Return to the Cacti & Succulents Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Haworthia cooperi v truncata name?

Posted by bikerdoc5968 6 SE MI (My Page) on
Sat, Apr 19, 14 at 18:03

I recently was given the Haworthia in the middle. I have had the flanking plants for some time. Those are labeled Haworthia cooperi v truncata, but I'm not certain the one on the right is, in fact, H. cooperi v truncata and I don't know the name of the middle one although it looks like the one on the left. The middle one has a brown flower while the one on the right is green. The middle one may be H. cooperi v cooperi or maybe v obtusa. So names, please for these threesome?????

Thanks,
Howard

This post was edited by bikerdoc5968 on Sun, Apr 20, 14 at 15:00


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Haworthia cooperi v truncata name?

From what I can see in the photo and comparing it to Bayer's "Haworthia Revisited", I would say that the one in the middle is indeed v. truncata. I cannot see the other two clearly, but I do see them well enough to say they are NOT v. truncata.


 o
RE: Haworthia cooperi v truncata name?

Sorry Howard. i don't think you have Haworthia cooperi v truncata in any of them.It grows in a tight mound of rounded leaves. Haworthias are as big a minefield as the Echeverias.


 o
RE: Haworthia name?

There are plants sold as Cooperi truncate from Arid Lands.com, looks like grown hard, look at the pics. Little flat rosettes of little roundish leaves. The middle and maybe the right look like the one I got from them.

I wonder if some of the plants called Cooperi out there may be mixes that have longer leaves but retain some roundness.

An of course, etolation is another factor for confusion. Plants grown in a greenhouse may look different.

This post was edited by noki on Mon, Apr 21, 14 at 1:16


 o
RE: Haworthia cooperi v truncata name?

I, certainly, am well aware of the effect our individual growing conditions can have on our plants. These all have been grown under similar conditions in a greenhouse with bright sunlight; I doubt any are etiolated, but then what do I know.

Here are some closer views of the plants in the same order as they originally appeared above. I have had this plant for several years and purchased it from someone, who I believe to be very reliable about naming plants. It is labeled as H. cooperi v truncata.

 photo DSC_Haw-cooperi2_zps1baf7148.jpg

This is the plant that I recently received and do not know for certain its name.

 photo DSC_Haw-cooperi1_zpsd252590d.jpg

I don't recall where I got this plant but it had no tag and just assumed it was H. cooperi v truncata.

 photo DSC_Haw-cooperi3_zps87b36328.jpg

This post was edited by bikerdoc5968 on Tue, Apr 22, 14 at 10:44


 o
RE: Haworthia cooperi v truncata name?

Hey gals and guys, how about some help, here...


 o
RE: Haworthia cooperi v truncata name?

I've honestly never been able to tell the difference between those three... I have a Cooperii that grows in a tight truncata-like fashion but I just call it a Cooperii to make it easy. :P


 o
RE: Haworthia cooperi v truncata name?

I struggle with these guys, and yet I would give up all other plants for my H. cooperi. Of the three the third sticks out to me just slightly, but I really don't know. It doesn't ring out to me as H. c. var. pilifera, and certainly not H. cooperi var. cooperi, but I can see the slight difference between it and the other two. It's so hard to tell. I just wish all the H. cooperi varieties could be pictured more accurately online, for the love of all things good.


 o
RE: Haworthia cooperi v truncata name?

I've seen them all separately from various sources. I really think the names are a matter of "in the eye of the beholder" cause I have seen supposed truncatas that don't look different... then obtusas that look really different, then just plain cooperii that look just like the others. I know. Could be a locational thing.


 o
RE: Haworthia cooperi v truncata name?

Howard, I think all 3 are H. cooperi v. truncata (or form of). The one Bev showed from Cactus art biz, I always thought was H. cooperi v. pilifera (although they list that as a synonym-also lumped in obtusa). Hard to say...as you know...difficult to ID, especially when it sometimes depends what area they came from to narrow it down.

The one book I own on Haworthia, have tuncata & pilifera listed separately & don't list obtusa at all.

Sorry I can't be of more help!


 o
RE: Haworthia cooperi v truncata name?

Rosemarie, you are always helpful just by offering your opinion. And thanks to all for your input, it is very much appreciated. I know all too well identification can be difficult at best with so many environmental influences. For me, knowing at least that it is Haworthia cooperi is great!


 o
RE: Haworthia cooperi v truncata name?

OUCH.... SPRUNG !!!!!!! Yes I did take it from the internet.. clever girl !!!!! I wasn't sure if I could get the page of my Haworthia book under far enough to scan well enough. Did get enough to see what it looks like. Sooo this plant pic was taken in an actual collection of one of our most prominent very long term Haworthia collectors. The plant I have came from him, but it's not currently pic worthy. There are about 18 different H.cooperi varieties depicted in the book


 o
RE: Haworthia cooperi v truncata name?

Bev, I'm not a "book" person but am interested in the title of the book you scanned for the above pics.

Also see you fancy Echeveria... would love to see as these are one of my favs, also.


 o
RE: Haworthia cooperi v truncata name?

It's "Haworthia for the collector" lotsa pretty pics, written by Rudolf Schulz one of the Echeveria Cultivars authors. Hawortha were my first succulent choice when I started collecting in 1970.. I still have about 500 of them. Echeverias came later around 1977, have specialisted in them since,Imported them from all over the world since 1980 but still love the Haworthias too. As I said in previous post, they have become the same minefields as the Echeverias.. Below one of 12 pics on my Facebook page. This is part of my main Echeveria collection. I have a 40ft x 40ft shed with more and the other species in it as well


 o
RE: Haworthia cooperi v truncata name?

Those are very nice, indeed. Thanks, Bev. Is it safe to assume you live someplace with lots of warmth and sun? I would love to visit your Facebook page to see your other pics...


 o
RE: Haworthia cooperi v truncata name?

Yes, a minefield, Bev!! =) Same books that I use for reference.

Fabulous shot of a GAZILLION Echeveria!! I LOVE it!
In which part of Australia do you live?


 o
RE: Haworthia cooperi v truncata name?

Wait a second, Rosemarie. Bev's profile says she lives in the USA. Are you saying this is Bev Spiller? If so, I believe she's in the Melbourne area, but I'll let her chime in. Now, I am confused...I'm going out to the greenhouse and stare at the plants until I recover!


 o
RE: Haworthia cooperi v truncata name?

Hee hee, Howard...revisit some (Echeveria) posts from last month. You were clear then who she was. :P But, Bev can tell us, too!


 o
RE: Haworthia cooperi v truncata name?

I thought that was her but when I looked at her profile as saw, "Lives in the USA", I got confused. Her handle looked familiar to me. I'm much better, now. I spent an hour just staring...LOL


 o
RE: Haworthia cooperi v truncata name?

Yup. I'm the Oz Bev !!!!!!! Haven't looked @ the the profile.since i joined years ago. I live in Queensland about 100 miles north of Brisbane, Echeverias luuuuuuuurve our Winter [ well what we get as Winter rarely a zero ] but struggle with the humidity in Summer. so it's always been a challenge to get what has survived the Summer on track again. Last season ... June to mid Nov.... they have been the best ever... as you can see by the pics. there is about 300 in that outside area..approx 12ft x 12ft I have a solarweave cover and shadecloth for the Nov / March period. Survival rate much better since I set that up. .EEEk tried to change the profile, but won't accept my address. will leave it as it is methinks


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Cacti & Succulents Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here