are attenuatas. all from the one that i bought some 10 years ago. the ones in brightest light and hot in the western window - they are the smallest. they don't grow at all. i often forget to water them too. yeh, i should move them, i know...the ones in the north-east window get morning sun-light only 4-5 months out of the year. they are doing ok, but growing very slow. it takes them a long time to clump. there's barely any soil and i have already 7 in a cluster , but for 5 years it was a single. just sat there.
then i put 5 in a larger pot and it sat like that too for years, until i finally started putting it outside on NE balcony - it took off like crazy. it spends winters on a cold NE window too. i am on a hudson across from nyc.
if i paid them more attention, i think i would have ground cover by now. that would be windowsill cover, that is ;). they are exceptionally resilient.


 o
RE: Is this what an etiolated haworthia looks like?

It looks like your haworthia is stretching for the sun, and it's not streatching to do exercises. This is a horrible time of the year for them, watch of for scale and mailies on the leafes. take out all dead leaves. you also may need to change it's soil, at this time that will give it a jump start on the season, it will not like the hot summer sun, low light is fine but some sun to grow correctly, so do we. Norma


 o
RE: Is this what an etiolated haworthia looks like?

@petrushka: Good to hear that they are resilient even in the least optimal conditions.

@norma: Thank you for all of the advice on keeping my haws healthy.


 o
RE: Is this what an etiolated haworthia looks like?

here's what the '5year-nogrow' looks like after it was switched from sunny window to NE. it's in 4" pot, maybe 1" deep. don't call me a torturer! it actually clumped suddenly and tripled in size in 5 years of NE.


 o
RE: Is this what an etiolated haworthia looks like?

@petrushka: Wow that clump looks great!


 o
RE: Is this what an etiolated haworthia looks like?

here's a comparative study... of neglect. yeh, i mostly neglect them.
i bought 1 single plant may be 10 years back?...?
1. the top right is what is left of it - it's a control ;)...in shallow 1.5" pot (replanted once about 4 years ago)
did 5 years in the east, 3 years in west, 2 years in NE, abandoned...
i took 2 cuts from it may be in 3rd year in eastern window (clumped with 5): one big, one small.
2. big is below mama - no grow until 2 years ago-it's about double what it was (half time in eastern window, it did a few years in western, then finally settled in NE and produced a baby).
3. small - is front, that's the one in prior pic (see life story above).
4. about 4 years ago i replanted choked mama and removed some more clumps((5?) from it and gave them a new house and send them on extended vacation to NE balcony from may thru xgiving.
they stay the moistest only because of hi humidity outdoors and a larger pot. usually it's in the darkest spot, smtimes under the shelf. and look how it grew !?
it winters in NE window. they all do now (family reunion).
am considering giving mama a rejuve : cutting off and potting in fresh soil. ... when and if i get to it...
there're so many plants, there are other things to do....and i need a vacation and rejuve meself occasionally too!


 o
RE: Is this what an etiolated haworthia looks like?

Thank you for sharing how the same haw grows so differently in different lighting conditions.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Cacti & Succulents Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here