Photo #3

Flowers will tell all, but it looks like that last one definitely is, almost without a doubt, P. o.

I don't know,but I sure do like them.Colorations are gorgeous.
kathi

If they are all P. oviferum, what does G. amethystinum look like?

I thought that G.a. has slightly 'pointed' leaves? (not completely round) - but may be wrong?

Rina

IME, G. a., aside from having completely different flowers from P. o., also grows in more of a rosette fashion, not as here-and-there-leaved as P. o. is (although I'm sure there's a pattern there, it's just more subtle than G. a. has).

This post was edited by cactusmcharris on Fri, May 2, 14 at 17:23

spapa, I really like this whatever it is, they remind me of those candies "JORDAN ALMONDS" :P
Have a nice weekend everyone, Greg

These comments are too focused on the leaf shape, which is variable. The flowers are completely different between the 2: upward-facing and star-like, with wide-spreading red-tipped petals for Graptopetalum amethystinum; flower stalk nodding downward at the top (so the buds point downward), with huge sepals almost hiding the petals for Pachyphytum oviferum. In the 3rd photo we can see the red-tipped Graptopetalum flowers at the top left, so this proves what it is.

I'm confused by mine too. What do you think mine is?

That's a Pachyphytum flower, lh.

Awesome! It's currently my favorite - now to figure out how best to propagate. Two leaves have fallen off and failed to do anything. :(