To the best of my knowledge, they are different. I recently sent one of each to someone on GW. They are cultivars, I believe, of a cross between C. argentea and C. lactea.

I have 'E.T's Fingers' jade, also known as 'Skinny Fingers' jade, which is slightly different from the regular 'Gollum' in that there are more thin pointed leaves. These are cultivars of Crassula ovata, not a cross.

Here is my one of my 'E.T.'s Fingers' or 'Skinny Fingers' this morning.

Christopher

This is my other one.

Christopher

Christopher is correct on all counts.
These two Finger Jades - 'Gollum' and 'Skinny Fingers' - are slightly different in their leaf-characteristics, notably the slender tips on 'Skinny Fingers' and the trumpeted/flared suction-cup tips on 'Gollum.'

Josh

Thanks for the help. I will be looking for Gollum and any others I don't have. Have gotten the Cactus and succulent bug.

Once you are infected, no cure. Sorry. Join the club.

Christopher

Same plant but skinny leaves, as far as I know. I also have the plant. Norma

Went store hopping yesterday. Came back with 9 new sedums including Purple Emperor. Also got 2 new Jades. Not marked. With your help I knew the one I got yesterday was E.T. The big pot I had that was marked E.T. was Gollum. There is a big difference in the looks of the jades. The other jade was marked Aloe something. Why do they bother to mark these plants if they can't do it right. I am thankful for my Search station and very thankful for this Forum. Tony

Here's mine on hypertufa pot...gary

Gary...that's one fine 'Gollum' with an incredible "pot"...very subtle. Superb shaping.

Josh

Just got my first Jade Plant, and it's ET Fingers. Doing some research on how to care for it and happened on this post. Gary, your plant is stunning. What an inspiration! How many years are in that plant?

Yes, that is one fine specimen Gary.

I love the container, too.

Hi Deanna. This is about 3 years old in this pot. However she was a branch cutting from a 20 year old mom. Thank you. Gary

Heres my fav.