I got a Cotyledon ladismithiensis, bear paw succulent off of ebay. However, some of the petals do not look like the bear paw petals while some others do. They look like fuzzy jade petals. Am I doing something wrong? I did put a LED light over it if that helps with narrowing down the possibility. Is it not getting enough nutrients?

The petal I yanked out on the bottom is one of the jade like petals.

Thank you in advance!